Lulu Direct vs MyDesigns: Print on Demandfor Shopify (2026)
Lulu Direct and MyDesigns: Print on Demand both aim to provide sourcing options for Shopify merchants, but they cater to different needs and offer distinct features. Lulu Direct is specifically geared towards authors and businesses looking to create, sell, and ship books. It emphasizes control over the book creation process and offers a wide range of book format options. MyDesigns: Print on Demand, on the other hand, focuses on a broader range of customizable print-on-demand products. It highlights efficiency and scalability with features like bulk mockup generation and effortless fulfillment. The most striking difference is their customer satisfaction, reflected in the vastly disparate ratings. Lulu Direct suffers from a low rating of 2.6/5 with 40 reviews, while MyDesigns: Print on Demand boasts a perfect 5/5 with 29 reviews. This suggests a significant difference in user experience. While Lulu Direct emphasizes its ease of use and professional quality printing, the low rating may indicate otherwise in practice. MyDesigns: Print on Demand focuses on streamlining the print-on-demand process with an emphasis on creating and selling custom products efficiently.
At a Glance
Lulu Direct
40 reviews
MyDesigns: Print on Demand
29 reviews
Detailed Overview
Lulu Direct
Create, Sell and Ship books easily with the Lulu Direct App
Key Features
- Easy to Use: Connect your books in a matter of minutes.
- Flexible Formats: Over 3,000 book format options, binding types, and layouts.
- Professional Quality: We deliver high quality printing at competitive prices.
MyDesigns: Print on Demand
MyDesigns makes it easy to create, publish, sell and fulfill Print on Demand products at scale.
Key Features
- Create, publish, and sell custom products
- Generate premium product mockups in bulk
- Fulfill personalized products effortlessly
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 2.6/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Lulu Direct2.6/5 MyDesigns: Print on Demand5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 40 | 29 |
Reviews Lulu Direct40 MyDesigns: Print on Demand29 | ||
| Product Focus | Books | General Print on Demand |
Product Focus Lulu DirectBooks MyDesigns: Print on DemandGeneral Print on Demand | ||
| Key Feature Highlight | Flexible book formats (3,000+ options) | Bulk Mockup Generation & Efficient Fulfillment |
Key Feature Highlight Lulu DirectFlexible book formats (3,000+ options) MyDesigns: Print on DemandBulk Mockup Generation & Efficient Fulfillment | ||
| Target Merchant | Authors, Businesses selling Books | Businesses selling Customizable Products at Scale |
Target Merchant Lulu DirectAuthors, Businesses selling Books MyDesigns: Print on DemandBusinesses selling Customizable Products at Scale | ||
| Value Proposition | Control over Book Production | Efficiency and Scalability |
Value Proposition Lulu DirectControl over Book Production MyDesigns: Print on DemandEfficiency and Scalability | ||
| Perceived Ease of Use | Potentially problematic based on rating | Good, with emphasis on streamlining processes |
Perceived Ease of Use Lulu DirectPotentially problematic based on rating MyDesigns: Print on DemandGood, with emphasis on streamlining processes | ||
| Customer Satisfaction | Low | High |
Customer Satisfaction Lulu DirectLow MyDesigns: Print on DemandHigh | ||
Our Verdict
MyDesigns: Print on Demand is likely the better choice for most merchants due to its significantly higher rating and focus on efficiency and scalability. It caters to businesses looking to sell a wider range of customizable products beyond just books. If the user is selling products other than books, MyDesigns is an easy recommendation.
Lulu Direct is specifically for merchants selling books and who want a large selection of customizable options. However, the extremely low rating (2.6/5) raises serious concerns about the user experience and potential issues with the service. Before opting for Lulu Direct, merchants should thoroughly investigate the negative reviews to determine if the specific issues are deal-breakers or if the flexible format options outweigh the potential risks. It's vital to address the rating before suggesting Lulu Direct.
Common Questions
Which app is better for selling books?
Lulu Direct is specifically designed for selling books and offers a wide range of formatting options. However, the low rating suggests potential issues with user experience and service. MyDesigns: Print on Demand can also potentially be used, but is not its core focus.
Which app is better for overall print-on-demand businesses?
MyDesigns: Print on Demand is better suited for overall print-on-demand businesses, offering features like bulk mockup generation and streamlined fulfillment for a variety of customizable products.
What accounts for Lulu Direct's low rating?
While the specific reasons for Lulu Direct's low rating aren't available from this data alone, the rating suggests potential issues with aspects like user experience, print quality, customer service, or fulfillment processes. Further research into user reviews would be necessary.
Which app is easier to scale with?
MyDesigns: Print on Demand appears to be easier to scale with, due to its emphasis on efficiency and features like bulk publishing and effortless fulfillment.
Does either app offer design services?
The provided data doesn't explicitly state whether either app offers design services. However, MyDesigns: Print on Demand highlights a 'premium mockup generator,' suggesting design-related capabilities.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store