Loop Subscriptions App vs Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxesfor Shopify (2026)
Loop Subscriptions App and Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes offer distinct approaches to enhancing sales on Shopify in 2026, though both cater to merchants looking to implement product bundling strategies. Loop focuses on turning one-time buyers into loyal subscribers through a robust subscription management system. Its strengths lie in comprehensive subscription features like flexible bundles, personalized cancellation flows, a customer portal, and automated payment recovery. The high rating with a significant number of reviews suggests strong user satisfaction and reliability. Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes, on the other hand, emphasizes the creation and marketing of product bundles, particularly viral mystery boxes, as standalone products. Its strengths lie in its ability to easily integrate with existing fulfillment systems (both in-house and 3PL) and compatibility with headless commerce architectures, ideal for omnichannel brands. The integration with external marketplaces, such as Instagram and Amazon, expands sales channels beyond the Shopify store. While it has a slightly lower rating and fewer reviews than Loop, its focus on 'bundles as products' with inventory syncing offers a unique value proposition for merchants prioritizing streamlined fulfillment and wider product visibility.
At a Glance
Loop Subscriptions App
503 reviews
Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes
63 reviews
Detailed Overview
Loop Subscriptions App
Boost Subscriber Growth with an All-in-One Subscription App for Smart Offers, Bundles & Cancel Flows
Key Features
- Automation & Workflows: Boost scale, save time & cut errors
- Subscription Bundles & Build-a-Box Options: Lift AOV & loyalty
- Cancellation Flows: Save at-risk subscribers & slash churn
- Customer Portal: Empower users to manage orders, swaps & skips
- Payment Recovery: Auto retries & dunning reclaim lost revenue
Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes
Explodes your Bundles into Child skus for Easy Order Fulfillment with Realtime Inventory syncing
Key Features
- Setup Viral Mystery Box Campaign (Be the brand everyone raves on Social Media)
- Unlimited Bundles: Freely Test various Product combos until find the winner.
- Customers can choose from options like size or color for products in the bundle.
- Build mix and match, multipacks, variant bundles and wholesale B2B packs
- 1-on-1 Onboarding, 24hr Resolution Time to drive your brand towards hypergrowth.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Loop Subscriptions App5/5 Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 503 | 63 |
Reviews Loop Subscriptions App503 Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes63 | ||
| Primary Focus | Subscription Management | Product Bundling & Mystery Boxes |
Primary Focus Loop Subscriptions AppSubscription Management Profit Bundles & Mystery BoxesProduct Bundling & Mystery Boxes | ||
| Key Differentiator | Subscription Features (cancel flows, payment recovery) | Bundles as Products with Inventory Syncing |
Key Differentiator Loop Subscriptions AppSubscription Features (cancel flows, payment recovery) Profit Bundles & Mystery BoxesBundles as Products with Inventory Syncing | ||
| Target Merchant | Brands prioritizing recurring revenue and subscriber retention | Brands focusing on increasing AOV with bundles and expanding to multiple sales channels |
Target Merchant Loop Subscriptions AppBrands prioritizing recurring revenue and subscriber retention Profit Bundles & Mystery BoxesBrands focusing on increasing AOV with bundles and expanding to multiple sales channels | ||
| Fulfillment Support | Native Subscription App Experience | Supports In-house and 3PL (ShipStation, etc.) |
Fulfillment Support Loop Subscriptions AppNative Subscription App Experience Profit Bundles & Mystery BoxesSupports In-house and 3PL (ShipStation, etc.) | ||
| Pricing | Not explicitly mentioned, likely based on usage or plan | Not explicitly mentioned, likely based on usage or plan |
Pricing Loop Subscriptions AppNot explicitly mentioned, likely based on usage or plan Profit Bundles & Mystery BoxesNot explicitly mentioned, likely based on usage or plan | ||
| Customer Support | Team permissions & bulk actions suggest good scale support | 1-on-1 onboarding & 24hr resolution time imply strong initial support |
Customer Support Loop Subscriptions AppTeam permissions & bulk actions suggest good scale support Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes1-on-1 onboarding & 24hr resolution time imply strong initial support | ||
| Integrations | Automated Workflows | Klaviyo, Recharge, Google integrations mentioned |
Integrations Loop Subscriptions AppAutomated Workflows Profit Bundles & Mystery BoxesKlaviyo, Recharge, Google integrations mentioned | ||
Our Verdict
If your primary goal is to build a robust subscription program with features like automated dunning, personalized cancellation flows, and a customer portal designed to maximize subscriber lifetime value, Loop Subscriptions App is the better choice. Its high rating and large number of reviews suggest it's a reliable and effective platform for managing subscriptions at scale.
However, if your focus is on creating and easily managing product bundles (especially mystery boxes) as individual, marketable products, particularly across multiple channels, Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes is more suitable. Its strength lies in its inventory syncing capabilities and support for various fulfillment options, making it ideal for merchants selling across diverse platforms and leveraging 3PL services.
Common Questions
Which app is better for a new Shopify store just starting out?
Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes might be easier to get started with due to its focus on simpler bundling strategies. Loop requires a more dedicated strategy and ongoing management related to subscriptions, making it better suited for stores with existing traction.
Does Loop Subscriptions App support selling physical boxes on subscription?
Yes, Loop Subscriptions App mentions "build a box features," indicating support for creating and managing subscriptions for physical boxes.
Can Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes handle complex inventory management for bundled products?
Yes, its key feature is Realtime Inventory syncing for bundles. It handles inventory updates when a bundle is sold, ensuring accurate stock levels.
Which app is better for reducing customer churn?
Loop Subscriptions App is specifically designed to reduce churn through features like personalized cancellation flows and smart payment recovery. Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes doesn't directly address customer churn reduction.
Do either of these apps integrate with email marketing platforms?
Profit Bundles & Mystery Boxes explicitly mentions integration with Klaviyo. While Loop doesn't explicitly name integrations, its automated workflows likely allow for email communication triggers. Checking the individual app stores for direct integrations is best for confirmation.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store