Link Redirect Manager vs Traffic Policefor Shopify (2026)
Link Redirect Manager and Traffic Police, while both falling under the Geolocation category on Shopify, address very different needs. Link Redirect Manager focuses solely on redirecting users from old URLs to new ones, specifically targeting merchants who have migrated their store from another platform to Shopify. Its value proposition lies in minimizing lost traffic due to outdated links. Traffic Police, on the other hand, is a security and geolocation tool. It aims to protect stores from malicious traffic, offer geo-based redirection, and provide content protection features. It caters to merchants concerned about security, GDPR compliance, and personalizing user experiences based on location.
At a Glance
Link Redirect Manager
0 reviews
Traffic Police
8 reviews
Detailed Overview
Link Redirect Manager
This app allows to redirecting the customers from an old URL to new URL in case migration happens.
Key Features
- Add Old and New URL if a migrated store
- Upload of URLs using a CSV file
- Reduce chances of landing on an incorrect page by a customer
Traffic Police
App Helps to block malicious traffic on your website and auto-redirect visitor based on location
Key Features
- Block Malicious traffic by Country , State or City - Create Block/Allow List
- Auto redirect visitors based on their geo location
- IP Logs
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Link Redirect Manager0/5 Traffic Police5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 8 |
Reviews Link Redirect Manager0 Traffic Police8 | ||
| Primary Function | URL Redirection (Post-Migration) | Traffic Blocking & Geolocation Redirection |
Primary Function Link Redirect ManagerURL Redirection (Post-Migration) Traffic PoliceTraffic Blocking & Geolocation Redirection | ||
| Target Merchant | Migrated Store Owners | Stores Concerned About Security and Geolocation |
Target Merchant Link Redirect ManagerMigrated Store Owners Traffic PoliceStores Concerned About Security and Geolocation | ||
| Content Protection | Not Offered | Image Anti-theft, Disable Right Clicks |
Content Protection Link Redirect ManagerNot Offered Traffic PoliceImage Anti-theft, Disable Right Clicks | ||
| Traffic Blocking | Not Offered | Country, State, City Based Blocking, IP Logs |
Traffic Blocking Link Redirect ManagerNot Offered Traffic PoliceCountry, State, City Based Blocking, IP Logs | ||
| GDPR Compliance | Not Offered | Cookie Bar |
GDPR Compliance Link Redirect ManagerNot Offered Traffic PoliceCookie Bar | ||
| Ease of Use (Inferred) | Likely Simple: Focus on URL Management | Potentially More Complex: Multiple Features |
Ease of Use (Inferred) Link Redirect ManagerLikely Simple: Focus on URL Management Traffic PolicePotentially More Complex: Multiple Features | ||
| Value Proposition | Preserve Traffic After Migration | Enhance Security, Geo-Target Traffic, GDPR Compliance |
Value Proposition Link Redirect ManagerPreserve Traffic After Migration Traffic PoliceEnhance Security, Geo-Target Traffic, GDPR Compliance | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants who have recently migrated to Shopify and need a straightforward solution for redirecting traffic from old URLs, Link Redirect Manager directly addresses that need. However, the lack of reviews and zero rating is a major concern. Traffic Police is a more comprehensive solution for merchants focused on security, geolocation-based marketing, and GDPR compliance. The higher rating and some positive reviews suggest a better user experience and greater perceived value. Given the available information, Traffic Police appears to offer a more robust set of features and a better reputation, making it a more compelling choice for most merchants unless their only requirement is basic URL redirection post-migration, and they're willing to take a significant risk on an unproven app.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use?
Link Redirect Manager, with its limited features focused solely on URL redirection, is likely easier to use than Traffic Police, which offers a broader range of functionalities. However, this is an inference based on the feature set and not explicitly stated.
Which app is better for a store concerned about international fraud?
Traffic Police is better suited for addressing concerns about international fraud due to its country, state, and city-based traffic blocking capabilities and IP log tracking.
Can Link Redirect Manager protect my website content?
No, Link Redirect Manager does not offer any content protection features. Traffic Police offers image anti-theft and the ability to disable right clicks.
Which app helps with GDPR compliance?
Traffic Police offers a cookie bar feature that can assist with GDPR compliance. Link Redirect Manager does not provide any features related to GDPR.
If I haven't migrated my store, which app is more relevant?
If you haven't migrated your store, Traffic Police is the more relevant app, as Link Redirect Manager is specifically designed for post-migration URL redirection. Traffic Police provides ongoing value through security features and geolocation-based redirection.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store