Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar vs OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Testfor Shopify (2026)
Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar and OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test are both Shopify apps designed to increase sales and grow email/SMS lists using onsite marketing techniques like popups and announcement bars. Attrac positions itself as an all-in-one solution, offering a wide range of campaign types beyond just popups, including announcement bars, upsell/cross-sell offers, and product bundles. This makes it appealing to merchants looking for a comprehensive marketing toolkit within a single app. Attrac boasts a slightly higher rating. OptiMonk, on the other hand, emphasizes ease of use and intelligent optimization through its AI-powered popup builder. Its focus is on creating highly converting popups tailored to a merchant's brand through AI or a drag-and-drop editor, along with a strong emphasis on A/B testing and analytics, allowing for data-driven optimization of campaigns. OptiMonk has a higher number of reviews, possibly indicating a larger user base or longer presence in the market. OptiMonk seems positioned towards digital marketers or those wanting more control over A/B testing and popup personalization.
At a Glance
Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar
301 reviews
OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test
439 reviews
Detailed Overview
Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar
Boost sales with high-converting announcement bars, banners, cross-sell offers, and discount pop ups
Key Features
- Top bar types: multi-announcement bar, countdown timer bar, & free shipping bar.
- Upsell and cross-sell campaigns to boost average order value (AOV) & sales.
- Diverse popup types such as opt-in popup, discount popup, & free shipping popup.
- Header newsletter signup forms & exit-intent popup windows for email marketing.
- Embedded banners to display store alerts on product pages & in the cart drawer.
OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test
Popups that perfectly match your brand. Built in minutes. Designed to convert.
Key Features
- AI wizard: Create stunning, on-brand popups instantly with AI.
- Drag & drop editor: Fine-tune your popups anytime with our easy visual editor.
- A/B testing: Launch quick tests to find the best headlines, offers, or messages.
- Analytics: Optimize for real revenue, not just clicks or signups.
- Personalization: Show the right message to the right customer, every time.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar4.9/5 OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 301 | 439 |
Reviews Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar301 OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test439 | ||
| Core Focus | All-in-one onsite marketing (popups, bars, offers) | AI-powered Popup building & CRO |
Core Focus Attrac Popup, Announcement BarAll-in-one onsite marketing (popups, bars, offers) OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI-powered Popup building & CRO | ||
| Ease of Use | Easy to set up, fully customizable | AI wizard for quick setup, Drag & drop editor |
Ease of Use Attrac Popup, Announcement BarEasy to set up, fully customizable OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI wizard for quick setup, Drag & drop editor | ||
| Key Features | Diverse popup types, announcement bars, upsell/cross-sell | AI popup creation, A/B testing, Advanced analytics |
Key Features Attrac Popup, Announcement BarDiverse popup types, announcement bars, upsell/cross-sell OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestAI popup creation, A/B testing, Advanced analytics | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants needing a broad marketing toolkit | Merchants focused on data-driven popup optimization |
Target Merchant Attrac Popup, Announcement BarMerchants needing a broad marketing toolkit OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestMerchants focused on data-driven popup optimization | ||
| Value Proposition | Comprehensive marketing campaigns in one app | High-converting popups tailored with AI & A/B testing |
Value Proposition Attrac Popup, Announcement BarComprehensive marketing campaigns in one app OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestHigh-converting popups tailored with AI & A/B testing | ||
| A/B Testing | Not explicitly mentioned | Yes, built-in A/B testing features |
A/B Testing Attrac Popup, Announcement BarNot explicitly mentioned OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B TestYes, built-in A/B testing features | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking a single, comprehensive solution for various onsite marketing needs, including announcement bars, upsell offers, and popups, Attrac Popup, Announcement Bar seems the better choice. Its wide array of features caters to a broader set of marketing activities. This is ideal for merchants who prioritize convenience and breadth of functionality.
However, if a merchant's primary focus is on highly optimized, brand-specific popups and A/B testing is a crucial part of their strategy, OptiMonk: Popup, CRO, A/B Test is likely the superior option. Its AI-powered builder, drag-and-drop editor, and robust analytics offer a more focused approach to popup optimization and conversion rate improvement. Especially appealing to e-commerce marketers who value granular control over design and performance.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use for a beginner?
Both apps claim to be easy to use. OptiMonk leverages AI for faster initial setup, whereas Attrac is intuitive for general setup.
Which app offers more customization options?
OptiMonk offers robust AI-driven and drag-and-drop customization for popups, while Attrac focuses on customizing all aspects of the various campaigns it offers (announcement bars, cross-sells, etc.). The 'more' depends on what needs customization.
Which app is better for growing an email list?
Both apps offer email capture popups. Attrac mentions header newsletter signup forms, which may be an advantage. OptiMonk's A/B testing features might lead to better-performing popups and thus faster email list growth.
Does either app integrate with SMS marketing platforms?
Attrac specifically mentions SMS subscribe popups, making it a better choice if that is a priority. OptiMonk does not explicitly mention SMS integrations in the provided description.
Which app is better for upselling and cross-selling?
Attrac directly features upsell and cross-sell campaigns and frequently bought together bundles, whereas OptiMonk's strength lies in general conversion rate optimization through popup design and targeting. Attrac would be preferred for this.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store