OneReview: Use Online Reviews vs Review Collect by Scalyfor Shopify (2026)
OneReview: Use Online Reviews and Review Collect by Scaly both aim to improve sales by leveraging product reviews, but they approach the problem from different angles. OneReview focuses on aggregating existing reviews from across the web, including supplier sites and major retailers, addressing the problem of products lacking initial reviews. This app positions itself as a quick and easy solution for merchants who need to populate their product pages with social proof immediately. Review Collect by Scaly, on the other hand, presumably focuses on collecting new reviews directly from customers (though specifics are missing from the prompt). It's not explicitly stated how they collect these reviews. The key differentiator lies in the *source* of the reviews. OneReview offers a shortcut by repurposing existing online reviews, providing immediate value but potentially sacrificing some control over content and relevance. Review Collect by Scaly likely aims for higher-quality, directly relevant reviews specific to your customer base, but requires time and effort to build up a sufficient volume. The choice depends on the merchant's specific needs: instant review presence versus cultivating a dedicated customer review base.
At a Glance
OneReview: Use Online Reviews
10 reviews
Review Collect by Scaly
79 reviews
Detailed Overview
OneReview: Use Online Reviews
Losing sales because your products are missing reviews?
Key Features
- Display review summaries & star ratings on product and collection pages
- Customizable widgets - default matches store branding
- Pair with any reviews app including Judge.me, Loox and Stamped
- One Free White-Glove Customization
- 5-minute set up
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating OneReview: Use Online Reviews5/5 Review Collect by Scaly5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 10 | 79 |
Reviews OneReview: Use Online Reviews10 Review Collect by Scaly79 | ||
| Review Source | Aggregates existing online reviews | Presumably collects new customer reviews (unclear) |
Review Source OneReview: Use Online ReviewsAggregates existing online reviews Review Collect by ScalyPresumably collects new customer reviews (unclear) | ||
| Setup Time | 5-minute set up | Unknown |
Setup Time OneReview: Use Online Reviews5-minute set up Review Collect by ScalyUnknown | ||
| Customization | Customizable widgets, one free white-glove customization | Unknown |
Customization OneReview: Use Online ReviewsCustomizable widgets, one free white-glove customization Review Collect by ScalyUnknown | ||
| Primary Benefit | Instant review presence | Building organic customer reviews (assumed) |
Primary Benefit OneReview: Use Online ReviewsInstant review presence Review Collect by ScalyBuilding organic customer reviews (assumed) | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants with products lacking reviews or wanting to bootstrap social proof. | Merchants prioritizing authentic customer reviews and building a long-term review strategy. |
Target Merchant OneReview: Use Online ReviewsMerchants with products lacking reviews or wanting to bootstrap social proof. Review Collect by ScalyMerchants prioritizing authentic customer reviews and building a long-term review strategy. | ||
| Value Proposition | Quickly add social proof and increase sales | Build trust and improve SEO with genuine customer feedback (assumed) |
Value Proposition OneReview: Use Online ReviewsQuickly add social proof and increase sales Review Collect by ScalyBuild trust and improve SEO with genuine customer feedback (assumed) | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants struggling with empty review sections and needing a quick boost in social proof, OneReview: Use Online Reviews seems like the better option. Its ability to source reviews from other sites offers an immediate solution. It is perfect for new stores, products without many existing reviews, or when the merchant's marketing budget cannot support a full review collection strategy in its initial phase.
If a merchant prioritizes authenticity and is willing to invest time and effort in building a dedicated base of customer-generated reviews, Review Collect by Scaly is likely the better choice, though the actual benefits are hard to confirm given how little information is provided about its function. It's geared towards long-term growth, increased customer loyalty, and better SEO through genuine customer feedback. However, the higher number of reviews despite the lack of information available is promising.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
OneReview explicitly states a 5-minute setup, making it likely faster to deploy. Review Collect by Scaly lacks this information.
Which app provides more authentic reviews?
Review Collect by Scaly likely offers more authentic reviews if it does indeed collect direct customer reviews. OneReview sources reviews from external sites, which may lack the personalized context of direct customer experiences. Although, sourcing reviews from major retailers may add credibility as well.
Which app is better for new stores?
OneReview is likely better for new stores needing immediate social proof. It addresses the 'empty store' problem directly. Building a review base with Review Collect by Scaly may take too long to impact early sales.
Which app offers more control over review content?
Review Collect by Scaly likely offers more control, as you can manage and potentially moderate customer-submitted reviews. OneReview is limited by the content available on external sites.
Does OneReview collect reviews from *any* site, or only those selling the same product?
OneReview states that it uses reviews from "other sites where your product is sold or reviewed including suppliers, review publishers, and major retailers like Amazon or Best Buy." It only indicates the same product or reviews, not reviews from *any* site.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store