FiveStar Product Reviews vs Judge.me Product Reviews Appfor Shopify (2026)
FiveStar Product Reviews and Judge.me Product Reviews App both aim to help Shopify merchants leverage social proof to increase sales by collecting and displaying product reviews. However, they differ significantly in their maturity and scale. Judge.me, with its massive user base (30,278 reviews) and extensive feature set, is a well-established and comprehensive solution suitable for merchants of all sizes, especially those prioritizing a wide range of features and integrations. FiveStar Product Reviews, on the other hand, appears to be a newer app with very limited reviews (2). It focuses on elegant display and easy moderation, suggesting a focus on aesthetics and user-friendliness. This makes it potentially appealing to smaller merchants or those prioritizing visual appeal over extensive functionality and a large established community.
At a Glance
FiveStar Product Reviews
2 reviews
Judge.me Product Reviews App
30,278 reviews
Detailed Overview
FiveStar Product Reviews
Curate & Display Stunning Photo/Video Reviews That Drive Sales
Key Features
- Stunning Displays — Create highly engaging video, photo, and text-based displays
- Easy Moderation — Moderate reviews in our simple dashboard
- Review Collection — Easy & fun review collection for your products
Judge.me Product Reviews App
Show real experiences with unlimited product reviews, Google reviews, star ratings, & testimonials
Key Features
- Collect and manage unlimited reviews, photos, videos, testimonials, ratings
- Display eye-catching review widgets, testimonial sliders and product ratings
- Send coupons and referrals to drive more reviews and repeat sales
- Syndicate reviews to Google, Meta & Shop App. Share on Facebook/Instagram/X
- Import reviews from Yotpo, Loox, Amazon, Etsy & other platforms
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating FiveStar Product Reviews5/5 Judge.me Product Reviews App5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 2 | 30278 |
Reviews FiveStar Product Reviews2 Judge.me Product Reviews App30278 | ||
| Key Differentiator | Focus on Stunning Displays & Ease of Moderation | Comprehensive Features & Extensive Integrations (Google, Meta, TikTok, Amazon, Yotpo, etc.) |
Key Differentiator FiveStar Product ReviewsFocus on Stunning Displays & Ease of Moderation Judge.me Product Reviews AppComprehensive Features & Extensive Integrations (Google, Meta, TikTok, Amazon, Yotpo, etc.) | ||
| Review Collection Methods | Easy & Fun Review Collection | Coupons, Referrals, Amazon Import |
Review Collection Methods FiveStar Product ReviewsEasy & Fun Review Collection Judge.me Product Reviews AppCoupons, Referrals, Amazon Import | ||
| Integration Capabilities | Not explicitly mentioned | Google, Meta, Shop App, Facebook, Instagram, X, Yotpo, Loox, Amazon, Etsy |
Integration Capabilities FiveStar Product ReviewsNot explicitly mentioned Judge.me Product Reviews AppGoogle, Meta, Shop App, Facebook, Instagram, X, Yotpo, Loox, Amazon, Etsy | ||
| Customer Support | Not explicitly mentioned | 24/7, 5-star support |
Customer Support FiveStar Product ReviewsNot explicitly mentioned Judge.me Product Reviews App24/7, 5-star support | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Smaller merchants prioritizing aesthetics and easy moderation | Merchants of all sizes, especially those needing comprehensive features and integrations |
Target Merchant Type FiveStar Product ReviewsSmaller merchants prioritizing aesthetics and easy moderation Judge.me Product Reviews AppMerchants of all sizes, especially those needing comprehensive features and integrations | ||
| Value Proposition | Elegant social proof to boost sales with visually appealing displays. | Turn hesitation into trust with unlimited reviews and wide reach. |
Value Proposition FiveStar Product ReviewsElegant social proof to boost sales with visually appealing displays. Judge.me Product Reviews AppTurn hesitation into trust with unlimited reviews and wide reach. | ||
Our Verdict
Judge.me is the clear choice for most Shopify merchants in 2026. Its massive number of reviews, extensive feature set including import capabilities, social media syndication, and 24/7 support make it a robust and reliable solution. Merchants needing comprehensive functionality to manage and leverage product reviews will find Judge.me superior. FiveStar Product Reviews, while potentially promising, lacks the maturity and proven track record of Judge.me. However, smaller merchants who are particularly concerned about ease of use and the visual aesthetics of their review displays might consider FiveStar Product Reviews, especially if they have very limited product selection initially.
Common Questions
Which app is better for a new Shopify store?
Judge.me is still likely the better option for a new store due to its scalability and feature-richness. It provides a solid foundation for future growth and review management, even if some features aren't immediately needed.
Does FiveStar Product Reviews offer review imports?
The provided data does not explicitly mention review import capabilities for FiveStar Product Reviews.
Does Judge.me offer a free plan?
The provided data doesn't mention pricing plans for either app, but many review apps offer free or limited free plans.
Which app is easier to use?
FiveStar Product Reviews positions itself around easy moderation, potentially suggesting higher ease of use. However, the ease of use of Judge.me can't be determined based only on the current data.
Which app has better support?
Judge.me explicitly states they have 24/7, 5-star support. FiveStar Product Reviews does not explicitly mention what support they offer.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store