Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery and PushAlert ‑ Push Notifications offer distinct approaches to recovering lost sales on Shopify. Cartly focuses on a broader, more traditional email marketing strategy alongside some push notification capability. It aims to recapture abandoned carts through automated email campaigns, email popups for list building, and even features like spin-a-sale discount wheels. PushAlert, on the other hand, is laser-focused on web push notifications as its primary tool for abandoned cart recovery, price drop alerts, flash sales, and back-in-stock notifications. While both address abandoned carts, their delivery mechanisms and feature sets differ significantly. Cartly appears positioned towards merchants seeking a more comprehensive email and abandoned cart recovery solution, incorporating various email marketing techniques. PushAlert caters to merchants prioritizing immediate, real-time engagement through web push notifications and who value ease of subscriber acquisition and automated journey creation. A key differentiator is the subscriber acquisition method; Cartly relies on email capture, while PushAlert utilizes one-click opt-in for push notifications, potentially leading to faster list growth.
243 reviews
5 reviews
Abandoned cart recovery email automation & email popup to recover abandoned cart, abandoned checkout
Integrate Web Push Notifications on site to recover abandoned carts, send automated drip campaigns.
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery4.9/5 PushAlert ‑ Push Notifications5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 243 | 5 |
Reviews Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery243 PushAlert ‑ Push Notifications5 | ||
| Primary Channel | Email Marketing (with push) | Web Push Notifications |
Primary Channel Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryEmail Marketing (with push) PushAlert ‑ Push NotificationsWeb Push Notifications | ||
| Abandoned Cart Recovery | Email & Push Notifications | Push Notifications (Automated Drip) |
Abandoned Cart Recovery Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryEmail & Push Notifications PushAlert ‑ Push NotificationsPush Notifications (Automated Drip) | ||
| List Building | Email Pop-ups, Spin-a-Sale | 1-Click Opt-in |
List Building Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryEmail Pop-ups, Spin-a-Sale PushAlert ‑ Push Notifications1-Click Opt-in | ||
| Additional Features | Order Follow Up Emails, Win-back Emails, Email Campaigns | Price Drop Alerts, Flash Sale Notifications, Back-in-Stock Alerts |
Additional Features Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryOrder Follow Up Emails, Win-back Emails, Email Campaigns PushAlert ‑ Push NotificationsPrice Drop Alerts, Flash Sale Notifications, Back-in-Stock Alerts | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants wanting a holistic email & abandoned cart solution | Merchants prioritizing immediate engagement via push notifications |
Target Merchant Type Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryMerchants wanting a holistic email & abandoned cart solution PushAlert ‑ Push NotificationsMerchants prioritizing immediate engagement via push notifications | ||
| Value Proposition | Comprehensive email marketing & abandoned cart system | Fast subscriber acquisition and real-time engagement |
Value Proposition Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryComprehensive email marketing & abandoned cart system PushAlert ‑ Push NotificationsFast subscriber acquisition and real-time engagement | ||
For Shopify merchants seeking a complete email marketing solution with abandoned cart recovery as a component, Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery is likely the better choice. Its broad feature set, including email pop-ups, order follow-up emails, and win-back campaigns, provides a more comprehensive approach to customer relationship management. However, for merchants who prioritize rapid subscriber acquisition and immediate engagement through push notifications, especially for use cases like flash sales, price drops, and back-in-stock alerts, PushAlert ‑ Push Notifications offers a more targeted and efficient solution.
The significantly higher number of reviews for Cartly suggests wider adoption and a longer track record. While PushAlert boasts a perfect rating, the limited number of reviews warrants cautious consideration. Ultimately, the ideal app depends on the merchant's specific needs and marketing strategy.
Based on the descriptions, PushAlert, with its 1-click opt-in and focus on automation, likely offers a simpler and faster setup process, particularly for merchants new to push notifications. Cartly, with its broader feature set, might require a steeper learning curve.
Cartly, with its email campaigns, order follow-up emails, and win-back emails, is better suited for nurturing long-term customer relationships. PushAlert is more geared towards transactional and immediate engagement.
PushAlert, with its dedicated flash sale notification feature and immediate delivery via push notifications, is the superior choice for promoting time-sensitive offers.
Cartly likely provides more granular control over message content and design through its email marketing capabilities, allowing for greater customization. PushAlert's push notifications, while effective, may offer less flexibility in terms of design and layout.
PushAlert's back-in-stock alert feature is specifically designed for this scenario, making it the better choice for stores with frequent stock fluctuations.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store