1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups vs Shopify Emailfor Shopify (2026)
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups positions itself as a growth-focused app specializing in lead capture through various interactive elements like popups, embedded forms, and spin wheels. Its core strength lies in its diverse lead capture methods and integration with Shop's user base for faster checkout. It explicitly targets merchants looking for advanced popup customization and multiple lead generation tools. Shopify Email, on the other hand, is Shopify's native email marketing solution. Its strength is its seamless integration with the Shopify platform, providing a straightforward email marketing experience. The key difference lies in their approach to lead capture and marketing automation. 1Click Popups focuses on attracting and capturing leads through interactive popups and leveraging external platforms (like Shop) and integrations with popular email marketing platforms like Klaviyo and Mailchimp. Shopify Email offers a more streamlined, internal approach, likely geared towards merchants seeking a simple and integrated email marketing solution without the complexities of third-party integrations for popup design and advanced lead capture. Shopify Email boasts significantly more reviews, suggesting wider adoption and familiarity, but with a slightly lower average rating, potentially due to a broader user base with varying levels of technical expertise.
At a Glance
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
223 reviews
Shopify Email
2,244 reviews
Detailed Overview
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
Grow your email & SMS list with email popups, embedded forms, spin wheel, and discount pop ups.
Key Features
- Build popups, forms, and announcements with a visual editor
- Capture sign ups with email popups, discount pop ups, and spin wheels
- Collect leads from Shop’s 100M+ users for faster checkout
- Generate unique discount codes and auto-apply them at checkout
- Sync to Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp & enable double opt-in
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.7/5 |
Rating 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups4.9/5 Shopify Email4.7/5 | ||
| Reviews | 223 | 2244 |
Reviews 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups223 Shopify Email2244 | ||
| Lead Capture Methods | Popups, Forms, Spin Wheel, Shop Integration | Email Only (Inferred) |
Lead Capture Methods 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsPopups, Forms, Spin Wheel, Shop Integration Shopify EmailEmail Only (Inferred) | ||
| Email Marketing Focus | Lead generation & List Growth | General Email Marketing |
Email Marketing Focus 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsLead generation & List Growth Shopify EmailGeneral Email Marketing | ||
| Customization | Visual Editor for Popups & Forms | Limited (Inferred) |
Customization 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsVisual Editor for Popups & Forms Shopify EmailLimited (Inferred) | ||
| Integration with Other Platforms | Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Shop | Shopify Email, Marketing Automations |
Integration with Other Platforms 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsKlaviyo, Mailchimp, Shop Shopify EmailShopify Email, Marketing Automations | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Growth-focused, needs diverse lead generation | Simple email marketing, ease of use priority |
Target Merchant Type 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsGrowth-focused, needs diverse lead generation Shopify EmailSimple email marketing, ease of use priority | ||
| Ease of Use | Moderate (due to advanced features) | High (due to native integration) |
Ease of Use 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsModerate (due to advanced features) Shopify EmailHigh (due to native integration) | ||
| Value Proposition | Aggressive list growth & higher conversion | Simplified email marketing within Shopify |
Value Proposition 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsAggressive list growth & higher conversion Shopify EmailSimplified email marketing within Shopify | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking aggressive list growth through interactive popups and advanced lead capture techniques, especially those aiming to leverage the Shop ecosystem or already using Klaviyo or Mailchimp, 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups offers a more feature-rich solution. Its visual editor allows for greater customization and control over the user experience.
Shopify Email is ideally suited for merchants prioritizing simplicity, seamless integration with the Shopify platform, and a straightforward email marketing experience. It's a good choice for stores just starting with email marketing or those with limited technical resources who want a native solution that doesn't require managing multiple integrations. While it may lack the advanced lead capture features of 1Click Popups, its ease of use and deep integration with Shopify make it a compelling option for many.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use for beginners?
Shopify Email is generally considered easier to use due to its native integration with the Shopify platform. 1Click Popups, with its advanced features and visual editor, may require a slightly steeper learning curve.
Which app offers more advanced lead capture options?
1Click Popups provides more advanced lead capture options, including email popups, discount pop ups, spin wheels, and integration with Shop's user base.
Which app is better for stores already using Klaviyo or Mailchimp?
1Click Popups is better for stores already using Klaviyo or Mailchimp, as it offers direct integration and synchronization with these platforms.
Does Shopify Email offer popup functionality?
The description does not explicitly state that Shopify Email offers popup functionality. 1Click Popups clearly emphasizes popups as a core feature.
Which app has a larger user base?
Shopify Email, with over 2200 reviews, has a significantly larger user base compared to 1Click Popups, which has just over 200.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store