Appstle℠ Memberships vs Recurpay: Subscriptions appfor Shopify (2026)
Appstle℠ Memberships and Recurpay: Subscriptions app, both aimed at boosting recurring revenue on Shopify, take different approaches. Appstle℠ Memberships positions itself as an end-to-end *membership* solution, emphasizing comprehensive member plans, perks like discounts and exclusive access, and automated billing. This makes it attractive to businesses looking to build a loyal member base beyond simple subscriptions. Recurpay: Subscriptions app, on the other hand, focuses squarely on *subscriptions*, with a strong emphasis on customer self-service through its customer portal and 24/7 human support, and upfront payment options. Appstle℠ Membership's strength lies in its detailed membership management features, including tiered perks, smart member tagging, and a customizable member portal. Recurpay: Subscription's strength comes from its subscription-centric feature set like customer self-management tools, upfront payment options, developer-friendly setup with API access, and its commitment to immediate and comprehensive human support. This positions Recurpay as a choice for subscription based businesses with complex requirements or high support needs. Both offer features for automated billing and management, falling into the subscription, customer loyalty, and loyalty and rewards categories on Shopify.
At a Glance
Appstle℠ Memberships
492 reviews
Recurpay: Subscriptions app
400 reviews
Detailed Overview
Appstle℠ Memberships
Only end-to-end memberships tool covering member plans, perks (e.g. discounts, access), and billing
Key Features
- Intuitive merchant UI to offer and manage membership plans within minutes
- Tiered & customized member perks (discounted pricing, shipping benefits, access)
- Smart member tagging, to associate the right perks with the right member plans
- Automated member billing at pre-chosen intervals that can be customized
- Comprehensive and customizable member portal. Robust APIs and webhooks
Recurpay: Subscriptions app
Subscriptions app to unlock recurring revenue with intuitive customer portal & 24/7 human support.
Key Features
- Support upfront and pay-as-you-go plans with flexible renewal, 24/7 live support
- Design custom subscription widget for your brand in few clicks with full access.
- Let customers manage subscriptions: skip, edit, reschedule, or cancel anytime
- Renew subscriptions on a specific day or date, offer tiered discount, free gifts
- Developer-friendly setup with full access to APIs, code & technical support
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Appstle℠ Memberships4.9/5 Recurpay: Subscriptions app5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 492 | 400 |
Reviews Appstle℠ Memberships492 Recurpay: Subscriptions app400 | ||
| Focus | Memberships (plans, perks, billing) | Subscriptions (recurring payments, customer portal) |
Focus Appstle℠ MembershipsMemberships (plans, perks, billing) Recurpay: Subscriptions appSubscriptions (recurring payments, customer portal) | ||
| Customer Support | Merchant success team (minutes away) | 24/7 live human support |
Customer Support Appstle℠ MembershipsMerchant success team (minutes away) Recurpay: Subscriptions app24/7 live human support | ||
| Key Differentiator | Tiered member perks & member tagging | Customer self-management features & upfront payments |
Key Differentiator Appstle℠ MembershipsTiered member perks & member tagging Recurpay: Subscriptions appCustomer self-management features & upfront payments | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses building exclusive member communities | Businesses focused on subscription models with high support needs |
Target Merchant Appstle℠ MembershipsBusinesses building exclusive member communities Recurpay: Subscriptions appBusinesses focused on subscription models with high support needs | ||
| API Access | Robust APIs and webhooks | Full access to APIs, code & technical support |
API Access Appstle℠ MembershipsRobust APIs and webhooks Recurpay: Subscriptions appFull access to APIs, code & technical support | ||
| Payment flexibility | Automated member billing at pre-chosen intervals | Supports upfront and pay-as-you-go plans |
Payment flexibility Appstle℠ MembershipsAutomated member billing at pre-chosen intervals Recurpay: Subscriptions appSupports upfront and pay-as-you-go plans | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking to create a robust membership program with tiered benefits and exclusive access, Appstle℠ Memberships is the stronger choice. Its focus on membership management and member perks makes it well-suited for building a loyal, engaged customer base beyond simple subscription models. However, for businesses with complex subscription needs, high demand for customer support, or a focus on payment flexibility including upfront payments, Recurpay: Subscriptions app is the better option. Its emphasis on customer self-service and readily available human support are key differentiators for merchants who prioritize a hands-on approach to subscription management. Recurpay is slightly better for those who need code access and customization.
Common Questions
What is the main difference between a membership and a subscription as offered by these apps?
While both involve recurring payments, Appstle℠ Memberships focuses on creating a more exclusive club-like experience with tiered benefits (perks) and access control. Recurpay: Subscriptions focuses purely on managing recurring payments for product or service subscriptions, with less emphasis on exclusive perks.
Which app offers better customer support?
Recurpay: Subscriptions app explicitly advertises 24/7 live human support. Appstle℠ Memberships describes their 'merchant success team' as being 'minutes away'. While both aim for quick response times, Recurpay's claim of 24/7 human support suggests a more comprehensive support system, assuming they deliver on the promise.
Which app is easier to integrate with existing systems via API?
Both apps boast robust API offerings. However, Recurpay: Subscription's description of 'full access to APIs, code & technical support' suggests a more developer-friendly approach, especially for merchants with complex integration needs. Appstle℠ Memberships says 'Robust APIs and webhooks' but does not guarantee 'full access'.
If I want to offer free gifts to my members/subscribers, which app is better?
Recurpay: Subscriptions app explicitly mentions the ability to 'offer tiered discount, free gifts'. Appstle℠ Memberships does not specifically mention free gifts as a perk, although it could potentially be implemented as a custom perk.
Which app is more suitable for a business that wants to offer different tiers of membership/subscription with varying benefits?
Appstle℠ Memberships explicitly states the ability to offer 'Tiered & customized member perks', making it the better choice for businesses that want to offer different levels of membership with varying benefits. Recurpay supports 'tiered discount' but does not advertise flexible tiers of membership
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store