Catalog Forge vs Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Downfor Shopify (2026)
Catalog Forge and Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down are both Shopify apps that enhance the collection experience, but they address fundamentally different needs. Catalog Forge focuses on organizing and presenting products through customizable catalogs, aiming to improve navigation and inventory management. It's designed for merchants seeking a more structured way to showcase their product range. On the other hand, Pushy automatically manages the display order of products within collections based on stock availability, prioritizing in-stock items and relegating sold-out ones to the bottom of the page. Pushy is geared towards stores where stock fluctuations are frequent and customer experience hinges on readily available products. It streamlines collection management by automating the visibility of in-stock items, reducing customer frustration and potentially increasing sales. While Catalog Forge is about meticulous organization and presentation, Pushy is about dynamic stock-based prioritization, reflecting real-time inventory changes without manual intervention.
At a Glance
Catalog Forge
1 reviews
Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down
4 reviews
Detailed Overview
Catalog Forge
Create a catalog and link it to your products with ease.
Key Features
- Create and customize product catalogs quickly and easily for your store.
- Seamlessly link products to catalogs for smooth organization and navigation.
- Optimize product data and streamline inventory management effortlessly.
Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down
Push sold-out products to the bottom of collections automatically - so in-stock items show first!
Key Features
- Auto push-down sold-out products to bottom of collections
- Auto-restore on restock based on your collection sorting
- One-click enable for all collections (bulk mode) or per-collection controls
- Exclude specific products by tag (e.g., do-not-move)
- Real-time updates + hourly safety re-check (stays accurate)
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Catalog Forge5/5 Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1 | 4 |
Reviews Catalog Forge1 Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down4 | ||
| Primary Function | Catalog Creation and Management | Automatic Out-of-Stock Product Repositioning |
Primary Function Catalog ForgeCatalog Creation and Management Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownAutomatic Out-of-Stock Product Repositioning | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants with large or complex product catalogs | Merchants concerned about displaying out-of-stock items in collections |
Target Merchant Catalog ForgeMerchants with large or complex product catalogs Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownMerchants concerned about displaying out-of-stock items in collections | ||
| Ease of Use | User-friendly features (implied) | One-click enable; configuration inside Shopify Admin |
Ease of Use Catalog ForgeUser-friendly features (implied) Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownOne-click enable; configuration inside Shopify Admin | ||
| Value Proposition | Improved product organization, inventory control, and customer navigation | Enhanced shopping experience by prioritizing in-stock items, no manual reordering |
Value Proposition Catalog ForgeImproved product organization, inventory control, and customer navigation Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownEnhanced shopping experience by prioritizing in-stock items, no manual reordering | ||
| Customization | Customize product catalogs | Exclude products by tag |
Customization Catalog ForgeCustomize product catalogs Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownExclude products by tag | ||
| Pricing (implied) | Not specified | Not specified |
Pricing (implied) Catalog ForgeNot specified Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownNot specified | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
The choice between Catalog Forge and Pushy depends entirely on the specific needs of the Shopify merchant. If the primary goal is to improve product organization and create visually appealing catalogs to showcase products, then Catalog Forge is the more suitable option. It empowers merchants to take control of their product presentation and simplify inventory management.
Conversely, if the main concern is optimizing the shopping experience by prioritizing in-stock items and automatically handling sold-out products, then Pushy is the clear winner. It provides a hands-off solution to a common problem, ensuring that customers are more likely to find available products quickly. Pushy is a better fit for stores with frequent stock changes and a desire to improve conversion rates.
Common Questions
Can Catalog Forge automatically hide out-of-stock items?
Based on the provided description, Catalog Forge does *not* explicitly mention a feature to automatically hide out-of-stock items. Its focus is on catalog creation and organization.
Does Pushy require any theme code modifications?
No, Pushy's description explicitly states 'no theme changes' are required.
Can I customize the appearance of the catalogs created with Catalog Forge?
The description states that you can 'customize product catalogs quickly and easily'. The extent of customization options is not detailed but implies a degree of control over the catalog's appearance.
Does Pushy work on all types of Shopify collections?
Pushy offers 'one-click enable for all collections', suggesting it's compatible with most collection types. However, specific edge cases might exist; testing is recommended.
How does Catalog Forge handle product variants?
The provided description of Catalog Forge does not specifically mention how it handles product variants within catalogs. Further research or a trial period would be needed to determine its capabilities in this area.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store