Magic Tips vs Redeemly Store Credit Cashbackfor Shopify (2026)
Magic Tips and Redeemly Store Credit Cashback both fall under the 'Payment options - Other' category on the Shopify app store, but serve distinctly different purposes. Magic Tips focuses on enabling customers to leave tips post-purchase, offering customization options for trigger conditions, tip amounts (percentage or fixed), and display elements. This app targets merchants looking to increase revenue through voluntary customer gratuity. Redeemly Store Credit Cashback, on the other hand, appears to focus on rewarding customers with store credit for purchases, thereby incentivizing repeat business and potentially improving customer loyalty. The primary difference lies in their core functionality. Magic Tips adds a tip functionality, while Redeemly focuses on a cashback loyalty program. Based on the provided data, Redeemly Store Credit Cashback enjoys significantly more user trust, reflected by a perfect 5/5 rating based on 45 reviews. Magic Tips, in stark contrast, has no reviews and therefore no rating. This difference suggests a disparity in either the maturity of the apps or the initial user experience and marketing effectiveness.
At a Glance
Magic Tips
0 reviews
Redeemly Store Credit Cashback
45 reviews
Detailed Overview
Magic Tips
Give your customers a simple option to leave a tip.
Key Features
- Whether you want to tip by the amount or by percentage, Magic Tips got you cover
- You can set multiple tips, or even both at the same time.
- Set to display the tips based on the purchase value or when the selected product
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Magic Tips0/5 Redeemly Store Credit Cashback5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 45 |
Reviews Magic Tips0 Redeemly Store Credit Cashback45 | ||
| Core Functionality | Post-Purchase Tipping | Store Credit Cashback |
Core Functionality Magic TipsPost-Purchase Tipping Redeemly Store Credit CashbackStore Credit Cashback | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses suitable for tipping (e.g., food delivery, service-based businesses) | E-commerce stores focused on customer loyalty and repeat purchases |
Target Merchant Magic TipsBusinesses suitable for tipping (e.g., food delivery, service-based businesses) Redeemly Store Credit CashbackE-commerce stores focused on customer loyalty and repeat purchases | ||
| Ease of Use (Implied) | Claims to be simple to install and use | No direct indication, but positive reviews usually correlate with good UX |
Ease of Use (Implied) Magic TipsClaims to be simple to install and use Redeemly Store Credit CashbackNo direct indication, but positive reviews usually correlate with good UX | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased revenue through customer tips | Increased customer loyalty and repeat purchases |
Value Proposition Magic TipsIncreased revenue through customer tips Redeemly Store Credit CashbackIncreased customer loyalty and repeat purchases | ||
| Customization | Customizable tip amounts, display triggers, and aesthetics | No information provided on customization |
Customization Magic TipsCustomizable tip amounts, display triggers, and aesthetics Redeemly Store Credit CashbackNo information provided on customization | ||
| Risk (Based on Reviews) | Higher perceived risk due to lack of reviews | Lower perceived risk due to positive reviews |
Risk (Based on Reviews) Magic TipsHigher perceived risk due to lack of reviews Redeemly Store Credit CashbackLower perceived risk due to positive reviews | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking to integrate a tipping feature into their post-purchase flow, Magic Tips *could* be an option, but the complete absence of reviews makes it a risky choice. Its primary advantage is its claim of simple setup and customizability of tipping options. However, the lack of social proof is a major drawback.
Redeemly Store Credit Cashback is a much safer bet for merchants aiming to boost customer loyalty and drive repeat purchases, given its excellent rating and substantial number of positive reviews. The social proof alone makes it a significantly more appealing option. Unless a merchant specifically needs a tipping feature and is willing to take a gamble on an unproven app, Redeemly is the more reliable choice.
Common Questions
Which app is more reliable based on the provided data?
Redeemly Store Credit Cashback is significantly more reliable, as evidenced by its 5/5 rating and 45 reviews, compared to Magic Tips' 0/5 rating and 0 reviews.
What is the primary difference between Magic Tips and Redeemly?
Magic Tips focuses on enabling customers to leave tips post-purchase, while Redeemly Store Credit Cashback focuses on rewarding customers with store credit to encourage repeat purchases.
Which app is better for increasing immediate revenue?
Magic Tips, theoretically, could increase immediate revenue through tips. However, Redeemly could drive more long-term revenue via repeat purchases thanks to enhanced customer loyalty.
Is Magic Tips risky to install?
Yes, Magic Tips carries a higher risk due to the complete absence of user reviews. Merchants should proceed with caution.
Which type of business would benefit most from Magic Tips?
Businesses where tipping is customary or common, such as restaurants offering delivery services or service-based businesses like salons, might find Magic Tips useful (if it works as advertised).
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store