Magic Collection vs Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Downfor Shopify (2026)
Magic Collection and Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down are both Shopify apps targeting collection management, but they address fundamentally different needs. Magic Collection aims to provide customizable and auto-updating collections, emphasizing flexible sorting and organization based on criteria like color or size. Its value proposition revolves around comprehensive data management and sharing. In contrast, Pushy focuses specifically on improving the customer shopping experience by automatically pushing out-of-stock products to the bottom of collections, ensuring that in-stock items are more visible. This contributes to a smoother and more efficient browsing process for shoppers.
At a Glance
Magic Collection
0 reviews
Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down
4 reviews
Detailed Overview
Magic Collection
Create Your Own Collection - Customize and Auto-update with Our Magic Collection!
Key Features
- Plenty of ways to share and store these collections
- Easily customize collections and let them auto-update
- User Friendly and Automatically updates them with the latest information
Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down
Push sold-out products to the bottom of collections automatically - so in-stock items show first!
Key Features
- Auto push-down sold-out products to bottom of collections
- Auto-restore on restock based on your collection sorting
- One-click enable for all collections (bulk mode) or per-collection controls
- Exclude specific products by tag (e.g., do-not-move)
- Real-time updates + hourly safety re-check (stays accurate)
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Magic Collection0/5 Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 4 |
Reviews Magic Collection0 Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down4 | ||
| Primary Function | Customizable Collection Creation & Management | Out-of-Stock Product Push-Down |
Primary Function Magic CollectionCustomizable Collection Creation & Management Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownOut-of-Stock Product Push-Down | ||
| Sorting/Filtering | Sort by Color, Size, Type, etc. | Automatic Sort by Stock Status |
Sorting/Filtering Magic CollectionSort by Color, Size, Type, etc. Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownAutomatic Sort by Stock Status | ||
| Automation | Auto-Updates Collections | Auto-Restore on Restock |
Automation Magic CollectionAuto-Updates Collections Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownAuto-Restore on Restock | ||
| Customization | Highly Customizable | Exclusion by Tag |
Customization Magic CollectionHighly Customizable Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownExclusion by Tag | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants needing flexible collection organization and data sharing. | Merchants with frequently out-of-stock items who want to improve customer experience. |
Target Merchant Magic CollectionMerchants needing flexible collection organization and data sharing. Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownMerchants with frequently out-of-stock items who want to improve customer experience. | ||
| Ease of Use | Implied User-Friendly | One-Click Enable, Configuration in Shopify Admin |
Ease of Use Magic CollectionImplied User-Friendly Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownOne-Click Enable, Configuration in Shopify Admin | ||
| Value Proposition | Centralized data management and flexible collection organization | Improved customer experience and sales by highlighting in-stock products |
Value Proposition Magic CollectionCentralized data management and flexible collection organization Pushy | Out Of Stock Push DownImproved customer experience and sales by highlighting in-stock products | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down is generally the more appealing option for merchants seeking to immediately improve their store's user experience, given its high rating and tangible benefit of prioritizing in-stock items. Its one-click enable feature and real-time updates also offer a streamlined implementation process. Magic Collection, while promising customizable collection management, lacks any user reviews and offers a more generalized solution that might require more setup and configuration. Merchants needing very specific, complex, and shareable collection setups beyond simple stock management might consider Magic Collection if it later gains traction and positive reviews, but Pushy is the clear choice for improving customer experience around out-of-stock items.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Based on the descriptions, Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down appears easier to set up with its "One-click enable" feature. Magic Collection is described as "User Friendly" but doesn't offer the same level of explicit ease of initial setup.
Which app is better for SEO?
Neither description explicitly discusses SEO benefits. However, a better user experience (provided by Pushy) could indirectly improve SEO through lower bounce rates and increased time on site.
Does either app require theme changes?
Pushy's description explicitly states 'no theme changes', while Magic Collection does not mention theme changes either way. So assuming Magic Collection also does not require theme changes, but its lack of information makes this less certain.
Which app is better if I don't want to manually manage my collections?
Both apps automate collection management to some degree. Magic Collection auto-updates based on your criteria, while Pushy automatically moves out-of-stock products. Pushy might be more suitable if your main concern is managing product visibility based on stock levels.
If my products frequently go out of stock, which app is more useful?
Pushy | Out Of Stock Push Down is specifically designed to address the issue of frequently out-of-stock items. Its auto push-down and auto-restore features directly tackle this problem, whereas Magic Collection offers broader collection management capabilities that may not be as immediately relevant.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store