Magic Collection vs ST: Product & Collection Sortfor Shopify (2026)
Magic Collection and ST: Product & Collection Sort both aim to help Shopify merchants manage collections, but they approach the problem from drastically different angles and with vastly different levels of social proof. Magic Collection positions itself as a user-friendly tool for basic collection customization and auto-updating based on merchant-defined criteria. However, with a rating of 0/5 and no reviews, its credibility is severely lacking. ST: Product & Collection Sort, on the other hand, leverages data analytics and past order data to automate merchandising decisions and optimize collections for revenue generation. Its 5/5 rating with 179 reviews suggests strong user satisfaction and a robust feature set focused on advanced sorting and merchandising strategies. The primary difference lies in the level of automation and sophistication offered: Magic Collection focuses on manual setup and basic organization, while ST: Product & Collection Sort offers data-driven, automated optimization.
At a Glance
Magic Collection
0 reviews
ST: Product & Collection Sort
179 reviews
Detailed Overview
Magic Collection
Create Your Own Collection - Customize and Auto-update with Our Magic Collection!
Key Features
- Plenty of ways to share and store these collections
- Easily customize collections and let them auto-update
- User Friendly and Automatically updates them with the latest information
ST: Product & Collection Sort
Automate merchandising decisions on collection pages to increase revenue and reduce manual work
Key Features
- Pin “Featured” products at the top using a drag-and-drop collection manager
- Sort by Views, Add to cart, Revenue, Inventory, New launch, Variant Availability
- Create New Arrivals, Trending, Size specific, Sale, Metafield based collections
- Use multi-segment sorting to group & sort daily deals, discounted & new products
- Automatically push sold-out items to the bottom or remove them from collections
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Magic Collection0/5 ST: Product & Collection Sort5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 179 |
Reviews Magic Collection0 ST: Product & Collection Sort179 | ||
| Automation Level | Basic, merchant-defined rules | Advanced, data-driven |
Automation Level Magic CollectionBasic, merchant-defined rules ST: Product & Collection SortAdvanced, data-driven | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants with simple collection needs and limited data analysis requirements | Merchants seeking to optimize collections for revenue using data and automation |
Target Merchant Magic CollectionMerchants with simple collection needs and limited data analysis requirements ST: Product & Collection SortMerchants seeking to optimize collections for revenue using data and automation | ||
| Sorting Capabilities | Based on color, size, type, or other merchant-defined criteria | Based on Revenue, Profit, Tags, Sizes, Metafields, Vendor, Product Age, GA4 data (Views, Add to Carts, etc.) |
Sorting Capabilities Magic CollectionBased on color, size, type, or other merchant-defined criteria ST: Product & Collection SortBased on Revenue, Profit, Tags, Sizes, Metafields, Vendor, Product Age, GA4 data (Views, Add to Carts, etc.) | ||
| Value Proposition | Easy customization and auto-updating | Increased revenue, reduced manual work through automated merchandising |
Value Proposition Magic CollectionEasy customization and auto-updating ST: Product & Collection SortIncreased revenue, reduced manual work through automated merchandising | ||
| User Friendliness | User friendly (claimed) | Not explicitly stated but implies a learning curve due to advanced features. |
User Friendliness Magic CollectionUser friendly (claimed) ST: Product & Collection SortNot explicitly stated but implies a learning curve due to advanced features. | ||
| Collection Types | General collections with custom criteria | New Arrivals, Trending, Size specific, Sale, Metafield based collections |
Collection Types Magic CollectionGeneral collections with custom criteria ST: Product & Collection SortNew Arrivals, Trending, Size specific, Sale, Metafield based collections | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking a simple and potentially free solution for basic collection organization and customization, Magic Collection *might* be a starting point. However, the complete lack of reviews raises serious concerns about its functionality and reliability. Given the absence of any positive feedback, proceeding with caution is advised.
In contrast, ST: Product & Collection Sort is clearly aimed at merchants who want to leverage data analytics and automation to optimize their collections for revenue generation. Its high rating and numerous reviews indicate a well-regarded and effective solution for more sophisticated merchandising strategies. If increasing sales and reducing manual workload are priorities, ST: Product & Collection Sort is the much stronger choice, despite a likely steeper learning curve.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use?
Magic Collection claims to be user-friendly, but without reviews, it's difficult to verify. ST: Product & Collection Sort likely has a steeper learning curve due to its advanced features, but this is offset by the automation provided.
Which app is better for a small store with limited data?
Magic Collection might be preferable for a small store with very limited data and a simple need for basic collection organization. However, even with limited data, ST: Product & Collection Sort could still be valuable for implementing basic rules-based sorting and product demotion.
Which app focuses more on automated merchandising?
ST: Product & Collection Sort is explicitly focused on automated merchandising decisions using data analytics, while Magic Collection relies on manual customization.
Does either app support A/B testing of collections?
Neither app explicitly mentions A/B testing capabilities in the provided descriptions. This would be something to confirm with the developers.
Which app is more likely to increase revenue?
ST: Product & Collection Sort is designed to increase revenue through automated merchandising and optimized sorting strategies. Magic Collection's impact on revenue is uncertain.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store