Keeper—Recover Abandoned Carts vs PayRules: Hide Payment Methodsfor Shopify (2026)
Keeper—Recover Abandoned Carts and PayRules: Hide Payment Methods are both Shopify apps operating within the 'Checkout' and 'Cart customization' categories, but they address fundamentally different needs. Keeper focuses on recovering lost sales by engaging customers who abandon their shopping carts, aiming to recapture revenue. PayRules, on the other hand, concentrates on optimizing the payment options presented to customers, allowing merchants to control which payment methods are visible based on specific criteria. This distinction places them in different optimization spheres; Keeper is about retention, while PayRules is about conversion and payment management.
At a Glance
Keeper—Recover Abandoned Carts
103 reviews
PayRules: Hide Payment Methods
76 reviews
Detailed Overview
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.1/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Keeper—Recover Abandoned Carts4.1/5 PayRules: Hide Payment Methods4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 103 | 76 |
Reviews Keeper—Recover Abandoned Carts103 PayRules: Hide Payment Methods76 | ||
| Focus | Abandoned Cart Recovery | Payment Method Visibility Control |
Focus Keeper—Recover Abandoned CartsAbandoned Cart Recovery PayRules: Hide Payment MethodsPayment Method Visibility Control | ||
| Primary Goal | Increase Recovered Sales | Optimize Payment Selection |
Primary Goal Keeper—Recover Abandoned CartsIncrease Recovered Sales PayRules: Hide Payment MethodsOptimize Payment Selection | ||
| Key Functionality | Automated Emails/SMS, Cart Saving | Payment Method Filtering, Rules Engine |
Key Functionality Keeper—Recover Abandoned CartsAutomated Emails/SMS, Cart Saving PayRules: Hide Payment MethodsPayment Method Filtering, Rules Engine | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants with high cart abandonment rates | Merchants needing payment gateway customization |
Target Merchant Keeper—Recover Abandoned CartsMerchants with high cart abandonment rates PayRules: Hide Payment MethodsMerchants needing payment gateway customization | ||
| Value Proposition | Recapture lost revenue from abandoned carts | Improve conversion rates by presenting relevant payment options |
Value Proposition Keeper—Recover Abandoned CartsRecapture lost revenue from abandoned carts PayRules: Hide Payment MethodsImprove conversion rates by presenting relevant payment options | ||
| User Interface Complexity | Likely focused on email/SMS campaign design and analytics | Likely focused on rule creation and payment method configuration |
User Interface Complexity Keeper—Recover Abandoned CartsLikely focused on email/SMS campaign design and analytics PayRules: Hide Payment MethodsLikely focused on rule creation and payment method configuration | ||
Our Verdict
Keeper—Recover Abandoned Carts is best suited for Shopify merchants experiencing significant cart abandonment issues. If a substantial portion of potential customers are leaving without completing their purchases, Keeper's automated recovery tools can provide a valuable return on investment. PayRules: Hide Payment Methods is ideal for merchants needing fine-grained control over payment method visibility. This is particularly useful for businesses dealing with international customers, specific product types, or payment gateway limitations. The higher rating of PayRules suggests higher user satisfaction, but it has fewer reviews; consider your priorities carefully.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Without specific feature details, it's difficult to definitively say. Keeper might be easier to set up if it primarily involves configuring email/SMS campaigns. PayRules might involve a steeper learning curve due to the rule creation aspect of payment method filtering. Consider the specific user interfaces, which cannot be determined from the data.
Which app is more likely to increase revenue?
Both apps aim to increase revenue, but in different ways. Keeper directly recovers revenue from abandoned carts, while PayRules indirectly increases revenue by optimizing the payment experience and potentially improving conversion rates.
Can these apps be used together?
Yes, they address different aspects of the checkout process and can be used in conjunction. Keeper recovers abandoned carts after the initial checkout attempt, while PayRules aims to improve the initial checkout experience by optimizing payment method visibility.
Does the higher rating of PayRules indicate it's a better app overall?
Not necessarily. A higher rating suggests higher user satisfaction, but the context is crucial. PayRules addresses a specific need (payment method control), while Keeper addresses a broader issue (cart abandonment). Your specific business needs should dictate which app is more valuable.
Which app offers better customer support?
The provided data does not provide information about customer support quality. It would be important to read user reviews to determine customer satisfaction with the quality of support for both apps.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store