Fish Wishlist vs Recurpay: Subscriptions appfor Shopify (2026)
Fish Wishlist and Recurpay: Subscriptions app, while both categorized under 'Customer Loyalty' in the Shopify app store, serve fundamentally different purposes. Fish Wishlist focuses on enhancing the shopping experience through wishlists, B2B functionality, and POS integration, appealing primarily to merchants looking to boost sales through enhanced customer engagement and omnichannel presence. It emphasizes ease of setup and offers features like social proof widgets and request-a-quote for B2B customers. Recurpay, on the other hand, is a subscription management app designed to unlock recurring revenue through automated subscription management, intuitive customer portals, and 24/7 live support. It targets merchants seeking to build predictable revenue streams and enhance customer retention through flexible subscription options and self-service capabilities for their customers. The large difference in the number of reviews suggests a significant difference in user base and maturity of the apps.
At a Glance
Fish Wishlist
7 reviews
Recurpay: Subscriptions app
400 reviews
Detailed Overview
Fish Wishlist
Lightning Fast Wishlist Plus POS, B2B, Social Proof & Flow Integration. 2 Minute Setup.
Key Features
- Express Wishlist: Fast Setup plus Checkout & Account Widgets
- B2B: Request a Quote, B2B pricing, Draft Order Integration
- POS: Manage wishlists, purchase history & abandoned Carts
- Share: Create wishlist links & use Social Proof widgets to boost sales
- Markets: Multi language & multi currency support
Recurpay: Subscriptions app
Subscriptions app to unlock recurring revenue with intuitive customer portal & 24/7 human support.
Key Features
- Support upfront and pay-as-you-go plans with flexible renewal, 24/7 live support
- Design custom subscription widget for your brand in few clicks with full access.
- Let customers manage subscriptions: skip, edit, reschedule, or cancel anytime
- Renew subscriptions on a specific day or date, offer tiered discount, free gifts
- Developer-friendly setup with full access to APIs, code & technical support
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Fish Wishlist5/5 Recurpay: Subscriptions app5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 7 | 400 |
Reviews Fish Wishlist7 Recurpay: Subscriptions app400 | ||
| Primary Function | Wishlist & Omnichannel Commerce | Subscription Management |
Primary Function Fish WishlistWishlist & Omnichannel Commerce Recurpay: Subscriptions appSubscription Management | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses seeking to enhance customer engagement and B2B commerce with wishlists and POS integration | Businesses seeking to unlock recurring revenue through subscription models |
Target Merchant Fish WishlistBusinesses seeking to enhance customer engagement and B2B commerce with wishlists and POS integration Recurpay: Subscriptions appBusinesses seeking to unlock recurring revenue through subscription models | ||
| Key Features | Wishlists, POS Integration, B2B Pricing, Request a Quote, Social Proof | Subscription Management, Customer Portal, Automated Billing, Flexible Renewal Options, 24/7 Support |
Key Features Fish WishlistWishlists, POS Integration, B2B Pricing, Request a Quote, Social Proof Recurpay: Subscriptions appSubscription Management, Customer Portal, Automated Billing, Flexible Renewal Options, 24/7 Support | ||
| Ease of Use | Described as 'Lightning Fast Wishlist' with '2 Minute Setup' | Described as 'Quick and easy setup that works within minutes' |
Ease of Use Fish WishlistDescribed as 'Lightning Fast Wishlist' with '2 Minute Setup' Recurpay: Subscriptions appDescribed as 'Quick and easy setup that works within minutes' | ||
| Customer Support | White Glove Installation available | 24/7 live human support |
Customer Support Fish WishlistWhite Glove Installation available Recurpay: Subscriptions app24/7 live human support | ||
| Value Proposition | Enhanced Customer Engagement & Omnichannel Sales | Recurring Revenue & Customer Retention |
Value Proposition Fish WishlistEnhanced Customer Engagement & Omnichannel Sales Recurpay: Subscriptions appRecurring Revenue & Customer Retention | ||
Our Verdict
The choice between Fish Wishlist and Recurpay depends heavily on the business model. If a merchant primarily sells products and seeks to increase customer engagement, drive sales through wishlists, and cater to B2B customers, Fish Wishlist is the more suitable choice. Its emphasis on ease of use, POS integration, and social proof elements makes it ideal for businesses focusing on one-time purchases and omnichannel experiences. Conversely, if a merchant aims to build a recurring revenue stream through subscriptions, Recurpay is the clear winner. Its comprehensive subscription management features, customer portal, and dedicated support make it a robust solution for businesses transitioning to or optimizing a subscription-based model. The larger review count for Recurpay also provides some confidence in its reliability and feature set compared to the less reviewed Fish Wishlist.
Common Questions
Which app is better for B2B businesses?
Fish Wishlist is more suitable for B2B businesses due to its 'Request a Quote' feature and B2B pricing support, allowing for customized pricing and order processes.
Which app is easier to set up?
Both apps claim to have a quick and easy setup, however, Fish Wishlist boasts a '2 Minute Setup' which suggests it may be slightly faster to get started than Recurpay.
Which app offers better customer support?
Recurpay offers 24/7 live human support, which is more comprehensive than the 'White Glove Installation' offered by Fish Wishlist. For ongoing support, Recurpay is the better option.
Can Fish Wishlist be used for subscription services?
While Fish Wishlist supports B2B pricing, it's not specifically designed for subscription management. Recurpay is the dedicated solution for handling subscriptions.
Which app is better for increasing average order value (AOV)?
Fish Wishlist, through its wishlist and social proof features, encourages customers to add more items to their cart. Recurpay increases customer lifetime value (CLTV) through recurring purchases, but Fish Wishlist is more directly aimed at increasing AOV on individual orders.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store