Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App vs Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop Upfor Shopify (2026)
Orderly Emails - Templates App and Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop Up are both highly-rated Shopify apps (4.9/5), but they address different needs within e-commerce. Orderly Emails focuses on enhancing the post-purchase customer experience and brand consistency by providing customizable email templates for order confirmations, shipping updates, and abandoned carts. Its strength lies in improving brand perception and potentially driving repeat sales through professionally designed transactional emails. It targets merchants looking to elevate their brand image and leverage email notifications as a marketing opportunity. Poptin, on the other hand, centers around on-site conversion optimization. It provides tools to capture leads, reduce cart abandonment, and drive immediate sales through popups, forms, and exit-intent technology. The primary difference lies in their focus: Orderly Emails optimizes the *outgoing* email communication, primarily after a purchase or cart abandonment event, while Poptin focuses on optimizing the *on-site* experience to prevent abandonment and encourage immediate purchase. Orderly Emails offers a 'Magic Designer' and emphasizes ease of use without coding skills, making it accessible to merchants with limited technical expertise. Poptin offers A/B testing and analytics to optimize popup performance, catering to merchants who actively want to test and refine their conversion strategies.
At a Glance
Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App
512 reviews
Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop Up
286 reviews
Detailed Overview
Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App
Customizable, branded email templates for your store. Upgrade your email marketing & order emails.
Key Features
- Upgrade your email marketing with beautiful, branded email templates for Shopify
- Add logos, colors and fonts to your email templates with The Magic Designer
- Sell more by adding discounts, product recommendations & upsells to your emails
- Multi-currency emails, quick translation & country settings are all supported
- Email marketing made easy: No coding or design skills needed for quick results!
Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop Up
Drive sales with Email& SMS pop ups, spin wheel popups, forms, exit intent popup & discount pop up
Key Features
- Show exit intent pop ups, email pop up, coupon popups, opt ins & spin the wheel
- Create announcement bars, popup message, & email forms using no-code popup maker
- Integrate newsletter popups, website forms & sticky bars to your email/CRM tools
- Optimize with popup triggers & targeting rules to convert quality leads
- Improve your Shopify SMS pop up & email popup forms using AB testing & analytics
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App4.9/5 Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop Up4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 512 | 286 |
Reviews Orderly Emails ‑ Templates App512 Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop Up286 | ||
| Core Function | Customizable email templates | Popups & forms for lead capture/conversion |
Core Function Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppCustomizable email templates Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpPopups & forms for lead capture/conversion | ||
| Target Email | Order, Shipping, Abandoned Cart Notifications | Newsletter, Exit Intent, Discount Offers via popups |
Target Email Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppOrder, Shipping, Abandoned Cart Notifications Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpNewsletter, Exit Intent, Discount Offers via popups | ||
| Key Feature: Design & Customization | Magic Designer, logo/color/font customization | No-code popup maker, customizable templates |
Key Feature: Design & Customization Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppMagic Designer, logo/color/font customization Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpNo-code popup maker, customizable templates | ||
| Key Feature: Optimization | Product recommendations & upsells in emails | A/B testing, triggers & targeting, analytics |
Key Feature: Optimization Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppProduct recommendations & upsells in emails Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpA/B testing, triggers & targeting, analytics | ||
| Ease of Use | No coding required | No-code popup maker |
Ease of Use Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppNo coding required Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpNo-code popup maker | ||
| Value Proposition | Improved brand image, repeat sales through better email experience | Increased lead capture, reduced cart abandonment, higher conversion rates |
Value Proposition Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppImproved brand image, repeat sales through better email experience Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpIncreased lead capture, reduced cart abandonment, higher conversion rates | ||
| SMS capabilities | Not specified | SMS popup |
SMS capabilities Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppNot specified Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpSMS popup | ||
| Multi-currency | Supported | Not Specified |
Multi-currency Orderly Emails ‑ Templates AppSupported Poptin Exit Popup Email Pop UpNot Specified | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing brand consistency and enhanced post-purchase communication, Orderly Emails is the better choice. Its focus on customizable email templates and ease of use makes it ideal for businesses aiming to create a polished brand experience. If the merchant's goal is to reduce on-site cart abandonment, increase immediate sales with promotions and capture leads with welcome offers, then Poptin is the superior option. Its strengths lie in the tools and targeting options needed to actively influence a visitor’s on-site behavior. A store looking for direct on-site conversions and SMS marketing is more suited to Poptin.
Common Questions
Which app is better for improving my brand image?
Orderly Emails is more focused on improving brand image by creating consistent and professional-looking email templates that reflect your brand's style. Poptin can contribute by creating visually appealing popups, but it’s more focused on driving immediate action rather than brand building.
Which app is better for reducing cart abandonment?
Both apps address cart abandonment, but in different ways. Orderly Emails sends branded abandoned cart emails, while Poptin focuses on preventing abandonment on the site itself with exit-intent popups and offers.
Do I need coding skills to use either of these apps?
No, both apps are designed to be user-friendly and do not require coding skills. Orderly Emails emphasizes its 'Magic Designer,' while Poptin highlights its 'no-code popup maker'.
Can I personalize the emails/popups based on customer behavior?
Orderly Emails enables personalization by allowing you to add discounts, product recommendations, and upsells to emails. Poptin enables personalization by using triggers and targeting rules based on customer behavior, like exit intent.
Which app offers analytics and A/B testing?
Poptin offers A/B testing and analytics to optimize popup performance. Orderly Emails does not explicitly mention A/B testing, but focuses on customization and design for improved email performance.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store