Amazon MCF and Buy with Prime and Fulfillrite Order Fulfillment both offer third-party logistics (3PL) solutions for Shopify merchants in 2026, but cater to different needs. Amazon MCF leverages Amazon's existing infrastructure, targeting merchants who already use Amazon's fulfillment network and wish to streamline operations across both platforms. It emphasizes fast, reliable delivery using Amazon's fulfillment network, particularly attractive to merchants in the US looking to boost conversion with Buy with Prime. The app simplifies catalog management and order placement directly within Shopify, extending Amazon's reach to Shopify stores. Fulfillrite Order Fulfillment, on the other hand, doesn't explicitly mention reliance on existing Amazon infrastructure, suggesting it's likely a more general 3PL solution. While it boasts a perfect 5/5 rating, it has a smaller number of reviews compared to Amazon MCF, indicating a potentially smaller user base or a newer entrant. Without specific feature details beyond being a 3PL, it's harder to pinpoint its unique strengths, but its high rating suggests strong customer satisfaction with its overall service. Merchants who aren't heavily invested in the Amazon ecosystem might find Fulfillrite a more independent solution.
56 reviews
34 reviews
Use Amazon MCF to fulfill your orders
| Rating | 4.6/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Amazon MCF and Buy with Prime4.6/5 Fulfillrite Order Fulfillment5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 56 | 34 |
Reviews Amazon MCF and Buy with Prime56 Fulfillrite Order Fulfillment34 | ||
| Fulfillment Network | Amazon | Unspecified |
Fulfillment Network Amazon MCF and Buy with PrimeAmazon Fulfillrite Order FulfillmentUnspecified | ||
| Buy with Prime | Supported (US Only) | Not Supported |
Buy with Prime Amazon MCF and Buy with PrimeSupported (US Only) Fulfillrite Order FulfillmentNot Supported | ||
| Primary Focus | Leveraging Amazon Infrastructure | General 3PL |
Primary Focus Amazon MCF and Buy with PrimeLeveraging Amazon Infrastructure Fulfillrite Order FulfillmentGeneral 3PL | ||
| SKU Management | Improved SKU Management within Shopify | Unspecified |
SKU Management Amazon MCF and Buy with PrimeImproved SKU Management within Shopify Fulfillrite Order FulfillmentUnspecified | ||
| Geographic Focus | US and UK | Unspecified |
Geographic Focus Amazon MCF and Buy with PrimeUS and UK Fulfillrite Order FulfillmentUnspecified | ||
| Value Proposition | Fast, reliable delivery using Amazon's network; Buy with Prime boost | Potentially high-quality 3PL service (based on perfect rating) |
Value Proposition Amazon MCF and Buy with PrimeFast, reliable delivery using Amazon's network; Buy with Prime boost Fulfillrite Order FulfillmentPotentially high-quality 3PL service (based on perfect rating) | ||
For merchants heavily invested in Amazon's ecosystem, utilizing Amazon MCF and Buy with Prime seems like the more strategic choice. The ability to manage inventory and fulfillment directly from Shopify, while leveraging Amazon's speed and reliability, offers a clear advantage, especially for US-based sellers wanting to utilize Buy with Prime.
However, if a merchant is looking for a more independent 3PL provider, and isn't already tied to Amazon's infrastructure, Fulfillrite might be a better option. Its perfect rating, though based on fewer reviews, suggests a high level of customer satisfaction. More research is needed to determine Fulfillrite's specific geographic coverage and integration capabilities.
Amazon MCF and Buy with Prime is likely the better choice, as it leverages your existing Amazon inventory and fulfillment network.
Based on the provided information, Fulfillrite does not offer Buy with Prime functionality.
Based on the number of reviews (56 vs 34), Amazon MCF and Buy with Prime appears to be more established and widely used.
Amazon MCF supports order fulfillment in the UK, making it the preferable option for UK-based sellers based on the data provided.
Fulfillrite would be the better choice if you're looking for a 3PL solution that is not tied to Amazon's infrastructure and services.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store