Doran Product Reviews App & QA vs Review Collect by Scalyfor Shopify (2026)
Both Doran Product Reviews App & QA and Review Collect by Scaly excel in the 'Product Reviews' category on the Shopify App Store and maintain a perfect 5/5 rating. However, Doran Product Reviews App & QA significantly outperforms Review Collect by Scaly in the number of reviews received (510 versus 79), suggesting a larger user base and a longer track record within the Shopify ecosystem. This implies greater market adoption and potentially a more mature feature set, even though specific feature details are missing from the data provided. Without feature lists to compare, we can only infer differences based on the review volume and presumed target audience. Doran, with its higher review count, likely caters to a broader range of merchants, potentially including larger stores with higher traffic. Review Collect by Scaly, while still highly rated, might be a newer app or one targeted towards smaller, more niche businesses. More information is needed to offer an objective assessment. It is highly recommended to evaluate the feature lists for each app. Ultimately, the choice depends on the specific needs and priorities of the merchant. Both apps are well-regarded. One is not definitively better without in depth examination.
At a Glance
Doran Product Reviews App & QA
510 reviews
Review Collect by Scaly
79 reviews
Detailed Overview
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Doran Product Reviews App & QA5/5 Review Collect by Scaly5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 510 | 79 |
Reviews Doran Product Reviews App & QA510 Review Collect by Scaly79 | ||
| Market Adoption | Higher (inferred from review count) | Lower (inferred from review count) |
Market Adoption Doran Product Reviews App & QAHigher (inferred from review count) Review Collect by ScalyLower (inferred from review count) | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Potentially broader range, including larger stores | Potentially smaller or niche businesses |
Target Merchant Type Doran Product Reviews App & QAPotentially broader range, including larger stores Review Collect by ScalyPotentially smaller or niche businesses | ||
| Ease of Use (inferred) | Potentially more documentation and community support | Potentially simpler setup process (speculative) |
Ease of Use (inferred) Doran Product Reviews App & QAPotentially more documentation and community support Review Collect by ScalyPotentially simpler setup process (speculative) | ||
| Value Proposition (inferred) | Robust feature set & extensive community (speculative) | Focused & streamlined functionality (speculative) |
Value Proposition (inferred) Doran Product Reviews App & QARobust feature set & extensive community (speculative) Review Collect by ScalyFocused & streamlined functionality (speculative) | ||
| Maturity | Likely more mature | Likely newer |
Maturity Doran Product Reviews App & QALikely more mature Review Collect by ScalyLikely newer | ||
| Pricing (unknown) | Unknown | Unknown |
Pricing (unknown) Doran Product Reviews App & QAUnknown Review Collect by ScalyUnknown | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking a proven solution with a large user base and potentially more extensive features, Doran Product Reviews App & QA is likely the better choice. The higher review count suggests a more mature and widely adopted app. However, Review Collect by Scaly might be a better option for smaller businesses or those seeking a simpler, more focused approach. Its perfect rating suggests high user satisfaction, despite the lower number of reviews.
Ultimately, merchants should carefully evaluate the features and pricing of both apps to determine which best aligns with their specific needs and budget. A trial of each app is highly recommended, alongside reading recent reviews.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Without additional information, it is not possible to say definitively. Review Collect by Scaly's lower review count might suggest a simpler, more streamlined setup, but this is speculative. It is best to review documentation or try the apps.
Which app is better for large Shopify stores?
Doran Product Reviews App & QA is potentially more suitable for larger stores due to its higher review count, implying greater scalability and a more robust feature set. However, this depends on the specific feature requirements of the store.
Which app offers better customer support?
Without specific data on customer support, it is impossible to determine which app offers better support. The number of reviews might indirectly suggest a larger knowledge base and community support for Doran Product Reviews App & QA.
Are there any hidden costs with either app?
Pricing information is not provided. Merchants must check pricing plans on the Shopify App Store to see if there are any charges or fees associated with each product review app. Watch out for limits, such as only a number of reviews permitted on free plans.
Which app is more likely to still be supported in 2027?
With the larger user-base and more reviews, Doran Product Reviews App & QA is statistically more likely to still be actively supported. That is not to say Review Collect by Scaly is not a stable and good app but just by the numbers alone, Doran is more likely to continue to be supported by developers in the future.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store