Offerly: Make an Offer Button! vs Quantity Discounts ‑ Selectorfor Shopify (2026)
Both Offerly: Make an Offer Button! and Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector are Pricing and Pricing optimization apps with high ratings (4.9/5). However, they serve distinct purposes. Offerly caters to merchants who want to allow customers to negotiate prices, potentially increasing conversions by engaging with price-sensitive buyers. Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector, on the other hand, focuses on volume-based discounts, product bundling, and BOGO offers to boost average order value and clear inventory. The former introduces an element of negotiation, while the latter automates discount structures based on purchase quantities or product combinations. The key differentiator lies in their core functionality. Offerly facilitates direct customer interaction regarding pricing, appealing to those seeking flexibility and a potential edge in competitive markets. Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector emphasizes pre-defined discount tiers and promotional offers, which can be implemented rapidly and scaled easily. One targets individual price sensitivity, while the other targets bulk purchasing behavior. This difference profoundly impacts their implementation and ultimate effectiveness in achieving revenue goals.
At a Glance
Offerly: Make an Offer Button!
49 reviews
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector
40 reviews
Detailed Overview
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector
Boost your sales revenue with product bundles, BOGO, BXGY, volume discounts, and free gifts.
Key Features
- Increase AOV — Create tiered volume discounts & bundling rules in minutes.
- Beautiful product widget — fully customizable to match your theme (no coding)
- Multiple currencies, swatches, restrict customers (B2B), and translation.
- 25 Automatic + Unlimited Manual Discounts.
- Buy one get one free (BOGO)
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating Offerly: Make an Offer Button!4.9/5 Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 49 | 40 |
Reviews Offerly: Make an Offer Button!49 Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector40 | ||
| Core Functionality | Make an Offer Button | Quantity/Bundle Discounts, BOGO |
Core Functionality Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Make an Offer Button Quantity Discounts ‑ SelectorQuantity/Bundle Discounts, BOGO | ||
| Target Audience | Merchants wanting flexible pricing | Merchants focusing on AOV and inventory clearing |
Target Audience Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Merchants wanting flexible pricing Quantity Discounts ‑ SelectorMerchants focusing on AOV and inventory clearing | ||
| Discount Customization | Limited, focuses on price negotiation | Extensive, tiered discounts, bundles, BOGO |
Discount Customization Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Limited, focuses on price negotiation Quantity Discounts ‑ SelectorExtensive, tiered discounts, bundles, BOGO | ||
| Theme Integration | Not explicitly mentioned, but assumed | Customizable widget to match theme (no coding) |
Theme Integration Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Not explicitly mentioned, but assumed Quantity Discounts ‑ SelectorCustomizable widget to match theme (no coding) | ||
| Automation | Less automation, relies on merchant response | 25 Automatic + Unlimited Manual Discounts |
Automation Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Less automation, relies on merchant response Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector25 Automatic + Unlimited Manual Discounts | ||
| Language Support | Not specified | Translation feature |
Language Support Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Not specified Quantity Discounts ‑ SelectorTranslation feature | ||
| Pricing Strategy | Negotiated Pricing | Volume & Bundled Pricing |
Pricing Strategy Offerly: Make an Offer Button!Negotiated Pricing Quantity Discounts ‑ SelectorVolume & Bundled Pricing | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector is the better choice for merchants aiming to increase AOV through volume discounts, product bundles, or promotional offers like BOGO. Its focus on automated discounts, customization, and B2B restrictions makes it a robust solution for scaling discount strategies. Offerly, on the other hand, is ideal for merchants in highly competitive markets or those selling unique or high-value items where price negotiation can be a key differentiator. If maximizing AOV is your goal, then Quantity Discounts – Selector is the recommended app. If you want direct customer interaction on pricing, then Offerly is a better fit.
Common Questions
Which app is better for clearing out old inventory?
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector, with its BOGO and discount tiers, is much better suited for quickly moving old stock.
Which app allows for more control over the look and feel of the discount widgets?
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector states that it has a fully customizable product widget that can be matched to your theme without coding.
Which app is better for B2B stores?
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector specifically mentions B2B support with its ability to restrict customers.
If I only want customers to be able to suggest a price, which app is the better choice?
Offerly: Make an Offer Button! is the only app that allows customers to suggest a price for a product.
Which app offers more automatic discount options?
Quantity Discounts ‑ Selector provides '25 Automatic + Unlimited Manual Discounts,' offering significant automation compared to Offerly.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store