Guardito vs PMO: ProtectMyOrderfor Shopify (2026)
Guardito and PMO: ProtectMyOrder both operate within the Shopify warranties and insurance category, but they target different merchant segments and offer distinct approaches to checkout upselling. Guardito positions itself as a checkout UI customization tool for Shopify Plus merchants, focusing on skip-the-line options and shipping protection. Its value proposition centers on providing exclusive services to "hot" buyers. PMO: ProtectMyOrder, on the other hand, is designed for a broader audience, aiming to boost AOV through upselling premium services like shipping protection, carbon neutral shipping, and free returns. Its key differentiator lies in its revenue-sharing model where the app provider retains 80% of the upsell revenue while handling claims. Guardito's focus is checkout UI customization and skip-the-line services, while PMO prioritizes upselling and revenue generation. Guardito appears to be positioned for high-volume merchants on Shopify Plus who are looking for checkout customization, whereas PMO seems geared towards a broader range of merchants seeking an immediate boost to their AOV with minimal setup overhead. A major differentiating factor is revenue sharing – PMO takes 80% of upsell revenue, but handles claims, while Guardito's approach to revenue is not explicitly stated but likely operates on a standard subscription model. Given the zero reviews and ratings for Guardito, it should be considered a much higher risk option than PMO.
At a Glance
Guardito
0 reviews
PMO: ProtectMyOrder
13 reviews
Detailed Overview
Guardito
Customize Checkout UI, ability for customers to secure the order with skip the line and protection
Key Features
- Merchants have benefits of providing value to most "hot" buyers with skip line
- Customise Checkout UI experience both for merchants and customers
- Customers have benefits of adding these two products to an order
PMO: ProtectMyOrder
Upsell premium services at checkout: increase AOV and improve customer experience
Key Features
- With 9 clicks, start selling premium services like package protection
- Show to 50% of site traffic to see impact on conversion rate
- Customise everything: pricing, titles, text and images
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Guardito0/5 PMO: ProtectMyOrder5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 13 |
Reviews Guardito0 PMO: ProtectMyOrder13 | ||
| Target Merchant | Shopify Plus | All Shopify Merchants |
Target Merchant GuarditoShopify Plus PMO: ProtectMyOrderAll Shopify Merchants | ||
| Core Functionality | Checkout UI Customization & Skip-the-Line | Upselling Premium Services |
Core Functionality GuarditoCheckout UI Customization & Skip-the-Line PMO: ProtectMyOrderUpselling Premium Services | ||
| Value Proposition | Exclusive Services for 'Hot' Buyers | Increased AOV & Improved Customer Experience |
Value Proposition GuarditoExclusive Services for 'Hot' Buyers PMO: ProtectMyOrderIncreased AOV & Improved Customer Experience | ||
| Ease of Use (implied) | Potentially more complex UI customization | Simplified setup (9 clicks) |
Ease of Use (implied) GuarditoPotentially more complex UI customization PMO: ProtectMyOrderSimplified setup (9 clicks) | ||
| Revenue Model | Subscription (likely) | Revenue Sharing (80% to PMO) |
Revenue Model GuarditoSubscription (likely) PMO: ProtectMyOrderRevenue Sharing (80% to PMO) | ||
| Features | Skip the line and shipping protection options | Package Protection, Carbon Neutral Shipping, Free Returns |
Features GuarditoSkip the line and shipping protection options PMO: ProtectMyOrderPackage Protection, Carbon Neutral Shipping, Free Returns | ||
Our Verdict
PMO: ProtectMyOrder is the safer and more immediately impactful choice for most Shopify merchants. With a perfect 5-star rating and 13 reviews, it demonstrates real-world effectiveness and positive user feedback. Its straightforward setup (9 clicks) and clear value proposition of increased AOV make it an attractive option for merchants looking to quickly boost revenue through upselling.
Guardito, while potentially offering more advanced checkout customization capabilities, is a riskier proposition due to its lack of reviews and focus on Shopify Plus. It might appeal to larger merchants seeking highly customized checkout experiences, but the absence of social proof and its unclear revenue model make it a less compelling choice for the average merchant. If checkout UI customization for skip-the-line functionality is critical and the merchant is on Shopify Plus, Guardito may be worth exploring cautiously. However, PMO is the superior choice for most merchants.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and start using?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder boasts a 9-click setup, suggesting a far simpler onboarding process than Guardito, which implies more involved UI customization.
Which app is better for increasing Average Order Value (AOV)?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder is explicitly designed to increase AOV through upselling premium services. Guardito might indirectly influence AOV by attracting 'hot' buyers, but its primary focus is on checkout experience.
Which app offers a more flexible revenue model?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder utilizes a revenue-sharing model where the app provider takes 80% of the upsell revenue while handling claims. Guardito's revenue model is not clearly stated, but it likely operates on a standard subscription model which offers less flexibility based on performance.
Which app is more suitable for a smaller Shopify store?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder is designed for all Shopify merchants, suggesting accessibility and ease of use for smaller stores. Guardito's exclusive focus on Shopify Plus indicates it's better suited for larger, higher-volume businesses.
Which app has better social proof?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder has a perfect 5-star rating with 13 reviews, demonstrating positive user feedback. Guardito has no reviews, making it difficult to assess its effectiveness or user satisfaction.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store