Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral vs Wishlist by Squarefor Shopify (2026)
Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral and Wishlist by Square both aim to enhance customer loyalty on Shopify stores, but they approach it from drastically different angles. Loyoly focuses on building a comprehensive loyalty program with diverse missions and rewards, incentivizing customer engagement beyond just purchases. It targets merchants looking to cultivate brand ambassadors through UGC and a deeply integrated reward system. Conversely, Wishlist by Square offers a straightforward 'save for later' functionality, allowing customers to create wishlists without accounts and enabling merchants to track product interest and buying intent. It's designed for merchants seeking a simple way to understand customer preferences and potentially boost future sales.
At a Glance
Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral
102 reviews
Wishlist by Square
11 reviews
Detailed Overview
Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral
Boost customer loyalty & retention and collect UGC with a Next Gen rewards and referral program
Key Features
- A fully customizable loyalty program to match your brand identity
- Referral program to reward loyal customers who recommend your brand
- A library of +40 missions to collect UGC and customer reviews on every channel
- Pre-built or customized rewards linked to your Shopify store
- Easy set-up and integration of your rewards program, in just a few clicks
Wishlist by Square
Boost sales with Wishlist features - let shoppers save favorites in a personal wish list
Key Features
- Let shoppers save products for later with a one-click Wishlist button
- Works without customer accounts — saves and tracks products automatically
- Customers manage saved items and add to cart from the Wishlist page
- Customize text, colors, icons, and placement to match your brand store
- Track saved products, Wishlist value, and shopper interest with insights
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral5/5 Wishlist by Square5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 102 | 11 |
Reviews Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral102 Wishlist by Square11 | ||
| Primary Focus | Comprehensive Loyalty & Referral Program | Wishlist Functionality & Tracking |
Primary Focus Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and ReferralComprehensive Loyalty & Referral Program Wishlist by SquareWishlist Functionality & Tracking | ||
| Key Features | 40+ Missions (UGC, Reviews, Referrals), Customizable Rewards | One-Click Wishlist, Automatic Saving, Insightful Tracking |
Key Features Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral40+ Missions (UGC, Reviews, Referrals), Customizable Rewards Wishlist by SquareOne-Click Wishlist, Automatic Saving, Insightful Tracking | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses seeking deep customer engagement & brand advocacy | Businesses looking to understand customer interest & drive future sales |
Target Merchant Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and ReferralBusinesses seeking deep customer engagement & brand advocacy Wishlist by SquareBusinesses looking to understand customer interest & drive future sales | ||
| Complexity | More complex, requiring setup of missions and rewards | Simpler, works 'out of the box' |
Complexity Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and ReferralMore complex, requiring setup of missions and rewards Wishlist by SquareSimpler, works 'out of the box' | ||
| Value Proposition | Cultivating brand ambassadors & collecting UGC | Understanding customer intent & boosting future sales |
Value Proposition Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and ReferralCultivating brand ambassadors & collecting UGC Wishlist by SquareUnderstanding customer intent & boosting future sales | ||
| Account Required | Likely required for loyalty program participation | Not required, operates automatically |
Account Required Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and ReferralLikely required for loyalty program participation Wishlist by SquareNot required, operates automatically | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants seeking a robust, multifaceted loyalty program to encourage engagement and user-generated content, Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral is the stronger choice. Its extensive mission library and customizable rewards system provide the tools to build a deeply integrated brand loyalty experience. However, for merchants who prioritize simplicity and want a straightforward way to understand customer product interest without requiring account creation, Wishlist by Square offers a more accessible and easy-to-implement solution. It's ideal for merchants who want to capture demand and boost future sales with minimal setup effort.
Common Questions
Which app requires customers to create an account?
Wishlist by Square states it works without customer accounts. Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral doesn't explicitly mention it, but it is highly likely an account is required to participate in a full loyalty program.
Which app is easier to set up?
Based on the descriptions, Wishlist by Square appears to be the easier to set up, working 'out of the box' compared to Loyoly's more complex customizable loyalty program.
Which app is better for collecting user-generated content?
Loyoly ‑ Loyalty and Referral is specifically designed to collect UGC with its library of +40 missions.
Which app provides insights into customer buying behavior?
Wishlist by Square tracks saved products, Wishlist value, and shopper interest, providing insights into potential future purchases. Loyoly focuses more on general engagement and doesn't explicitly provide insight into specific product demand in the app description.
Do these apps integrate with other marketing tools?
The provided app descriptions do not mention specific integrations with other marketing tools. Merchants should investigate integrations further for each app directly.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store