MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout vs Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmapfor Shopify (2026)
Both MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout and Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmap aim to help Shopify merchants optimize their stores through user behavior analysis. Both apps are rated 4.9/5, suggesting high user satisfaction. However, Propel has significantly more reviews (415) than MIDA (248), indicating a larger user base and potentially broader feedback pool. The core function of both apps revolves around heatmaps and session replays, allowing merchants to visually understand how customers interact with their website and identify friction points in the customer journey. A key difference highlighted in their names is the inclusion of surveys in Propel, which MIDA does not explicitly mention. Propel's inclusion of surveys positions it as a more comprehensive tool for gathering direct customer feedback in addition to observed behavior. This allows merchants to supplement heatmap and replay data with qualitative insights. MIDA, on the other hand, focuses more narrowly on heatmaps and replay, particularly emphasizing checkout optimization. This potentially makes it a more targeted solution for merchants primarily concerned with improving conversion rates at the final stages of the purchase funnel. Choosing between them depends on whether the merchant values integrated surveys for holistic understanding or a laser focus on checkout optimization. Given both apps belong to 'Site Optimization - Other', 'Operations', and 'Analytics' categories, they appeal to merchants seeking to improve site performance, streamline operations based on data insights, and enhance their overall analytics capabilities to drive sales and improve customer experience. The ideal merchant for either app is one who is data-driven and actively seeks to understand and optimize their customer journey.
At a Glance
MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout
248 reviews
Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmap
415 reviews
Detailed Overview
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout4.9/5 Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmap4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 248 | 415 |
Reviews MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout248 Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmap415 | ||
| Key Differentiating Feature | Checkout Focus | Integrated Surveys |
Key Differentiating Feature MIDA: Heatmap, Replay CheckoutCheckout Focus Propel Replay, Survey, HeatmapIntegrated Surveys | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants prioritizing checkout optimization. | Merchants desiring holistic user feedback via surveys & behavior tracking. |
Target Merchant Type MIDA: Heatmap, Replay CheckoutMerchants prioritizing checkout optimization. Propel Replay, Survey, HeatmapMerchants desiring holistic user feedback via surveys & behavior tracking. | ||
| Ease of Use (based on user sentiment proxy) | Potentially easier due to fewer features, though not directly stated. | Potentially more complex due to broader feature set, but also more comprehensive. |
Ease of Use (based on user sentiment proxy) MIDA: Heatmap, Replay CheckoutPotentially easier due to fewer features, though not directly stated. Propel Replay, Survey, HeatmapPotentially more complex due to broader feature set, but also more comprehensive. | ||
| Value Proposition | Focused user behavior analytics for checkout optimization, potentially higher ROI on conversion. | Comprehensive user insights through behavior and survey data, potentially better overall understanding of the customer. |
Value Proposition MIDA: Heatmap, Replay CheckoutFocused user behavior analytics for checkout optimization, potentially higher ROI on conversion. Propel Replay, Survey, HeatmapComprehensive user insights through behavior and survey data, potentially better overall understanding of the customer. | ||
| Feature Set Breadth | Narrower (Heatmap, Replay) | Broader (Replay, Survey, Heatmap) |
Feature Set Breadth MIDA: Heatmap, Replay CheckoutNarrower (Heatmap, Replay) Propel Replay, Survey, HeatmapBroader (Replay, Survey, Heatmap) | ||
| User Base Size (proxy) | Smaller | Larger |
User Base Size (proxy) MIDA: Heatmap, Replay CheckoutSmaller Propel Replay, Survey, HeatmapLarger | ||
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants primarily focused on boosting checkout conversion rates and deeply understanding checkout behavior, MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout might be the better choice. Its targeted focus can lead to faster insights and more direct optimizations. However, for merchants seeking a more comprehensive view of the entire customer journey, including qualitative feedback through surveys integrated with behavioral analytics, Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmap offers a more robust and versatile solution.
Ultimately, the choice depends on the merchant's specific needs and priorities. If checkout optimization is the primary goal, MIDA may be the winner. If a holistic understanding of the customer journey and the ability to directly solicit feedback are paramount, then Propel is the stronger contender. It is essential that the merchant also look at the pricing and available support for each app to finalize the decision.
Common Questions
Does MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout offer customer surveys like Propel Replay, Survey, Heatmap?
Based on the provided data, MIDA: Heatmap, Replay Checkout does not explicitly offer customer surveys. Propel's name directly states inclusion of surveys, indicating that its feature set is wider in capturing user opinions.
Which app is better for optimizing mobile traffic?
The data does not explicitly state which app is better for optimizing mobile traffic. However, both apps, through heatmaps and replay functionality, should provide insights into user behavior on mobile devices. It's recommended to explore the app demos and reviews to see which one is better suited for mobile data and ease of use in mobile devices.
Which app is more user-friendly?
Determining user-friendliness is subjective. The review counts suggest Propel has a larger user base; a larger user base can signal greater usability, but it isn't definite. MIDA, with a narrower focus, might be simpler to navigate. It's best to trial both apps or read recent reviews that explicitly mention ease of use before making a decision.
Which app offers a more comprehensive analytics dashboard?
While both apps are in the 'Analytics' category, the data does not provide detailed insight into the comprehensiveness of their dashboards. Propel's survey feature suggests a broader data collection capability, which might translate to a more comprehensive dashboard. Explore screenshots and demo videos of both apps' analytics dashboards to compare before making a decision.
Is one app significantly cheaper than the other?
The provided data does not include any information on pricing. Merchants need to check the Shopify App Store listings for current pricing plans and compare the features offered at each price point to determine which app offers the best value for their budget.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store