Gatsby: Convert Your Followers and Gift Box • Gift with Purchase both operate within the Shopify 'Giveaways and Contests' category, but cater to vastly different marketing strategies. Gatsby focuses on leveraging Instagram followers to build email and SMS lists, enhance engagement, and manage ambassador programs, ultimately aiming to personalize marketing efforts and drive sales through social interaction. Its core strength lies in integrating social media activity with email and SMS marketing automation. Gift Box, on the other hand, emphasizes boosting sales and loyalty by offering free gifts with purchase (GWP) or BOGO deals. It's designed for merchants who want to quickly implement promotional offers to incentivize customers to spend more. The target audience for Gatsby is merchants actively engaged in social media marketing, particularly on Instagram, and who are looking to expand their email and SMS marketing lists and leverage user-generated content. It's especially suited for brands with a strong social media presence and a desire to automate engagement. Gift Box targets merchants who want a straightforward and easy-to-use tool for creating and managing promotional offers, such as free gifts or BOGO deals, to increase average order value and customer retention. While both contribute to sales growth, Gatsby relies on social media influence and personalized communication while Gift Box utilizes direct purchase incentives.
110 reviews
178 reviews
Faster list growth is just the beginning. Convert Instagram followers into email and SMS subscribers
Motivate your customers to spend more with free gift with purchase (GWP) & BOGO offers.
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Gatsby: Convert Your Followers5/5 Gift Box • Gift with Purchase4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 110 | 178 |
Reviews Gatsby: Convert Your Followers110 Gift Box • Gift with Purchase178 | ||
| Focus | Social Media Conversion | Gift with Purchase Offers |
Focus Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersSocial Media Conversion Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseGift with Purchase Offers | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Instagram DM Subscriber Acquisition | BOGO Offers |
Key Feature 1 Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersInstagram DM Subscriber Acquisition Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseBOGO Offers | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Automated Ambassador Programs | Spend X Get Free Gift Rules |
Key Feature 2 Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersAutomated Ambassador Programs Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseSpend X Get Free Gift Rules | ||
| Target Merchant | Social Media Focused Brands | Any merchant seeking sales lift |
Target Merchant Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersSocial Media Focused Brands Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseAny merchant seeking sales lift | ||
| Integration | Klaviyo, Attentive, Loyalty Programs | Shopify Translate App |
Integration Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersKlaviyo, Attentive, Loyalty Programs Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseShopify Translate App | ||
| Value Proposition | Convert followers to subscribers, drive UGC sales | Increase order value through free gifts |
Value Proposition Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersConvert followers to subscribers, drive UGC sales Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseIncrease order value through free gifts | ||
For merchants who prioritize building an email and SMS list through social media, particularly Instagram, and want to leverage user-generated content and ambassador programs, Gatsby: Convert Your Followers is the clear winner. It offers a comprehensive solution for integrating social media engagement with marketing automation.
However, if the primary goal is to quickly and easily implement promotional offers like BOGO or free gifts with purchase to increase average order value and drive sales, Gift Box • Gift with Purchase is the better choice. Its ease of use and straightforward functionality make it ideal for merchants who want to launch campaigns without coding or complex integrations.
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase emphasizes ease of use, promising offer creation in minutes without coding. Gatsby might require more initial setup to connect with Instagram, Klaviyo, Attentive, and other platforms.
Gatsby could be argued as better for long-term relationships. The UGC features and customer flows enable you to engage with them on a more personal level. That said, both ultimately aim to do this in their own ways.
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase is designed for immediate sales boosts through enticing offers that directly incentivize purchases. It is likely the better pick to see revenue increases faster.
The data doesn't specify theme compatibility. It's crucial to check each app's documentation or contact their support to confirm compatibility with your specific Shopify theme.
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase is likely the better choice for brands that lack a substantial social media presence, since it focuses directly on purchase incentives rather than social media marketing.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store