Enhance: Approve New Customers and OTP Login with Phone address distinct needs within Shopify's Accounts and Login category. Enhance: Approve New Customers focuses on providing merchants with manual control over customer registration, primarily aiming to restrict access and validate new users before granting them full store access. It caters to merchants who prioritize security and exclusivity, potentially dealing with sensitive products or a members-only business model. OTP Login with Phone, conversely, emphasizes ease of use and security through OTP verification for both login and registration. It provides a streamlined process for customers, reducing friction and enhancing security by eliminating traditional passwords. The crucial difference lies in their core function: Enhance focuses on *controlling* access after registration, while OTP Login prioritizes *simplifying and securing* the login/registration process itself. Enhance may appeal to stores requiring strict verification, while OTP Login suits merchants seeking a frictionless and secure login experience. The significant disparity in review count suggests that OTP Login with Phone has a larger user base and potentially more proven reliability and features.
1 reviews
39 reviews
Manually verify customer registrations and restrict access until the registration is approved
Enable fast, secure OTP login with phone number and email for a smooth store login experience.
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Enhance: Approve New Customers5/5 OTP Login with Phone5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1 | 39 |
Reviews Enhance: Approve New Customers1 OTP Login with Phone39 | ||
| Core Function | Manual Customer Approval | OTP Login/Registration |
Core Function Enhance: Approve New CustomersManual Customer Approval OTP Login with PhoneOTP Login/Registration | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses needing strict user validation | Businesses prioritizing ease of use and security |
Target Merchant Enhance: Approve New CustomersBusinesses needing strict user validation OTP Login with PhoneBusinesses prioritizing ease of use and security | ||
| Ease of Use (customer) | Potentially Higher Friction | Lower Friction - Simplifies Login |
Ease of Use (customer) Enhance: Approve New CustomersPotentially Higher Friction OTP Login with PhoneLower Friction - Simplifies Login | ||
| Security Focus | Controlling Access Post-Registration | Securing Login/Registration |
Security Focus Enhance: Approve New CustomersControlling Access Post-Registration OTP Login with PhoneSecuring Login/Registration | ||
| Customization | Limited, focuses on approval process | Customizable OTP settings, account fields |
Customization Enhance: Approve New CustomersLimited, focuses on approval process OTP Login with PhoneCustomizable OTP settings, account fields | ||
| Notifications | Provides Account Status Updates | OTP via SMS/Email |
Notifications Enhance: Approve New CustomersProvides Account Status Updates OTP Login with PhoneOTP via SMS/Email | ||
For merchants running a members-only store, needing strict user verification processes, or dealing with sensitive product offerings, Enhance: Approve New Customers provides essential manual control and access restriction features. It ensures only approved customers gain access, enhancing exclusivity and security, but comes with potentially higher friction for new users. In contrast, OTP Login with Phone is a superior choice for merchants looking to streamline their login process while boosting security. Its passwordless login and integration with SMS providers make it a user-friendly option, improving conversion rates and customer experience. It is generally the better choice for the majority of Shopify stores in 2026.
OTP Login with Phone likely offers a smoother, faster experience. Enhance adds an extra step of waiting for approval.
Both enhance security in different ways. Enhance manually controls access, while OTP prevents unauthorized login with temporary codes. OTP is generally considered more robust against common attacks.
OTP Login explicitly mentions integration with SMS providers like MSG91 and Firebase. Enhance doesn't specify SMS integration.
OTP Login with Phone is designed for a passwordless login experience. Enhance focuses on manual approvals, not password replacement.
Enhance: Approve New Customers is more suited for a wholesale store needing manual approval of new accounts. OTP Login might be a good addition for approved users though, to further enhance security of existing accounts.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store