GeoLocation+Currency Converter vs Magic 404for Shopify (2026)
GeoLocation+Currency Converter and Magic 404 address vastly different needs for Shopify merchants. GeoLocation+Currency Converter focuses on enhancing the customer experience through personalization based on geographical location. It aims to increase sales and conversions by automatically redirecting visitors to region-specific sites, offering multi-currency conversion, and providing content in the customer's preferred language. Magic 404, on the other hand, is a utility app designed to improve website navigation by automatically redirecting users away from broken or missing pages (404 errors). It prioritizes user experience by preventing dead-end pages and ensuring customers reach their intended destination. The key difference lies in their core functionality: GeoLocation+Currency Converter proactively shapes the user journey based on location, while Magic 404 reactively corrects navigation errors. GeoLocation+Currency Converter requires setup to define region-specific sites and conversion rates. Magic 404 claims to be easy-to-use and requiring no coding knowledge. The target audiences also differ significantly. GeoLocation+Currency Converter is suited to businesses with international customers and multiple localized storefronts, whereas Magic 404 is beneficial for any Shopify store owner looking to improve site navigation and eliminate 404 errors.
At a Glance
GeoLocation+Currency Converter
9 reviews
Magic 404
0 reviews
Detailed Overview
GeoLocation+Currency Converter
IP-based geo redirection with currency and language converter
Key Features
- Redirect visitors to country or state-specific domains with auto geo redirection
- Block malicious IPs and visitors from restricted countries and states
- Multi-currency conversion feature as per customer’s location
- Show pop-up before redirecting customers to their country-specific domain
- Campaign parameters to track the number of redirects
Magic 404
Say Goodbye to 404 Links with Magic 404
Key Features
- Magic 404 eliminates pesky 404 links from your store
- Easy-to-use, no coding knowledge or technical expertise required
- Ensures a smooth browsing experience for customers
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 0/5 |
Rating GeoLocation+Currency Converter5/5 Magic 4040/5 | ||
| Reviews | 9 | 0 |
Reviews GeoLocation+Currency Converter9 Magic 4040 | ||
| Core Functionality | Geo-location based redirection, currency and language conversion | 404 error redirection |
Core Functionality GeoLocation+Currency ConverterGeo-location based redirection, currency and language conversion Magic 404404 error redirection | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses with international presence and multiple localized stores | All Shopify store owners seeking improved site navigation |
Target Merchant GeoLocation+Currency ConverterBusinesses with international presence and multiple localized stores Magic 404All Shopify store owners seeking improved site navigation | ||
| Ease of Use | Requires initial setup for geo-redirection rules, multi-currency configuration. | Claims to be easy-to-use and requires no coding knowledge |
Ease of Use GeoLocation+Currency ConverterRequires initial setup for geo-redirection rules, multi-currency configuration. Magic 404Claims to be easy-to-use and requires no coding knowledge | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase conversions and personalize customer experience based on location. | Ensure smooth browsing experience and prevent customers from encountering broken links. |
Value Proposition GeoLocation+Currency ConverterIncrease conversions and personalize customer experience based on location. Magic 404Ensure smooth browsing experience and prevent customers from encountering broken links. | ||
| Customization | Offers custom redirect pop-ups and campaign tracking parameters | Not specified in features provided |
Customization GeoLocation+Currency ConverterOffers custom redirect pop-ups and campaign tracking parameters Magic 404Not specified in features provided | ||
| IP Blocking | Blocks malicious IPs and visitors from restricted countries | Not applicable. |
IP Blocking GeoLocation+Currency ConverterBlocks malicious IPs and visitors from restricted countries Magic 404Not applicable. | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants with a global audience seeking to personalize the customer experience based on geographical location and language preferences, GeoLocation+Currency Converter is the clear choice. Its geo-redirection capabilities, multi-currency conversion, and campaign tracking features offer tangible benefits for businesses operating across multiple regions. The 5/5 rating, although based on a limited number of reviews (9), suggests that users are satisfied with its functionality.
Magic 404, conversely, addresses a more fundamental need: preventing customers from encountering 404 errors. While it may not directly drive sales like GeoLocation+Currency Converter, a smooth and error-free browsing experience is crucial for customer satisfaction and brand perception. However, the app has no reviews to support its claims of user-friendliness and effectiveness. If a store is experiencing numerous 404 errors, or has recently migrated to Shopify, Magic 404 is worth investigating (after doing additional due diligence given the lack of reviews), but a tool offering more advanced analytics for identifying broken links might be a better alternative.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Magic 404 claims to be extremely easy to set up, requiring no coding knowledge. GeoLocation+Currency Converter likely requires more configuration, including defining redirection rules for different countries/regions and setting up currency conversion rates.
Does GeoLocation+Currency Converter fix broken links?
No, GeoLocation+Currency Converter does not address broken links. It focuses on redirecting users based on their location.
Is Magic 404 useful for stores targeting customers in a single country?
Yes, Magic 404 is useful for any store, regardless of its target market. All stores can experience 404 errors due to deleted products, changes in URL structure, or other factors.
Can GeoLocation+Currency Converter help me prevent fraud?
Yes, GeoLocation+Currency Converter includes a feature to block malicious IPs and visitors from restricted countries, which can help reduce fraudulent activities.
Why does Magic 404 have no reviews?
There could be several reasons why Magic 404 has no reviews in 2026. It could be a relatively new app, it might have had issues that dissuaded users from leaving positive reviews, or it might simply be that very few stores are using it. Further investigation is recommended to understand the app's reliability.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store