Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App vs Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Bannersfor Shopify (2026)
Orderly Emails - Templates App and Pop Convert - Pop Ups, Banners both aim to improve the Shopify merchant's marketing efforts, but they approach the problem from vastly different angles. Orderly Emails focuses specifically on enhancing the branded experience and marketing effectiveness of transactional emails sent by Shopify (order confirmations, shipping updates, abandoned cart reminders). It allows merchants to customize these emails with logos, colors, discounts, and product recommendations to drive sales and brand recognition through existing communication channels. Pop Convert, on the other hand, centers around on-site engagement through pop-ups and banners. It aims to increase subscriber lists, promote specific products or announcements, and drive traffic to desired pages within the store. Its target audience seeks tools to capture leads and directly influence visitor behavior while they are actively browsing. The main distinction lies in where and when the apps engage with customers: Orderly Emails focuses on post-purchase (or abandoned cart) email communication, while Pop Convert focuses on active website visitors through visual and interactive elements.
At a Glance
Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App
512 reviews
Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Banners
8,449 reviews
Detailed Overview
Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App
Customizable, branded email templates for your store. Upgrade your email marketing & order emails.
Key Features
- Upgrade your email marketing with beautiful, branded email templates for Shopify
- Add logos, colors and fonts to your email templates with The Magic Designer
- Sell more by adding discounts, product recommendations & upsells to your emails
- Multi-currency emails, quick translation & country settings are all supported
- Email marketing made easy: No coding or design skills needed for quick results!
Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Banners
Use popups and banners to collect emails and phone numbers from visitors and boost sales!
Key Features
- Smart Bars to show specific and important information all the time
- Pop Ups to capture leads, announce a new coupon, or just shoot a message
- Share a coupon, an announcement, or drive traffic to a special link
- Fully customizable styles for all pop ups, smart bars, and more
- Drag n' Drop editor to create any combination you want with your widgets
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App4.9/5 Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Banners4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 512 | 8449 |
Reviews Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App512 Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Banners8449 | ||
| Primary Function | Customizable Email Templates | Pop-ups and Banners |
Primary Function Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppCustomizable Email Templates Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersPop-ups and Banners | ||
| Target Audience | Merchants wanting to improve branded email marketing | Merchants focused on on-site lead generation and promotions |
Target Audience Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppMerchants wanting to improve branded email marketing Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersMerchants focused on on-site lead generation and promotions | ||
| Key Features | Magic Designer, Product Recommendations in Emails, Multi-currency support | Smart Bars, Drag n' Drop Editor, Webhooks |
Key Features Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppMagic Designer, Product Recommendations in Emails, Multi-currency support Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersSmart Bars, Drag n' Drop Editor, Webhooks | ||
| Ease of Use | No coding required, quick results | Drag n' Drop editor for customization |
Ease of Use Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppNo coding required, quick results Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersDrag n' Drop editor for customization | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase sales and brand loyalty through better email communication | Grow subscriber base and drive traffic to specific store areas |
Value Proposition Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppIncrease sales and brand loyalty through better email communication Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersGrow subscriber base and drive traffic to specific store areas | ||
| Customer Engagement | Passive (through automated emails) | Active (through website interaction) |
Customer Engagement Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppPassive (through automated emails) Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersActive (through website interaction) | ||
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants primarily concerned with optimizing their existing transactional emails and leveraging them as a marketing tool to boost sales and brand loyalty, Orderly Emails is the clear choice. Its focus on email customization and integration of marketing elements within order confirmations and shipping updates provides a direct path to improved customer engagement and revenue generation.
Conversely, merchants prioritizing on-site lead generation, immediate promotion of offers, and driving traffic to specific pages should opt for Pop Convert. Its pop-ups and banners offer a more proactive approach to engaging with visitors and converting them into subscribers or customers. A store looking to capture leads and increase conversions through strategic website interaction would likely prefer Pop Convert.
Common Questions
Which app requires more technical skill?
Neither app appears to require advanced technical skills. Orderly Emails boasts 'no coding or design skills needed,' while Pop Convert offers a 'Drag n' Drop editor,' suggesting a user-friendly interface.
Can both apps be used together?
Yes, both apps can be used together as they address different aspects of marketing. Orderly Emails enhances email communication, while Pop Convert focuses on on-site engagement. Using both creates a more holistic approach.
Which app is better for a new Shopify store?
Pop Convert might be more immediately beneficial for a new store aiming to quickly build an email list and promote awareness. Orderly Emails' value might be more apparent once the store has established a consistent order flow.
Which app is best for A/B testing marketing messages?
Pop Convert's pop-up functionality lends itself more readily to A/B testing different offers, headlines, and visuals to optimize conversion rates. While Orderly Emails provides customization, A/B testing within that platform isn't explicitly mentioned.
Does either app integrate directly with Klaviyo or Mailchimp?
While neither description explicitly mentions Klaviyo or Mailchimp integration, Pop Convert's reference to 'webhooks' suggests the possibility of connecting to external platforms like email marketing services. Orderly Emails is focused on the Shopify email system itself.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store