1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups vs BON Loyalty Rewards Programfor Shopify (2026)
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups focuses on lead generation and list growth through visually customizable popups, embedded forms, and gamified elements like spin wheels. It targets merchants seeking to expand their email and SMS marketing reach, emphasizing integration with major email marketing platforms and leveraging the Shop platform's user base for faster checkout. BON Loyalty Rewards Program, on the other hand, is designed for customer retention and repeat purchases through a comprehensive loyalty program featuring points, VIP tiers, and referrals. It aims at fostering long-term customer relationships and increasing customer lifetime value through omnichannel loyalty experiences. This difference in primary objective means that 1Click Popups is acquisition-focused, while BON Loyalty is retention-focused.
At a Glance
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
223 reviews
BON Loyalty Rewards Program
1,519 reviews
Detailed Overview
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
Grow your email & SMS list with email popups, embedded forms, spin wheel, and discount pop ups.
Key Features
- Build popups, forms, and announcements with a visual editor
- Capture sign ups with email popups, discount pop ups, and spin wheels
- Collect leads from Shop’s 100M+ users for faster checkout
- Generate unique discount codes and auto-apply them at checkout
- Sync to Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp & enable double opt-in
BON Loyalty Rewards Program
Ultimate customer loyalty & rewards solution for Retention & Growth: Point, VIP Tier & Referrals
Key Features
- Effortless Setup: Launch your customer loyalty point program in just minutes
- Maximize customer lifetime value with VIP Tier: accelerated points & rewards
- Integrate loyalty app at every touchpoint: homepage, product pages, and checkout
- Seamless loyalty across channels—reward online and in-store (POS) shoppers alike
- B2B Loyalty Program boosts wholesale sales with exclusive tiered rewards
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups4.9/5 BON Loyalty Rewards Program4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 223 | 1519 |
Reviews 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups223 BON Loyalty Rewards Program1519 | ||
| Primary Focus | Lead Generation | Customer Retention |
Primary Focus 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsLead Generation BON Loyalty Rewards ProgramCustomer Retention | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Customizable Popups & Forms | Loyalty Points & VIP Tiers |
Key Feature 1 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsCustomizable Popups & Forms BON Loyalty Rewards ProgramLoyalty Points & VIP Tiers | ||
| Key Integration | Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp | Omnichannel (Online & POS) |
Key Integration 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsShopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp BON Loyalty Rewards ProgramOmnichannel (Online & POS) | ||
| Target Merchant | New Stores & Marketing Driven Businesses | Established Stores with Existing Customer Base |
Target Merchant 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsNew Stores & Marketing Driven Businesses BON Loyalty Rewards ProgramEstablished Stores with Existing Customer Base | ||
| Value Proposition | Rapid list growth and improved signup rates | Increased Customer Lifetime Value and Brand Loyalty |
Value Proposition 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsRapid list growth and improved signup rates BON Loyalty Rewards ProgramIncreased Customer Lifetime Value and Brand Loyalty | ||
| Ease of Use (claimed) | Visual Editor for building popups | Effortless Setup in Minutes |
Ease of Use (claimed) 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsVisual Editor for building popups BON Loyalty Rewards ProgramEffortless Setup in Minutes | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing rapid email list growth and experimenting with different signup incentives like discount popups and spin wheels, 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups is the more suitable choice. Its integration with Shop and major email marketing platforms streamlines the lead capture and nurturing process. However, for businesses seeking to cultivate long-term customer loyalty and reward repeat purchases through a structured loyalty program, BON Loyalty Rewards Program offers a comprehensive solution with VIP tiers, referrals, and omnichannel support. While both have excellent ratings, BON's significantly higher number of reviews suggests a broader adoption and potentially more established track record.
Common Questions
Can both apps be used together?
Yes, but their functionalities overlap only slightly. Using both requires careful planning to avoid conflicting incentives or overwhelming customers with too many popups and loyalty programs.
Which app is easier to set up?
Both apps claim ease of setup, but BON Loyalty explicitly states 'Effortless Setup: Launch your customer loyalty point program in just minutes' suggesting potentially faster initial configuration compared to designing multiple popup variations in 1Click Popups.
Does either app offer a free plan?
The provided data doesn't specify whether either app offers a free plan. Further research on the Shopify App Store would be needed to confirm.
Which app is better for B2B?
BON Loyalty explicitly calls out a B2B Loyalty Program with tiered rewards, making it the better choice for wholesale or B2B businesses. 1Click Popups has no specific B2B features mentioned.
Can 1Click Popups create urgency like 'Limited Time Offer' notices?
The description mentions 'announcement popups' which could be used for limited-time offers, but BON Loyalty does not cover such functionalities.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store