Newsletter pop up+GetResponse vs Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builderfor Shopify (2026)
In 2026, Shopify merchants choosing a form solution face a significant disparity between 'Newsletter pop up+GetResponse' and 'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder.' 'Newsletter pop up+GetResponse' appears to be a fledgling app, evidenced by its zero rating and zero reviews, suggesting it may be new or unpopular. Its purpose, based on its name, seems focused on newsletter signup forms and integration with GetResponse, potentially targeting merchants specifically seeking email marketing list growth. In contrast, 'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' is positioned as a versatile, AI-powered form builder capable of handling a wide array of form types beyond just newsletter signups. Its 5/5 rating (albeit with only 6 reviews) hints at strong initial satisfaction. 'Primy' differentiates itself through its AI-driven capabilities, file upload support, multi-step form creation, conditional logic, integration options with platforms like Google Sheets, Mailchimp, Klaviyo, and Zapier, and its flexibility to be embedded on various page types. It seems to cater to merchants needing more sophisticated form functionality, such as lead generation, order management, customer feedback, and wholesale inquiries. The breadth of its features suggests a more robust solution targeting businesses with diverse data collection needs.
At a Glance
Newsletter pop up+GetResponse
0 reviews
Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder
6 reviews
Detailed Overview
Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder
AI-powered form builder with file upload for contact form, order forms, survey forms, inquiry forms
Key Features
- Create multistep contact form, registration form, lead form, or custom form fast
- Build conditional forms with file upload, image upload, and checkbox forms
- Send form autoresponder emails and sync forms with Google Sheets or Mailchimp
- Embed forms on product pages, cart pages, home pages, or popup form blocks
- Create feedback forms, quote forms, support forms, wholesale forms, survey forms
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Newsletter pop up+GetResponse0/5 Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 6 |
Reviews Newsletter pop up+GetResponse0 Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder6 | ||
| AI Powered | No Data | Yes |
AI Powered Newsletter pop up+GetResponseNo Data Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderYes | ||
| File Upload Support | No Data | Yes |
File Upload Support Newsletter pop up+GetResponseNo Data Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderYes | ||
| Form Types | Newsletter Signup (Implied) | Contact, Registration, Lead, Order, Survey, Inquiry, Feedback, Support, Wholesale |
Form Types Newsletter pop up+GetResponseNewsletter Signup (Implied) Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderContact, Registration, Lead, Order, Survey, Inquiry, Feedback, Support, Wholesale | ||
| Integrations | GetResponse (Implied) | Google Sheets, Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Zapier, Shopify Customers |
Integrations Newsletter pop up+GetResponseGetResponse (Implied) Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderGoogle Sheets, Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Zapier, Shopify Customers | ||
| Ease of Use | Unknown | AI powered, which should make it easy to use |
Ease of Use Newsletter pop up+GetResponseUnknown Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderAI powered, which should make it easy to use | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants seeking simple newsletter sign-up forms integrated with GetResponse | Merchants needing diverse forms (contact, registration, etc.) with file upload and advanced integrations |
Target Merchant Newsletter pop up+GetResponseMerchants seeking simple newsletter sign-up forms integrated with GetResponse Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderMerchants needing diverse forms (contact, registration, etc.) with file upload and advanced integrations | ||
| Price | No Data | No Data |
Price Newsletter pop up+GetResponseNo Data Primy ‑ AI Custom Form BuilderNo Data | ||
Our Verdict
Based on available data, 'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' appears to be the stronger choice for most Shopify merchants in 2026 due to its broader feature set, AI assistance, and integrations. Its higher rating, even with limited reviews, suggests better user satisfaction. While 'Newsletter pop up+GetResponse' might suffice for businesses solely focused on simple newsletter acquisition with GetResponse, its lack of data makes it a riskier option.
However, the 'Primy' app's superiority isn't absolute. If a merchant's *only* need is a simple newsletter signup form and they are already deeply invested in the GetResponse ecosystem, 'Newsletter pop up+GetResponse', if it had any positive reviews, *might* be a lighter-weight alternative. But, given the lack of reviews, it represents a significant gamble compared to the more established and feature-rich Primy.
Common Questions
Which app is better for creating complex, multi-step forms?
'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' is significantly better for complex, multi-step forms due to its explicit feature set supporting multistep forms, conditional logic, and various field types, including file uploads.
Which app is easier to integrate with my existing email marketing platform?
It depends on your email marketing platform. 'Newsletter pop up+GetResponse' is designed for GetResponse. 'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' integrates with Mailchimp, Klaviyo, and Zapier, which can then connect to other platforms.
Which app is best for collecting files from customers through forms?
'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' is the only option that explicitly supports file uploads, making it ideal for collecting documents, images, or other files from customers.
Which app offers more diverse form types?
'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' offers a much wider range of form types, including contact forms, registration forms, lead forms, order forms, survey forms, inquiry forms, feedback forms, support forms, and wholesale forms.
Which app has a better reputation based on user reviews?
'Primy ‑ AI Custom Form Builder' has a significantly better reputation, with a 5/5 rating based on 6 reviews, compared to 'Newsletter pop up+GetResponse' which has a 0/5 rating and 0 reviews.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store