NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels and ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups both boast perfect 5-star ratings, indicating strong user satisfaction. However, ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups has significantly more reviews (89) than NotifyMe (17), suggesting a larger user base and more extensive real-world testing. This difference in review volume offers a greater degree of confidence in ProveSource's consistent performance and reliability in 2026. While both fall under the 'Pop-ups' category on Shopify, their intended functionalities likely differ. NotifyMe, suggested by its name, likely focuses on displaying warnings and labels, catering to stores needing to communicate critical information. ProveSource, on the other hand, probably specializes in sales pop-ups for social proof and urgency. Given the limited data, we can only infer the specific functionalities each app offers. However, it's clear that NotifyMe is positioned to help merchants highlight warnings, disclaimers, or special labels, aiming to improve compliance, transparency, or user experience. Conversely, ProveSource aims to leverage social proof by displaying recent sales and customer activity, targeting merchants focused on increasing conversions through FOMO and trust. The choice between the two heavily depends on the specific needs of the merchant, whether they need to warn or persuade their visitors.
17 reviews
89 reviews
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels5/5 ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 17 | 89 |
Reviews NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels17 ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups89 | ||
| Focus | Warnings and Labels | Sales Pop Ups |
Focus NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and LabelsWarnings and Labels ProveSource: Sales Pop UpsSales Pop Ups | ||
| Primary Goal | Inform & Alert | Convert & Persuade |
Primary Goal NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and LabelsInform & Alert ProveSource: Sales Pop UpsConvert & Persuade | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses needing compliance or product information display | Businesses focused on social proof and sales velocity |
Target Merchant NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and LabelsBusinesses needing compliance or product information display ProveSource: Sales Pop UpsBusinesses focused on social proof and sales velocity | ||
| Evidence of Reliability | Limited | Stronger |
Evidence of Reliability NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and LabelsLimited ProveSource: Sales Pop UpsStronger | ||
| Likely Ease of Use (inferred) | Potentially simpler due to a narrower focus | May have more configuration options for sales tactics |
Likely Ease of Use (inferred) NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and LabelsPotentially simpler due to a narrower focus ProveSource: Sales Pop UpsMay have more configuration options for sales tactics | ||
For merchants primarily concerned with clearly communicating important information, warnings, disclaimers, or product specifications, NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels is the likely better choice, assuming its features align with those needs. Its focused functionality could lead to a simpler setup and easier management.
If, however, the primary goal is to boost sales through social proof and create a sense of urgency, ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups appears to be the stronger contender. Its significantly higher number of reviews suggests a more robust and widely tested solution for implementing sales-focused pop-ups. ProveSource is the clearer frontrunner for driving conversions, assuming its feature set offers the functionalities expected of a sales pop-up app.
Based on the number of reviews, ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups likely has significantly more users than NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels.
Without specific feature information, it's difficult to say definitively. However, NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels' focused nature may suggest a simpler setup process.
ProveSource: Sales Pop Ups is likely better for directly increasing sales through social proof and urgency. NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels may indirectly impact sales through increased transparency and trust.
NotifyMe ‑ Warnings and Labels, given its name and assumed focus, is likely the better choice for highlighting necessary disclaimers or compliance information.
The provided data does not include pricing information. You would need to consult the Shopify App Store listings for each app to determine if they offer free plans or trials.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store