BuyAfterTry vs Redeemly Store Credit Cashbackfor Shopify (2026)
BuyAfterTry and Redeemly Store Credit Cashback, while both categorized under 'Payment options - Other' in the Shopify app store, cater to fundamentally different merchant needs and business strategies. BuyAfterTry focuses on offering flexible purchasing options like 'try before you buy' and multiple selling plans, alongside simplified returns. This targets merchants who want to reduce purchase hesitancy by allowing customers to experience products before committing, potentially increasing conversion rates and average order value. In contrast, Redeemly Store Credit Cashback emphasizes customer retention and repeat purchases by rewarding customers with store credit. This strategy appeals to merchants looking to build customer loyalty and drive long-term engagement, particularly those in competitive markets. The stark contrast in user ratings and reviews paints a significant picture. BuyAfterTry, with a rating of 0/5 and no reviews, indicates it is either very new to the market or has faced significant challenges in user adoption or satisfaction. Redeemly Store Credit Cashback, on the other hand, boasts a perfect 5/5 rating based on 45 reviews, suggesting strong user satisfaction and a proven track record. This difference in social proof should weigh heavily in a merchant's decision-making process.
At a Glance
BuyAfterTry
0 reviews
Redeemly Store Credit Cashback
45 reviews
Detailed Overview
BuyAfterTry
App offers purchase options like "BuyAfterTry", multiple selling plans & returns
Key Features
- Allow customers to try before they buy.
- Ability to create multiple selling plans for each product
- Easy Returns interface for customers.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating BuyAfterTry0/5 Redeemly Store Credit Cashback5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 45 |
Reviews BuyAfterTry0 Redeemly Store Credit Cashback45 | ||
| Core Functionality | Try-before-you-buy, multiple selling plans, easy returns | Store credit cashback rewards |
Core Functionality BuyAfterTryTry-before-you-buy, multiple selling plans, easy returns Redeemly Store Credit CashbackStore credit cashback rewards | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants with products requiring customer experience prior to purchase; those with high return rates. | Merchants focused on customer retention and repeat purchases. |
Target Merchant Type BuyAfterTryMerchants with products requiring customer experience prior to purchase; those with high return rates. Redeemly Store Credit CashbackMerchants focused on customer retention and repeat purchases. | ||
| User Interface | Claimed to be 'very intuitive' | Not specified |
User Interface BuyAfterTryClaimed to be 'very intuitive' Redeemly Store Credit CashbackNot specified | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase revenue by allowing customers to experience offerings before committing. | Increase customer loyalty and drive repeat purchases through rewards. |
Value Proposition BuyAfterTryIncrease revenue by allowing customers to experience offerings before committing. Redeemly Store Credit CashbackIncrease customer loyalty and drive repeat purchases through rewards. | ||
| Risk Level | Higher risk due to lack of reviews | Lower risk due to high rating and multiple reviews |
Risk Level BuyAfterTryHigher risk due to lack of reviews Redeemly Store Credit CashbackLower risk due to high rating and multiple reviews | ||
| Primary Goal | Reduce purchase hesitancy | Boost Customer Lifetime Value |
Primary Goal BuyAfterTryReduce purchase hesitancy Redeemly Store Credit CashbackBoost Customer Lifetime Value | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking to overcome customer hesitancy by offering try-before-you-buy options and flexible payment plans, BuyAfterTry might seem appealing *in theory*. However, the complete lack of reviews and a 0/5 rating present a significant risk. Until BuyAfterTry establishes a track record, it is difficult to recommend.
In contrast, Redeemly Store Credit Cashback is a safer and potentially more effective choice for most Shopify merchants in 2026. Its stellar rating and established user base demonstrate its value in boosting customer loyalty and driving repeat purchases. Unless the specific needs of your business necessitate the unique features of BuyAfterTry and you are willing to take a risk on an unproven app, Redeemly Store Credit Cashback is the superior option.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to integrate into an existing Shopify store?
Without further information, it is difficult to assess ease of integration for BuyAfterTry. Redeemly Store Credit Cashback has a proven track record and likely established documentation, suggesting a potentially smoother integration process.
Does BuyAfterTry offer store credit features like Redeemly?
Based on the provided descriptions, BuyAfterTry does not explicitly offer store credit features. Its focus is on 'try before you buy' and multiple selling plans.
Which app is more likely to increase customer lifetime value?
Redeemly Store Credit Cashback is designed specifically to increase customer lifetime value through rewards and repeat purchases. While BuyAfterTry *could* indirectly impact lifetime value by reducing purchase hesitancy, it isn't its primary focus.
Which app is best for stores with high return rates?
BuyAfterTry *claims* to have an 'Easy Returns' interface. If returns are a major issue, BuyAfterTry might seem like the solution. However, the lack of reviews to back up that claim make this uncertain. Consider investigating other return management solutions with established reputations.
Does either app offer subscriptions?
While BuyAfterTry mentions 'multiple selling plans', it's unclear if this includes subscription functionality. There is no mention of subscriptions for Redeemly Store Credit Cashback.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store