Bony: Checkout Rules & COD vs Checkout Plusfor Shopify (2026)
Bony: Checkout Rules & COD and Checkout Plus are both Shopify apps that enhance the checkout experience, but they cater to different needs. Bony focuses primarily on checkout validation and rule-based control over payment and shipping methods, with a strong emphasis on fraud prevention and order reliability. Its strength lies in its granular control over payment options like COD, specifically tailoring them to regions, products, or customer segments. This makes it ideal for merchants prioritizing risk management and precise control over order fulfillment. Checkout Plus, on the other hand, offers a broader suite of customization options extending beyond just payment and shipping rules. It focuses on boosting conversions and enhancing the customer journey by enabling upsells, showcasing social proof elements (reviews, UGC, trust badges), gathering customer information through gift messages and surveys, and customizing post-purchase pages. This makes it a better fit for merchants who want a more comprehensive solution to optimize the entire checkout funnel, aiming to increase AOV and foster customer engagement. While both apps allow for payment and shipping method customizations based on rules, Bony's core value proposition is preventing fraud and ensuring order reliability, while Checkout Plus prioritizes increasing sales and improving customer communication throughout the entire buying process, extending beyond the initial checkout stage.
At a Glance
Bony: Checkout Rules & COD
21 reviews
Checkout Plus
52 reviews
Detailed Overview
Bony: Checkout Rules & COD
Rename, reorder, hide payment and shipping methods, validate block checkout page with few clicks
Key Features
- Hide payment methods like COD for products, regions, or customers
- Set custom payment rules based on order value, discounts, or tags
- Create shipping rules by weight, price, destination, or conditions
- Block checkout with minimum order value or product restrictions
- Block risky COD and reduce fraud with smart checkout conditions
Checkout Plus
Customize Your Checkout: Free Gifts, Trust Badges, Upsells, Messages, Payment Customizations & Rules
Key Features
- Upsells: Sell more at checkout increasing average order value (AOV)
- Social Proof: Establish trust with Reviews, UGC & Trust Badges at Checkout
- Gift Messages, Delivery Instructions & Surveys: Collect information at Checkout
- Post Purchase: Thank you, Order Status & Customer Account Customizations
- Payment, Shipping Methods & Order Limits: customize at checkout with conditions
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Bony: Checkout Rules & COD5/5 Checkout Plus4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 21 | 52 |
Reviews Bony: Checkout Rules & COD21 Checkout Plus52 | ||
| Core Focus | Checkout Rules & Fraud Prevention | Checkout Customization & Conversion Optimization |
Core Focus Bony: Checkout Rules & CODCheckout Rules & Fraud Prevention Checkout PlusCheckout Customization & Conversion Optimization | ||
| Key Feature Highlight | Granular COD Control | Upsells & Social Proof |
Key Feature Highlight Bony: Checkout Rules & CODGranular COD Control Checkout PlusUpsells & Social Proof | ||
| Target Merchant | High-risk orders, COD concerns | Optimizing AOV, Customer Engagement |
Target Merchant Bony: Checkout Rules & CODHigh-risk orders, COD concerns Checkout PlusOptimizing AOV, Customer Engagement | ||
| Post-Purchase Customization | No | Yes (Thank You, Order Status, Customer Account) |
Post-Purchase Customization Bony: Checkout Rules & CODNo Checkout PlusYes (Thank You, Order Status, Customer Account) | ||
| Upselling Capabilities | Limited | Yes |
Upselling Capabilities Bony: Checkout Rules & CODLimited Checkout PlusYes | ||
| Social Proof Features | No | Yes (Reviews, UGC, Trust Badges) |
Social Proof Features Bony: Checkout Rules & CODNo Checkout PlusYes (Reviews, UGC, Trust Badges) | ||
| Customer Information Gathering | Basic (order details) | Gift messages, delivery instructions, surveys |
Customer Information Gathering Bony: Checkout Rules & CODBasic (order details) Checkout PlusGift messages, delivery instructions, surveys | ||
| Ease of Use | Potentially Easier Rule Setup (focused feature set) | Potentially more complex setup (broader feature set) |
Ease of Use Bony: Checkout Rules & CODPotentially Easier Rule Setup (focused feature set) Checkout PlusPotentially more complex setup (broader feature set) | ||
| Value Proposition | Reliable Sales, Reduced Fraud | Increased AOV, Improved Customer Experience |
Value Proposition Bony: Checkout Rules & CODReliable Sales, Reduced Fraud Checkout PlusIncreased AOV, Improved Customer Experience | ||
Our Verdict
If your primary concern is managing risk associated with COD orders, preventing fraud, and ensuring reliable checkout processes, especially with international orders or specific product types, Bony: Checkout Rules & COD is the clear choice. It offers precise control over payment and shipping methods tailored to specific conditions, minimizing potential losses and streamlining order fulfillment.
However, if your goal is to significantly boost your Average Order Value (AOV), enhance the overall customer experience during checkout and beyond, and implement various conversion optimization techniques like upsells and social proof, Checkout Plus is the better option. Its comprehensive feature set extends beyond basic rules, allowing for personalized messaging, data collection, and post-purchase customization, ultimately creating a more engaging and profitable customer journey.
Common Questions
Does Bony: Checkout Rules & COD support upsells?
Based on the description, Bony: Checkout Rules & COD doesn't appear to offer upsell functionality. Its primary focus is on checkout validation and payment/shipping rules.
Can Checkout Plus block fake COD orders?
Checkout Plus focuses more on checkout customization. Bony would be a better tool to block fake COD orders, due to its focus on validation rules.
Which app is easier to set up?
It's difficult to definitively say which app is easier without hands-on experience. However, Bony's narrower focus on rules and COD management may make its initial setup slightly simpler compared to Checkout Plus's broader range of features.
Does either app customize the Thank You page?
Only Checkout Plus explicitly states that it can customize the Thank You page.
Which app is better for merchants with high international shipping costs?
Bony: Checkout Rules & COD is better for merchants with high international shipping costs, since it offers shipping rules by weight, price, destination, or conditions, allowing precise control over shipping costs. It also allows you to set payment rules to allow prepaid only for international orders.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store