CP: Order Editing & Upsells vs Draft Order Magicfor Shopify (2026)
CP: Order Editing & Upsells and Draft Order Magic both address order editing needs on Shopify, but cater to distinct merchant profiles. CP: Order Editing & Upsells focuses on *post-purchase* self-service editing by customers, aiming to reduce support costs and boost AOV through upsells and customer empowerment. It targets merchants looking for efficiency gains and improved customer experience through self-service options. Draft Order Magic, on the other hand, targets merchants dealing with *draft* orders requiring advanced customization beyond Shopify's native capabilities, specifically B2B, custom quotes, and high-touch sales. It empowers merchants to create highly customized orders with unique pricing and properties.
At a Glance
CP: Order Editing & Upsells
12 reviews
Draft Order Magic
5 reviews
Detailed Overview
CP: Order Editing & Upsells
Cut support costs and boost AOV with self-service order editing, address validation, and upsells
Key Features
- Self-Service Editing - Customers fix addresses, apply discounts, change variants
- Instant order cancellations with automated refunds
- Address validation via Google Maps to flag bad addresses
- Post-purchase upsells to increase average order value (AOV)
- 3PL/WMS integrations to keep fulfillments in sync
Draft Order Magic
Edit draft orders with custom prices, sorting, and properties not possible in native drafts
Key Features
- Set custom prices for any product in the draft without affecting your catalog
- Add custom properties to line-items and custom order attributes
- Reorder line items easily with a drag-and-drop interface
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4/5 |
Rating CP: Order Editing & Upsells5/5 Draft Order Magic4/5 | ||
| Reviews | 12 | 5 |
Reviews CP: Order Editing & Upsells12 Draft Order Magic5 | ||
| Primary Use Case | Post-Purchase Self-Service Editing | Draft Order Customization |
Primary Use Case CP: Order Editing & UpsellsPost-Purchase Self-Service Editing Draft Order MagicDraft Order Customization | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Customer Order Editing | Custom Pricing |
Key Feature 1 CP: Order Editing & UpsellsCustomer Order Editing Draft Order MagicCustom Pricing | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Post-Purchase Upsells | Custom Line-Item Properties |
Key Feature 2 CP: Order Editing & UpsellsPost-Purchase Upsells Draft Order MagicCustom Line-Item Properties | ||
| Target Merchant | General e-commerce with high support volume | B2B, custom quote sellers, high-touch sales |
Target Merchant CP: Order Editing & UpsellsGeneral e-commerce with high support volume Draft Order MagicB2B, custom quote sellers, high-touch sales | ||
| Core Benefit | Reduced Support Costs, Increased AOV | Advanced Draft Order Control |
Core Benefit CP: Order Editing & UpsellsReduced Support Costs, Increased AOV Draft Order MagicAdvanced Draft Order Control | ||
| Ideal User | High-volume stores needing support automation | Merchants needing flexible pricing & order structures |
Ideal User CP: Order Editing & UpsellsHigh-volume stores needing support automation Draft Order MagicMerchants needing flexible pricing & order structures | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily focused on reducing support tickets and increasing AOV through customer self-service, CP: Order Editing & Upsells is the better choice. Its address validation, automated refunds, and post-purchase upsells offer a complete solution for streamlining order management and enhancing the customer experience. However, if a merchant's business model relies on custom quotes, B2B sales, or any process involving highly customized draft orders, Draft Order Magic provides the granular control needed to manage pricing, product properties, and order structure that Shopify's native draft orders lack. Essentially, one focuses on *post-purchase* efficiency, the other on *pre-purchase* customization.
Common Questions
Can customers edit shipping addresses with both apps?
Only CP: Order Editing & Upsells explicitly mentions customer editing of shipping addresses post-purchase. Draft Order Magic focuses on modifying draft orders before they become official.
Do both apps integrate with shipping providers?
Only CP: Order Editing & Upsells specifies integration with 3PL/WMS to maintain fulfillment sync after order edits. Draft Order Magic doesn't mention shipping integrations.
Which app is easier to use for non-technical merchants?
CP: Order Editing & Upsells likely has a shallower learning curve as it automates many tasks. Draft Order Magic, with its advanced customization options, might require more familiarity with order creation and product properties.
Can I add custom discounts with both apps?
While CP: Order Editing & Upsells allows customers to *apply* existing discounts to their orders, Draft Order Magic allows you to *set custom prices* for products, effectively creating a discount or custom quote. The approach and scope are different.
Are these apps compatible with Shopify Plus?
The app descriptions do not explicitly mention Shopify Plus compatibility, but typically apps with integrations like 3PL/WMS sync (CP: Order Editing & Upsells) are designed to handle the scale and requirements of Shopify Plus merchants. Further investigation would be needed to confirm.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store