Carty: Add To Cart Button and Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down address very different needs for Shopify merchants, though both are categorized under 'Product display' and 'Collections'. Carty focuses on improving conversion rates by making it easier and faster for customers to add products to their cart from various pages, and even skip the cart page altogether. Its strength lies in simplifying the buying process and offering customization options for the 'Add to Cart' button. Pushy, on the other hand, addresses inventory management presentation. Its main objective is to enhance the shopper experience by automatically organizing collection pages to prioritize in-stock items, ensuring customers see available products first. It automates the display of sold-out products. Carty targets merchants aiming to streamline the purchasing process and increase sales through enhanced add-to-cart functionality. This would especially benefit stores with a high volume of product browsing on collection or search pages. Pushy serves merchants with fluctuating inventory levels who want to maintain a clean and user-friendly storefront, preventing customer frustration from encountering out-of-stock items frequently. Pushy’s offering has specific tools like bulk mode and tag exclusions that provide additional functionality for their niche. The significant difference lies in the core function: Carty is a conversion rate optimizer, while Pushy is an inventory management enhancer for product listings.
32 reviews
4 reviews
Enable customers to buy products directly from the homepage, collection page, and search page
Push sold-out products to the bottom of collections automatically - so in-stock items show first!
| Rating | 4.3/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Carty: Add To Cart Button4.3/5 Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 32 | 4 |
Reviews Carty: Add To Cart Button32 Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down4 | ||
| Core Function | Simplifies 'Add to Cart' process | Auto-organizes collections by stock |
Core Function Carty: Add To Cart ButtonSimplifies 'Add to Cart' process Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownAuto-organizes collections by stock | ||
| Target Merchant | Seeks to improve conversion rates and streamline purchase flow | Wants to keep collection pages clean and prioritize in-stock items |
Target Merchant Carty: Add To Cart ButtonSeeks to improve conversion rates and streamline purchase flow Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownWants to keep collection pages clean and prioritize in-stock items | ||
| Key Feature | Quick Add to Cart on multiple page types. | Automatically pushes out-of-stock products down. |
Key Feature Carty: Add To Cart ButtonQuick Add to Cart on multiple page types. Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownAutomatically pushes out-of-stock products down. | ||
| Customization | Customizable 'Add to Cart' buttons | Product exclusion by tag; collection selection |
Customization Carty: Add To Cart ButtonCustomizable 'Add to Cart' buttons Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownProduct exclusion by tag; collection selection | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased sales via simplified purchase process | Improved customer experience by prioritizing in-stock products; time saving |
Value Proposition Carty: Add To Cart ButtonIncreased sales via simplified purchase process Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownImproved customer experience by prioritizing in-stock products; time saving | ||
| Inventory Management | No inventory management features | Implicitly improves management of products on storefront based on stock levels |
Inventory Management Carty: Add To Cart ButtonNo inventory management features Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownImplicitly improves management of products on storefront based on stock levels | ||
For merchants prioritizing improved conversion rates and a smoother purchasing experience, particularly those with many products browsed on collection or search pages, Carty: Add To Cart Button is the stronger choice. Its quick add-to-cart functionality and customization options offer tangible benefits for increasing sales. However, the low number of reviews is a potential concern.
For merchants struggling with presenting a clean and frustration-free storefront due to fluctuating inventory, Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down is the better option. It automatically addresses the problem of out-of-stock items, saving time and improving customer satisfaction. Despite the perfect rating, the very low number of reviews should be carefully considered, and further research into the app's performance and reliability would be recommended before adoption.
Based on descriptions, Pushy seems easier to set up, requiring one-click enabling or per-collection controls within the Shopify Admin. Carty appears to involve more customization related to button design and placement.
The provided data doesn't specify whether either app offers a free trial.
Pushy explicitly states 'no theme changes' are required, suggesting Carty might require theme modifications for optimal integration, but this is not definitively stated.
Pushy is arguably better suited for very large catalogs, as managing sold-out products in large collections manually can be time-consuming. Carty would be valuable in either case.
Neither description specifically highlights mobile optimization. It's reasonable to assume both apps are designed to be responsive, but further investigation would be necessary to confirm.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store