CP24 Membership vs Supercyclefor Shopify (2026)
CP24 Membership and Supercycle both target Shopify merchants looking to move beyond traditional e-commerce, but they approach it from fundamentally different angles. CP24 Membership focuses on building customer loyalty and recurring revenue through traditional membership programs, offering features like exclusive discounts, automated order placement, and a comprehensive member portal. It’s geared towards businesses selling products that lend themselves to subscription-based access or premium tiers. Supercycle, on the other hand, is a complete circular commerce platform. It's designed for businesses involved in rentals, resale, or subscriptions where physical inventory management is crucial. Supercycle differentiates itself with granular inventory tracking down to the serial number level, facilitating rental management, resale of used items, and subscription services based on usage. It also incorporates risk mitigation tools like ID checks and pre-authorized credit cards, making it suitable for businesses dealing with high-value or easily damaged items.
At a Glance
CP24 Membership
5 reviews
Supercycle
7 reviews
Detailed Overview
CP24 Membership
Create membership plans, offer members-only discounts, auto-renewal & orders, FAQs & Product Q/A
Key Features
- Membership Plans: Create custom plans for loyal customers.
- Exclusive Discounts: Offer exclusive member only discounts.
- Effortless Management: Automate orders, track transactions, manage membership.
- FAQs modules assist in creating modern FAQ pages for store, plans & products.
- Comprehensive and customizable member portal to manage plans & transactions.
Supercycle
The complete circular commerce platform. One platform to manage rentals, resale, and subscriptions.
Key Features
- Calendar: Rent items between two fixed dates.
- Subscription: Recurring billing until the item is returned.
- Membership: Access to a catalogue of items for one recurring price.
- Resale: Selling not-new products.
- Powered by inventory management, rebuilt for circular.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating CP24 Membership5/5 Supercycle5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 5 | 7 |
Reviews CP24 Membership5 Supercycle7 | ||
| Core Functionality | Membership Programs & Subscriptions | Circular Commerce (Rentals, Resale, Subscriptions) |
Core Functionality CP24 MembershipMembership Programs & Subscriptions SupercycleCircular Commerce (Rentals, Resale, Subscriptions) | ||
| Inventory Management | Basic Membership Tracking | Granular, Serialized Inventory Tracking |
Inventory Management CP24 MembershipBasic Membership Tracking SupercycleGranular, Serialized Inventory Tracking | ||
| Risk Management | Member portal management of plans and transactions | ID checks, Deposits, Pre-authorized Credit Cards |
Risk Management CP24 MembershipMember portal management of plans and transactions SupercycleID checks, Deposits, Pre-authorized Credit Cards | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses offering premium memberships or subscriptions for digital products | Businesses renting physical goods, reselling used items, or offering usage-based subscriptions |
Target Merchant CP24 MembershipBusinesses offering premium memberships or subscriptions for digital products SupercycleBusinesses renting physical goods, reselling used items, or offering usage-based subscriptions | ||
| Primary Value Proposition | Increased customer loyalty and recurring revenue | Efficiently manage circular commerce operations and mitigate risk |
Primary Value Proposition CP24 MembershipIncreased customer loyalty and recurring revenue SupercycleEfficiently manage circular commerce operations and mitigate risk | ||
| Ease of Use (Implied) | Likely Easier - Focus on Member Management | Potentially More Complex - In-depth Inventory & Risk Management |
Ease of Use (Implied) CP24 MembershipLikely Easier - Focus on Member Management SupercyclePotentially More Complex - In-depth Inventory & Risk Management | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily focused on offering premium memberships or exclusive content access and looking to build customer loyalty, CP24 Membership is the better choice. Its features are tailored toward this specific use case and likely provide a simpler setup experience.
However, if a merchant's business model revolves around renting products, reselling used goods, or offering usage-based subscriptions where precise inventory tracking and risk management are paramount, Supercycle is the superior platform. While potentially more complex to implement, its comprehensive circular commerce features address the unique challenges of these business models.
Common Questions
Which app is better for selling access to online courses?
CP24 Membership is likely the better choice. Its membership-focused features and ease of use are more suited for managing access to digital content. Supercycle's inventory management features would be largely unnecessary.
Which app is better for renting out camera equipment?
Supercycle is the clear winner. Its rental-specific features, serialised inventory tracking, and risk management tools are essential for managing a rental business.
Does either app offer a free trial?
The provided data does not specify whether either app offers a free trial. Merchants should check the Shopify App Store listings for this information.
Which app is better for managing different subscription tiers (e.g., Basic, Premium, Gold)?
While both mention subscription capability, CP24 Membership's description emphasizes membership plans and exclusive discounts, suggesting a greater focus on managing subscription tiers. Supercycle's description focuses more on the overall circular model.
Is either app suitable for managing a subscription box service?
Both could potentially work for a subscription box service. CP24 Membership could automate ordering and subscriptions. Supercycle’s inventory tracking could be useful but might be overkill depending on the specific product.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store