Gatsby: Convert Your Followers vs Giveaway Gatorfor Shopify (2026)
Gatsby: Convert Your Followers and Giveaway Gator both aim to help Shopify merchants leverage giveaways, but they approach it from vastly different angles and cater to distinct needs. Gatsby focuses on converting Instagram followers into email and SMS subscribers through automated giveaways and campaigns integrated with popular marketing platforms like Klaviyo and Attentive. Its strength lies in social media engagement, personalized marketing flows triggered by user-generated content (UGC), and ambassador management. It targets merchants seeking to amplify their social presence and convert followers into paying customers through comprehensive marketing automation. Giveaway Gator, in contrast, is designed for managing complex, concurrent giveaway and sweepstakes promotions directly within the Shopify store. It prioritizes on-site engagement through entry badges, bonus entries for specific products, order multipliers to increase AOV, and integration with Shopify's email order confirmation. Giveaway Gator caters to merchants who want granular control over their in-store giveaway promotions, using them to boost sales, deflect discount requests, and increase average order value. The primary difference lies in the source of engagement: Instagram for Gatsby and the Shopify storefront for Giveaway Gator. Gatsby is geared toward list building and social amplification, while Giveaway Gator is for direct sales incentives and AOV improvement.
At a Glance
Gatsby: Convert Your Followers
110 reviews
Giveaway Gator
1 reviews
Detailed Overview
Gatsby: Convert Your Followers
Faster list growth is just the beginning. Convert Instagram followers into email and SMS subscribers
Key Features
- Faster List Growth: Acquire email & SMS subscribers directly from DMs
- Higher Engagement: Connect with customers across email & social channels
- Personalized Marketing: Trigger flows when customers post UGC, follow you & more
- Ambassador Management: Run fully automated ambassador programs
- Drive conversions: From social sharing to high converting UGC, increase sales
Giveaway Gator
Manage giveaways and sweepstakes promotions with ease.
Key Features
- Create, manage and automate multiple giveaways, at the same time.
- Entry badges for product cards & pages that update automatically.
- Create entry-only bonus discount codes to deflect discounts & retain margin.
- Create order multiplier products to increase AOV.
- Give extra entries with order tag bonuses and Shopify Flow actions.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Gatsby: Convert Your Followers5/5 Giveaway Gator5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 110 | 1 |
Reviews Gatsby: Convert Your Followers110 Giveaway Gator1 | ||
| Primary Focus | Instagram follower conversion | In-store giveaway management |
Primary Focus Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersInstagram follower conversion Giveaway GatorIn-store giveaway management | ||
| Marketing Integration | Klaviyo, Attentive, Loyalty Programs | Shopify email order confirmation, Shopify Flow |
Marketing Integration Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersKlaviyo, Attentive, Loyalty Programs Giveaway GatorShopify email order confirmation, Shopify Flow | ||
| Key Feature: UGC | Automated flows triggered by UGC | Bonus entries for specific products |
Key Feature: UGC Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersAutomated flows triggered by UGC Giveaway GatorBonus entries for specific products | ||
| Target Merchant | Brands with a strong Instagram presence focused on list growth | Merchants seeking to boost on-site sales and AOV with giveaways |
Target Merchant Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersBrands with a strong Instagram presence focused on list growth Giveaway GatorMerchants seeking to boost on-site sales and AOV with giveaways | ||
| Automation Emphasis | High (automated flows, ambassador programs) | Medium (multiple giveaway management, order bonuses) |
Automation Emphasis Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersHigh (automated flows, ambassador programs) Giveaway GatorMedium (multiple giveaway management, order bonuses) | ||
| Value Proposition | Convert followers into email/SMS subscribers and reward loyalty | Increase AOV, deflect discounts, and retain margin with giveaways |
Value Proposition Gatsby: Convert Your FollowersConvert followers into email/SMS subscribers and reward loyalty Giveaway GatorIncrease AOV, deflect discounts, and retain margin with giveaways | ||
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants heavily invested in Instagram marketing and focused on building their email and SMS lists, Gatsby: Convert Your Followers is the superior choice. Its deep integration with platforms like Klaviyo and Attentive, combined with automated UGC-triggered flows, provides a robust system for converting social engagement into tangible results. The higher number of reviews suggests a more established and widely adopted app.
However, if the primary goal is to enhance on-site sales and increase AOV through strategically designed giveaways and sweepstakes, Giveaway Gator is the better fit. Its features for managing concurrent promotions, offering bonus entries for specific products, and creating order multiplier products offer granular control over in-store incentives. While the single review is a limitation, the specific features addressing AOV and discount deflection make it a targeted solution for merchants seeking direct sales impact from giveaway promotions.
Common Questions
Which app is better for increasing email subscribers?
Gatsby: Convert Your Followers is specifically designed for this purpose, offering direct acquisition of email and SMS subscribers from Instagram DMs. Giveaway Gator does not directly focus on email subscriber acquisition.
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Without hands-on experience, it's difficult to definitively say. However, Gatsby's focus on automation suggests a potentially simpler initial setup for ongoing campaigns. Giveaway Gator might require more manual configuration for each individual promotion.
Can I run multiple giveaways simultaneously with both apps?
While Gatsby facilitates automated campaigns, Giveaway Gator explicitly states that it allows merchants to 'Create and manage concurrent sweepstakes and giveaway promotions'. Therefore, Giveaway Gator is the better choice for managing multiple concurrent giveaways.
Which app offers better reporting and analytics?
The descriptions don't provide specific details on reporting and analytics capabilities for either app. It's crucial to review the apps' documentation or contact their developers for detailed information.
Which app is more suitable for a small business with a limited marketing budget?
Given the limited information, it is difficult to make an informed recommendation for a small business with a limited marketing budget. Both apps offer different value propositions, so you need to decide what is more important for your business at this time.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store