1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups vs OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Testfor Shopify (2026)
Both 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups and OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test are strong contenders for Shopify merchants looking to enhance lead generation and conversion through pop-ups. 1Click Popups focuses on straightforward list building and leveraging the Shop app ecosystem, emphasizing email and SMS list growth through features like spin wheels, discount pop-ups, and Shop integration for lead capture. It positions itself as a user-friendly option for merchants who want to quickly grow their lists and integrate with popular email marketing platforms. OptiMonk, on the other hand, emphasizes AI-powered design and A/B testing, positioning itself as a more sophisticated, data-driven solution for conversion rate optimization. OptiMonk's core strength lies in its AI-driven popup creation and A/B testing capabilities, allowing merchants to optimize their popups for maximum revenue generation. While 1Click Popups offers customization, OptiMonk emphasizes ease of use through AI-powered design and drag-and-drop editing, allowing merchants to quickly create visually appealing and highly effective popups. The integration with the Shop app network is a unique selling point for 1Click Popups that is not offered by OptiMonk.
At a Glance
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
223 reviews
OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test
439 reviews
Detailed Overview
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
Grow your email & SMS list with email popups, embedded forms, spin wheel, and discount pop ups.
Key Features
- Build popups, forms, and announcements with a visual editor
- Capture sign ups with email popups, discount pop ups, and spin wheels
- Collect leads from Shop’s 100M+ users for faster checkout
- Generate unique discount codes and auto-apply them at checkout
- Sync to Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp & enable double opt-in
OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test
Popups that perfectly match your brand. Built in minutes. Designed to convert.
Key Features
- AI wizard: Create stunning, on-brand popups instantly with AI.
- Drag & drop editor: Fine-tune your popups anytime with our easy visual editor.
- A/B testing: Launch quick tests to find the best headlines, offers, or messages.
- Analytics: Optimize for real revenue, not just clicks or signups.
- Personalization: Show the right message to the right customer, every time.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups4.9/5 OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 223 | 439 |
Reviews 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups223 OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test439 | ||
| Key Focus | Email & SMS List Growth, Shop Integration | AI-Driven Conversion Optimization & A/B Testing |
Key Focus 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsEmail & SMS List Growth, Shop Integration OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI-Driven Conversion Optimization & A/B Testing | ||
| Design Approach | Visual Editor | AI Wizard & Drag & Drop Editor |
Design Approach 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsVisual Editor OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI Wizard & Drag & Drop Editor | ||
| Email Integrations | Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp | Not explicitly mentioned, implied |
Email Integrations 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsShopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestNot explicitly mentioned, implied | ||
| Unique Feature | Shop App Lead Capture | AI Popup Creation |
Unique Feature 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsShop App Lead Capture OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI Popup Creation | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants focused on simple email list building. | Merchants prioritizing data-driven CRO. |
Target Merchant 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsMerchants focused on simple email list building. OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestMerchants prioritizing data-driven CRO. | ||
| Ease of Use | Potentially Simple Setup | AI-assisted Easy Setup & Optimization |
Ease of Use 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsPotentially Simple Setup OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI-assisted Easy Setup & Optimization | ||
| Value Proposition | Fast list growth leveraging Shop App | High Conversion rates via AI & A/B testing |
Value Proposition 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsFast list growth leveraging Shop App OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestHigh Conversion rates via AI & A/B testing | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily focused on rapid email and SMS list growth, particularly those interested in leveraging the Shop app ecosystem, 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups is the stronger choice. Its focus on list building, integrations, and the unique Shop app lead capture feature make it a valuable tool for quickly expanding reach. On the other hand, if conversion rate optimization, data-driven decisions, and AI-powered design are paramount, OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test is the better option. Its A/B testing and AI capabilities provide a more sophisticated approach to popup marketing, albeit potentially requiring more investment in time and strategy.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use for a beginner?
OptiMonk is likely easier for a beginner due to its AI wizard that creates popups instantly. 1Click Popups' visual editor may require more manual design effort, though it is likely intuitive as well.
Which app offers better A/B testing capabilities?
OptiMonk explicitly mentions and emphasizes its A/B testing functionality as a key feature. 1Click Popups doesn't mention A/B testing.
Which app integrates with more email marketing platforms?
1Click Popups explicitly mentions integrations with Shopify Email, Klaviyo, and Mailchimp. OptiMonk implies integrations but doesn't specify which ones.
Does 1Click Popups work only for email collection, or also SMS?
1Click Popups allows collecting both emails and SMS numbers, as it states that it helps you grow your email & SMS list.
Which app is better for overall sales uplift?
While both apps aim to increase sales, OptiMonk, with its A/B testing and optimization features, is better suited for maximizing sales uplift via conversion rate optimization.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store