BuyAfterTry vs TryOnify: Try Before You Buyfor Shopify (2026)
BuyAfterTry and TryOnify: Try Before You Buy both cater to Shopify merchants looking to offer 'try before you buy' payment options, but they approach it differently. BuyAfterTry focuses on flexible selling plans and easy returns, allowing customers to experience products before full commitment. It emphasizes creating custom purchase options and offering a user-friendly returns process within the customer's account area. BuyAfterTry seemingly provides greater customization in terms of selling plans tailored to individual products. In contrast, TryOnify: Try Before You Buy centers on deferring payments for a free trial period, aiming to reduce cart abandonment and acquire new customers. It automates payment collection and credit card authorization, reducing the operational overhead for merchants. TryOnify explicitly positions itself as a BNPL alternative without predatory lending practices.
At a Glance
BuyAfterTry
0 reviews
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy
4 reviews
Detailed Overview
BuyAfterTry
App offers purchase options like "BuyAfterTry", multiple selling plans & returns
Key Features
- Allow customers to try before they buy.
- Ability to create multiple selling plans for each product
- Easy Returns interface for customers.
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy
Provide customers with a free trial shopping experience in minutes.
Key Features
- Quick & easy setup
- No usage-based tax that eats into your profits
- Automatic payment collection when the trial ends
- Automatic credit card authorizations to ensure payment on time
- Reauthorize credit cards for longer trial periods
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating BuyAfterTry0/5 TryOnify: Try Before You Buy5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 4 |
Reviews BuyAfterTry0 TryOnify: Try Before You Buy4 | ||
| Key Differentiation | Flexible selling plans & returns | Deferred payments & automated payment collection |
Key Differentiation BuyAfterTryFlexible selling plans & returns TryOnify: Try Before You BuyDeferred payments & automated payment collection | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants with diverse product offerings requiring tailored selling options and robust return process | Merchants aiming to reduce cart abandonment and acquire new customers via deferred payments |
Target Merchant Type BuyAfterTryMerchants with diverse product offerings requiring tailored selling options and robust return process TryOnify: Try Before You BuyMerchants aiming to reduce cart abandonment and acquire new customers via deferred payments | ||
| Ease of Use (Claimed) | Very Easy to Use interface | Quick & easy setup |
Ease of Use (Claimed) BuyAfterTryVery Easy to Use interface TryOnify: Try Before You BuyQuick & easy setup | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase revenues through customized selling plans and easy returns. | Acquire new customers sustainably through free trial shopping. |
Value Proposition BuyAfterTryIncrease revenues through customized selling plans and easy returns. TryOnify: Try Before You BuyAcquire new customers sustainably through free trial shopping. | ||
| Payment Structure | Not specified but implied standard pricing model | No usage-based tax mentioned |
Payment Structure BuyAfterTryNot specified but implied standard pricing model TryOnify: Try Before You BuyNo usage-based tax mentioned | ||
| Credit Card Authorization | Not mentioned | Automatic credit card authorizations, reauthorization for longer trials |
Credit Card Authorization BuyAfterTryNot mentioned TryOnify: Try Before You BuyAutomatic credit card authorizations, reauthorization for longer trials | ||
Our Verdict
Given the available data, TryOnify: Try Before You Buy seems to be the more reliable choice currently due to its perfect rating and existing user reviews, although the sample size is small. It's better suited for merchants primarily focused on customer acquisition and reducing cart abandonment using a payment deferral model with automated credit card management. BuyAfterTry, while potentially offering greater flexibility in selling plan customization, lacks any user feedback, making it a riskier option unless the merchant is comfortable being an early adopter. If a merchant needs very specific and different plans for product variations, the untested BuyAfterTry might provide the option to create those (if the claims are accurate).
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy explicitly claims "Quick & easy setup." BuyAfterTry claims "very intuitive interface", suggesting ease of use but doesn't explicitly promise quick setup.
Which app offers more control over the trial period?
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy allows reauthorization of credit cards for longer trial periods, suggesting more direct control over the trial duration. BuyAfterTry's control over trial duration depends on the selling plans created, which offers potentially more granular control but lacks specific detail in the description.
Which app is better for a product with a high return rate?
BuyAfterTry provides an "Easy Returns interface for customers", making it possibly more suitable for products with a naturally high return rate, though 'easy' is subjective. TryOnify doesn't emphasize returns directly, focusing more on customer acquisition upfront.
Which app is better for acquiring new customers?
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy directly states its goal is to "acquire new customers efficiently and sustainably" using deferred payments. BuyAfterTry aims to "increase revenues" which may come from both new and existing customers.
Which app manages credit card authorizations?
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy handles "Automatic credit card authorizations to ensure payment on time" and even supports "Reauthorize credit cards for longer trial periods". BuyAfterTry does not mention credit card authorization functionality in its description.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store