BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty vs Keep on Hold Wishlistfor Shopify (2026)
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty and Keep on Hold Wishlist both aim to improve customer loyalty, but they approach it from fundamentally different angles. BLOY focuses on building comprehensive loyalty programs with points, rewards, VIP tiers, and referral programs. Its positioning is geared towards larger Shopify stores that are serious about creating a structured loyalty experience to drive repeat purchases and increase customer lifetime value. In contrast, Keep on Hold Wishlist offers a simpler, more focused solution centered around wishlists and 'save for later' functionality. It targets merchants looking for a quick and easy way to capture customer interest and reduce abandoned carts, primarily through wishlists and save-for-later features.
At a Glance
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty
267 reviews
Keep on Hold Wishlist
5 reviews
Detailed Overview
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty
Build a loyalty program to increase retention with points, rewards, VIP tiers, membership and POS.
Key Features
- Build and scale a customer loyalty program with points, rewards, and VIP tiers
- Reward purchases and actions with loyalty points customers actually redeem
- Design VIP tiers and memberships to drive higher repeat purchase behavior
- Activate referral rewards to grow retention-led customer acquisition
- Launch and optimize your loyalty program with confidence and 24/7 support
Keep on Hold Wishlist
Keep on Hold adds Save-for-Later button to items on cart page and a wishlist button to product pages
Key Features
- Save removed cart items from the Cart page. Product page wishlist button.
- Fast and compatible with all themes. Install and enable in a just a few minutes.
- Optional login for shoppers to save their wishlist across devices.
- Reports of cart and wishlist transactions and populate products on you store.
- Boost Sales & Loyalty by allowing your shoppers to save items for later.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.3/5 |
Rating BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty5/5 Keep on Hold Wishlist4.3/5 | ||
| Reviews | 267 | 5 |
Reviews BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty267 Keep on Hold Wishlist5 | ||
| Focus | Comprehensive Loyalty Program (points, rewards, VIP tiers) | Wishlists and 'Save for Later' functionality |
Focus BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyComprehensive Loyalty Program (points, rewards, VIP tiers) Keep on Hold WishlistWishlists and 'Save for Later' functionality | ||
| Target Merchant | Larger stores seeking structured loyalty programs | Smaller stores needing quick wishlist/abandoned cart solutions |
Target Merchant BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyLarger stores seeking structured loyalty programs Keep on Hold WishlistSmaller stores needing quick wishlist/abandoned cart solutions | ||
| Complexity | More complex setup and management | Simple and easy to install and enable |
Complexity BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyMore complex setup and management Keep on Hold WishlistSimple and easy to install and enable | ||
| Pricing (Not Provided) | Likely higher, reflecting feature richness | Likely lower, reflecting focused functionality |
Pricing (Not Provided) BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyLikely higher, reflecting feature richness Keep on Hold WishlistLikely lower, reflecting focused functionality | ||
| Customer Support | 24/7 Support | Not Mentioned |
Customer Support BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty24/7 Support Keep on Hold WishlistNot Mentioned | ||
| Key Functionality | Points, Rewards, VIP Tiers, Referrals | Wishlists, Save for Later, Analytics |
Key Functionality BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyPoints, Rewards, VIP Tiers, Referrals Keep on Hold WishlistWishlists, Save for Later, Analytics | ||
| Integration | POS integration Mentioned | Shopify Login integration |
Integration BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyPOS integration Mentioned Keep on Hold WishlistShopify Login integration | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For established Shopify stores seeking a robust, fully-fledged loyalty program with points, rewards, VIP tiers, and comprehensive customer support, BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty is the clear choice. Its higher rating and significantly larger number of reviews suggest strong user satisfaction and reliability. However, for smaller Shopify stores, or those just starting out with loyalty initiatives, Keep on Hold Wishlist provides a simpler and more accessible solution for addressing abandoned carts and capturing customer interest through wishlists. It's a more straightforward app for a focused need, which could translate to ease of use and lower cost.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Keep on Hold Wishlist likely offers a simpler setup process due to its focus on a single feature: wishlists. BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty, with its comprehensive loyalty program features, will likely require more configuration.
Which app is better for increasing repeat purchases?
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty is specifically designed to drive repeat purchases through its points, rewards, and VIP tier system. Keep on Hold Wishlist can contribute to repeat purchases by allowing customers to easily save items for later, but it's not its primary function.
Which app provides more detailed analytics?
Keep on Hold Wishlist offers analytics on cart and wishlist transactions. BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty, while not explicitly stated, likely provides analytics on loyalty program performance (points earned, rewards redeemed, etc.) due to its focus on optimization. The specific type of analytics differs based on each app's core function.
Which app is better for a brick-and-mortar store with a Shopify POS system?
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty explicitly mentions POS integration, making it a better choice for brick-and-mortar stores using Shopify POS who want to integrate their online and offline loyalty programs.
Which app focuses more on acquiring new customers?
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty includes referral rewards as a feature, specifically aimed at customer acquisition. Keep on Hold Wishlist primarily focuses on retaining existing customers and capturing their interest, rather than acquisition.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store