Aimerce First‑Party Pixel vs Bily ‑ CAPI Ai Trackingfor Shopify (2026)
Aimerce First-Party Pixel and Bily - CAPI Ai Tracking both aim to improve ad performance by providing better tracking, but they differ significantly in approach and user perception, at least according to available data. Aimerce, with a perfect 5/5 rating from 59 reviews, suggests a highly satisfied user base, likely focused on first-party data strategies. Bily, on the other hand, focuses on circumventing tracking limitations (iOS14 and ad blockers) using Conversion API, boasting a 3.8/5 rating based on only 13 reviews. Bily aims to give merchants access to more data by enabling 12 trackable events compared to the standard 6. This suggests Bily targets merchants actively struggling with ad tracking accuracy and are seeking a solution to maintain data flow, potentially at the expense of ease of use, given the lower rating.
At a Glance
Aimerce First‑Party Pixel
59 reviews
Bily ‑ CAPI Ai Tracking
13 reviews
Detailed Overview
Bily ‑ CAPI Ai Tracking
Feed your Facebook pixel with accurate data using Conversion API
Key Features
- Manage multiple pixels (Facebook, Google Analytics, Tiktok etc) in one click
- Bypass iOS-14 & ad blockers with Conversion API for Facebook, Google, TikTok
- Track 12 different events instead of 6
- Track every conversion Post-IOS14 with Conversion API
- We integrate with all Shopify theme
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 3.8/5 |
Rating Aimerce First‑Party Pixel5/5 Bily ‑ CAPI Ai Tracking3.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 59 | 13 |
Reviews Aimerce First‑Party Pixel59 Bily ‑ CAPI Ai Tracking13 | ||
| Focus | First-Party Pixel | Conversion API (CAPI) |
Focus Aimerce First‑Party PixelFirst-Party Pixel Bily ‑ CAPI Ai TrackingConversion API (CAPI) | ||
| Bypassing iOS14/Adblockers | Not explicitly mentioned | Yes |
Bypassing iOS14/Adblockers Aimerce First‑Party PixelNot explicitly mentioned Bily ‑ CAPI Ai TrackingYes | ||
| Number of Trackable Events | Unknown | 12 |
Number of Trackable Events Aimerce First‑Party PixelUnknown Bily ‑ CAPI Ai Tracking12 | ||
| Pixel Management | Focus on First-Party | Manage multiple pixels (Facebook, Google Analytics, Tiktok etc) |
Pixel Management Aimerce First‑Party PixelFocus on First-Party Bily ‑ CAPI Ai TrackingManage multiple pixels (Facebook, Google Analytics, Tiktok etc) | ||
| Ease of Use (Inferred) | Likely higher, based on rating | Potentially lower, based on rating |
Ease of Use (Inferred) Aimerce First‑Party PixelLikely higher, based on rating Bily ‑ CAPI Ai TrackingPotentially lower, based on rating | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants prioritizing first-party data strategies. | Merchants concerned about data loss due to iOS14/Adblockers, needing multi-pixel management. |
Target Merchant Type Aimerce First‑Party PixelMerchants prioritizing first-party data strategies. Bily ‑ CAPI Ai TrackingMerchants concerned about data loss due to iOS14/Adblockers, needing multi-pixel management. | ||
| Value Proposition | Unknown without additional info, but assumed to be more robust first-party data. | Recover lost conversion data and scale ads post-iOS14. |
Value Proposition Aimerce First‑Party PixelUnknown without additional info, but assumed to be more robust first-party data. Bily ‑ CAPI Ai TrackingRecover lost conversion data and scale ads post-iOS14. | ||
Our Verdict
Aimerce First-Party Pixel, given its perfect rating and larger number of reviews, seems the safer choice for merchants seeking a reliable and well-received solution, particularly if they are already prioritizing first-party data. However, its feature set remains largely unknown. If a merchant is significantly impacted by iOS14 and ad blockers, and is dealing with multiple pixels across Facebook, Google Analytics, and TikTok, Bily - CAPI Ai Tracking might be worth exploring despite the lower rating. The promise of bypassing tracking limitations and tracking more events can be crucial for maintaining data accuracy and ad performance. The lower rating suggests merchants proceed with caution and carefully test the app's functionality.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use?
Based on ratings and review count, Aimerce First-Party Pixel likely offers a smoother user experience. The higher rating typically indicates a more intuitive and less problematic setup process.
Which app is better for dealing with iOS14 updates?
Bily - CAPI Ai Tracking specifically addresses iOS14 and ad blocker limitations through Conversion API, making it the better choice for merchants heavily impacted by these changes.
Which app supports multiple pixels?
Bily - CAPI Ai Tracking explicitly states that it supports managing multiple pixels across different platforms like Facebook, Google Analytics, and TikTok. Aimerce does not mention this feature.
Which app offers better data insights?
While Aimerce's strength is unclear without feature details, Bily claims to track 12 events compared to the standard 6, potentially providing more granular data insights, especially concerning conversions.
Which app is better for merchants new to Conversion API?
Bily explicitly positions itself as easy-to-use for implementing Conversion API, even though it has the lower rating overall, it should be considered for merchants who are not familiar with CAPI implementation.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store