Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing vs Enlistly Affiliate, Influencerfor Shopify (2026)
Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing and Enlistly Affiliate, Influencer both cater to Shopify merchants seeking to leverage affiliate programs to boost sales, traffic, and customer retention. However, their emphasis differs slightly. Affiliatly appears to be geared towards a broader affiliate marketing approach, focusing on ease of use, customization, and automatic Shopify integration, making it suitable for merchants of various sizes seeking a plug-and-play solution. They highlight flexibility in tracking and commission structures. Enlistly, conversely, leans more into influencer marketing alongside traditional affiliate programs, emphasizing influencer onboarding, custom marketing materials for affiliates, and flexible payment options, potentially targeting merchants keen to engage with social media influencers and those seeking more sophisticated affiliate management tools. The key difference lies in the marketing focus. Affiliatly presents a more general affiliate marketing solution with broad tracking and commission customization. It prioritizes ease of setup and seamless integration for users without extensive technical expertise. Enlistly, on the other hand, caters to merchants wanting to combine influencer marketing with traditional affiliate programs and offer flexible payment options, potentially appealing to those with an existing influencer network or those looking to build one. Both apps have the same number of reviews, but Enlistly boasts a perfect 5/5 rating, which suggests very satisfied users, though the sample size is identical to Affiliatly.
At a Glance
Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing
63 reviews
Enlistly Affiliate, Influencer
63 reviews
Detailed Overview
Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing
Increase traffic, revenue and customer retention with an affiliate program.
Key Features
- Seamless and automatic integration with Shopify, no coding needed
- Easy affiliate recruitment and onboarding through post checkout invitation
- Track your affiliate's performance with stats and in-app analytics
- Real-time click and commission tracking and 3rd-party tracking
- Set rules and custom commission per product
Enlistly Affiliate, Influencer
Boost Sales with an Automated Affiliate Platform to Manage Influencer & Referral Marketing Programs
Key Features
- Boost your affiliate program engagement with custom branded affiliate onboarding
- Master influencer marketing with custom affiliate links, codes and referral URLs
- Share marketing data with your affiliates, influencer & boost affiliate success
- Promote affiliate programs with affiliate marketing & influencer marketing tools
- Use a payment method you and your affiliate / influencer prefer & pay with ease
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.2/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing4.2/5 Enlistly Affiliate, Influencer5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 63 | 63 |
Reviews Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing63 Enlistly Affiliate, Influencer63 | ||
| Primary Focus | General Affiliate Marketing, Customization | Affiliate & Influencer Marketing, Flexible Payments |
Primary Focus Affiliatly Affiliate MarketingGeneral Affiliate Marketing, Customization Enlistly Affiliate, InfluencerAffiliate & Influencer Marketing, Flexible Payments | ||
| Ease of Use | Simple setup, no coding required | Automated Platform |
Ease of Use Affiliatly Affiliate MarketingSimple setup, no coding required Enlistly Affiliate, InfluencerAutomated Platform | ||
| Integration | Seamless Shopify Integration | Custom Affiliate Links & URLs |
Integration Affiliatly Affiliate MarketingSeamless Shopify Integration Enlistly Affiliate, InfluencerCustom Affiliate Links & URLs | ||
| Commission Structure | Custom rules and commissions per product/affiliate | Flexible Commissions |
Commission Structure Affiliatly Affiliate MarketingCustom rules and commissions per product/affiliate Enlistly Affiliate, InfluencerFlexible Commissions | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants needing a simple, customizable affiliate program | Merchants focusing on influencer marketing & flexible payments |
Target Merchant Affiliatly Affiliate MarketingMerchants needing a simple, customizable affiliate program Enlistly Affiliate, InfluencerMerchants focusing on influencer marketing & flexible payments | ||
| Value Proposition | Easy setup, flexible tracking, and broad affiliate recruitment | Combined affiliate & influencer management with payment flexibility |
Value Proposition Affiliatly Affiliate MarketingEasy setup, flexible tracking, and broad affiliate recruitment Enlistly Affiliate, InfluencerCombined affiliate & influencer management with payment flexibility | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing ease of use and a straightforward affiliate program with solid Shopify integration, Affiliatly Affiliate Marketing is a good choice. Its focus on customization and automatic integration caters to a wider range of merchants, especially those without significant technical expertise. However, if influencer marketing and flexible payment options are paramount, Enlistly Affiliate, Influencer is the better option. Its focus on custom affiliate links and codes, coupled with its emphasis on influencer onboarding, makes it ideal for merchants building influencer programs or those who want to offer various payment methods to their affiliates. Enlistly's perfect rating, while based on the same number of reviews as Affiliatly, suggests higher user satisfaction and potential ease of use, however both could benefit from a larger review sample to truly understand the long term viability.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up for a beginner?
Affiliatly is likely easier to set up for beginners due to its emphasis on simple setup and no-code integration. Enlistly, while automated, may require more initial configuration for influencer onboarding and payment methods.
Which app is better for managing a large number of affiliates?
Both apps likely have features to manage a large number of affiliates. However, Enlistly's features geared towards influencer marketing, like custom affiliate links and onboarding, could be beneficial for managing larger influencer networks. Affiliatly's reporting features may also be beneficial for larger numbers of affiliates.
Which app offers more flexibility in commission structures?
Both apps offer flexible commission structures. Affiliatly explicitly mentions custom rules and commissions per product or affiliate, while Enlistly highlights flexible commissions in general. A trial period for each may be valuable to determine suitability for specific commission needs.
Which app is more focused on tracking affiliate performance?
Both apps offer affiliate performance tracking. Affiliatly lists 'Track your affiliate's performance with stats and in-app analytics' while Enlistly focuses on sharing 'marketing data with affiliates'. It's not possible to say for sure which is more robust based on the provided descriptions.
Does either app offer fraud prevention features?
Neither description explicitly mentions fraud prevention features. Merchants should inquire with each app provider about available fraud detection or prevention mechanisms before committing to either app.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store