Carty: Add To Cart Button vs EG Auto Add to Cart Free Giftfor Shopify (2026)
Carty: Add To Cart Button focuses on streamlining the buying process, allowing customers to quickly add products to their cart from various pages (homepage, collection, search) and proceed to checkout efficiently. Its core value proposition is improving conversion rates by reducing the steps to purchase. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift, on the other hand, is centered on incentivizing purchases and increasing average order value through automated free gift and BOGO offers. It provides tools for creating rules that automatically add free gifts or additional products to the cart based on predefined conditions. The main difference lies in their primary goals. Carty aims to simplify the buying journey, while EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift focuses on upselling and cross-selling via promotions. Therefore, Carty appeals to merchants looking to remove friction from the purchase process, whereas EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift is better suited for merchants focused on increasing sales volume through strategic offers and promotions. Notably, EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift has significantly more reviews (762) and a perfect 5-star rating, suggesting a high level of user satisfaction, compared to Carty's 32 reviews and a 4.3-star rating.
At a Glance
Carty: Add To Cart Button
32 reviews
EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift
762 reviews
Detailed Overview
Carty: Add To Cart Button
Enable customers to buy products directly from the homepage, collection page, and search page
Key Features
- Add Quick Add to Cart button on Collection, Home, Product, and Search pages.
- Add a quantity selector to make it possible to add more than one product.
- Fully customize 'Add to Cart' buttons to match your store.
- Instant checkout: Skip the cart page and send customers straight to checkout.
EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift
EasyGift: Free gift with purchase app for auto add to cart automatic gift, BOGO & Buy X Get Y offer
Key Features
- Auto add to cart products when cart has certain products or is over a cart total
- Schedule rules for BOGO, Buy X Get Y offers to run them over a certain period
- Run targeted rules to give free gifts add on or free products to customers
- Add free gift with purchase trigged based on specific products or collections
- Add to cart upsells for easy gift
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.3/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Carty: Add To Cart Button4.3/5 EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 32 | 762 |
Reviews Carty: Add To Cart Button32 EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift762 | ||
| Primary Function | Quick Add to Cart | Automated Free Gift/BOGO |
Primary Function Carty: Add To Cart ButtonQuick Add to Cart EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftAutomated Free Gift/BOGO | ||
| Target Merchant | Those wanting simplified purchase flow | Those wanting to increase AOV via promotions |
Target Merchant Carty: Add To Cart ButtonThose wanting simplified purchase flow EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftThose wanting to increase AOV via promotions | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Quick Add Button on multiple pages | Auto add gifts based on cart rules |
Key Feature 1 Carty: Add To Cart ButtonQuick Add Button on multiple pages EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftAuto add gifts based on cart rules | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Instant Checkout | Schedule BOGO offers |
Key Feature 2 Carty: Add To Cart ButtonInstant Checkout EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftSchedule BOGO offers | ||
| Customization Focus | Button appearance | Offer rules & scheduling |
Customization Focus Carty: Add To Cart ButtonButton appearance EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftOffer rules & scheduling | ||
| Value Proposition | Improve conversion rate | Increase average order value |
Value Proposition Carty: Add To Cart ButtonImprove conversion rate EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftIncrease average order value | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing a seamless and quick checkout experience, especially those with high traffic to product pages, collections, and search results, Carty: Add To Cart Button is the better choice. The ability to add products to the cart directly from these pages with customizable buttons and instant checkout significantly reduces friction in the buying process.
However, if the main objective is to increase average order value and incentivize purchases through strategic promotions like free gifts and BOGO offers, EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift is the superior option. Its robust rule-based system and scheduling features offer powerful tools for creating compelling offers and boosting sales. The overwhelmingly positive reviews also indicate a reliable and effective app. The large difference in review count also shows which app is more established.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use?
While both apps claim ease of use, EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift's description emphasizes a "super simple UI" for creating rules, suggesting potentially greater user-friendliness. However, without testing both, it is hard to determine the actual ease of use of Carty.
Can both apps be used together?
While technically possible, using both apps might create a confusing shopping experience for customers. Both apps affect the cart, and running them simultaneously could trigger unexpected behavior or conflicting rules. Careful configuration and testing would be necessary.
Which app is more suitable for a new store?
EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift can provide immediate value to a new store by incentivizing initial purchases and increasing order values. Carty's benefits might be more noticeable once the store has established traffic and a clear understanding of customer browsing patterns.
Which app offers more customization options?
Carty offers customization of the 'Add to Cart' button appearance. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift focuses on customizing the rules and conditions for triggering free gift offers and BOGO deals, which can also be seen as customization, just in a different area of the customer journey.
Does either app support mobile optimization?
Neither description explicitly mentions mobile optimization. However, both apps impact the cart and checkout process, which must be responsive on mobile devices to provide a good user experience. It would be essential to test both apps on mobile devices before committing to one.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store