Bounce Back Redirector vs Traffic Policefor Shopify (2026)
Bounce Back Redirector and Traffic Police represent two vastly different approaches to managing website traffic. Bounce Back Redirector focuses aggressively on leveraging 'bounced' traffic by redirecting users who attempt to leave a site, aiming to lower bounce rates and potentially monetize this traffic through offers or email opt-ins. Its sole focus is manipulating user behavior when they try to leave. Traffic Police, conversely, emphasizes security and geo-based personalization. It allows merchants to block malicious traffic based on location, create allow/block lists, log IPs, and protect content through anti-theft measures. A key feature is the ability to automatically redirect visitors based on their geolocation and implement GDPR compliance through a cookie bar. The stark contrast lies in their core objectives. Bounce Back Redirector is a growth-oriented tool targeting merchants primarily concerned with SEO and conversion rate optimization through potentially aggressive tactics. Traffic Police caters to merchants prioritizing website security, compliance, and delivering a tailored user experience based on location. The app ratings and number of reviews heavily favor Traffic Police, suggesting greater user satisfaction and a more established presence within the Shopify ecosystem. Considering these aspects, these apps cater to two distinct audiences looking to solve fundamentally different issues on their Shopify store.
At a Glance
Bounce Back Redirector
1 reviews
Traffic Police
8 reviews
Detailed Overview
Bounce Back Redirector
Take over the back button in the browser and redirect visitors
Key Features
- TAKE OVER THE BACK BUTTON TO REDIRECT AND MONETIZE YOUR TRAFFIC
- USE YOUR BOUNCED TRAFFIC TO SHOW OFFERS AND GENERATE REVENUE
- SEO RANKINGS AND BOUNCE RATE
Traffic Police
App Helps to block malicious traffic on your website and auto-redirect visitor based on location
Key Features
- Block Malicious traffic by Country , State or City - Create Block/Allow List
- Auto redirect visitors based on their geo location
- IP Logs
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 1/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Bounce Back Redirector1/5 Traffic Police5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1 | 8 |
Reviews Bounce Back Redirector1 Traffic Police8 | ||
| Core Function | Redirect back button clicks | Block malicious traffic & geo-based redirection |
Core Function Bounce Back RedirectorRedirect back button clicks Traffic PoliceBlock malicious traffic & geo-based redirection | ||
| Target Merchant | SEO-focused, conversion-obsessed | Security-conscious, compliance-driven |
Target Merchant Bounce Back RedirectorSEO-focused, conversion-obsessed Traffic PoliceSecurity-conscious, compliance-driven | ||
| Risk of Negative UX | High (potential for user frustration) | Low (security & personalization focus) |
Risk of Negative UX Bounce Back RedirectorHigh (potential for user frustration) Traffic PoliceLow (security & personalization focus) | ||
| Value Proposition | Monetize exiting traffic, improve SEO | Protect website, customize visitor experience |
Value Proposition Bounce Back RedirectorMonetize exiting traffic, improve SEO Traffic PoliceProtect website, customize visitor experience | ||
| Primary Category | SEO, Conversion | Security, Geolocation |
Primary Category Bounce Back RedirectorSEO, Conversion Traffic PoliceSecurity, Geolocation | ||
| Content Protection Features | None | Image antitheft, disable right click |
Content Protection Features Bounce Back RedirectorNone Traffic PoliceImage antitheft, disable right click | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily concerned with website security, protecting against malicious traffic, and offering location-based customizations, Traffic Police is the clear choice. Its higher rating, more numerous reviews, and robust feature set for security and geo-targeting make it a more reliable and feature-rich solution. The cookie bar for GDPR compliance is another benefit.
Bounce Back Redirector, with its focus on redirecting users who click the back button, carries inherent risks related to user experience and potential negative SEO impacts despite claiming the opposite. This app might appeal to merchants aggressively pursuing conversion rate optimization and willing to experiment with potentially disruptive tactics. However, given its low rating and minimal reviews, merchants should proceed with extreme caution and carefully monitor user behavior if choosing to implement it.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use?
Without direct access to the app interfaces, ease of use is difficult to definitively determine. However, Traffic Police, with its wider range of features including block lists and geo-based redirection, likely has a steeper learning curve but provides greater control. Bounce Back Redirector's singular focus *should* make it simpler to initially configure, but the ethical implications of back button hijacking must be carefully considered.
Which app is more ethical?
Traffic Police is generally considered more ethical. It provides security and personalization options that benefit users. Bounce Back Redirector's practice of hijacking the back button is often seen as intrusive and can lead to a negative user experience.
Does either app impact site speed?
Both apps *could* impact site speed. Traffic Police's security features, especially IP logging and content protection, might add overhead. Bounce Back Redirector's redirection script also requires resources. Testing with tools like Google PageSpeed Insights is recommended after installation to identify and address any performance bottlenecks.
Which app offers better value for money?
Determining value for money depends on the pricing structures (not provided) and the merchant's specific needs. If security and geo-targeting are paramount, Traffic Police likely offers better value. If the merchant is solely focused on potentially monetizing bounced traffic (with the associated risks), Bounce Back Redirector might seem more appealing *if* the price is significantly lower, but given the app's poor rating, this is unlikely.
Are there alternatives to Bounce Back Redirector that are less intrusive?
Yes, many less intrusive alternatives focus on improving user engagement through targeted content and offers presented in a more respectful manner, such as exit-intent pop-ups or personalized recommendations based on browsing history. These approaches avoid hijacking the back button and provide a better overall user experience.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store