OrderProtect vs Sam Shipping Protection Upsellfor Shopify (2026)
Both OrderProtect and Sam Shipping Protection Upsell aim to empower Shopify merchants with tools to offer order protection to customers, retaining the revenue generated from protection fees. While both apps have a perfect 5/5 rating, Sam Shipping Protection Upsell has more than double the number of reviews (24) compared to OrderProtect (11), suggesting greater adoption or a longer presence in the market. They both advertise that the merchant keeps all the additional revenue generated. They target merchants looking to increase revenue and enhance customer experience by reducing anxieties around lost, stolen, or damaged goods during shipping.
At a Glance
OrderProtect
11 reviews
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell
24 reviews
Detailed Overview
OrderProtect
Offer customers the option to pay an additional fee at checkout to protect their order.
Key Features
- Offer Order Protection
- Generate Additional Revenue
- Easy to use Dashboard
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell
Take Control of Shipping Protection — Build Trust & Create a Better Shopping Experience
Key Features
- Flexible protection plans: fixed fees, order ranges, or percentage-based options
- Auto-add to cart & auto-fulfillment
- Customizable widget that matches your brand style
- Easy self-serve claims portal for customers
- Supports multiple languages and currencies
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating OrderProtect5/5 Sam Shipping Protection Upsell5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 11 | 24 |
Reviews OrderProtect11 Sam Shipping Protection Upsell24 | ||
| Protection Plans | Single Option | Flexible (fixed, ranges, percentage) |
Protection Plans OrderProtectSingle Option Sam Shipping Protection UpsellFlexible (fixed, ranges, percentage) | ||
| Customer Claims | Not explicitly mentioned | Easy self-serve portal |
Customer Claims OrderProtectNot explicitly mentioned Sam Shipping Protection UpsellEasy self-serve portal | ||
| Customization | Easy to use Dashboard (assumed basic) | Customizable widget to match brand |
Customization OrderProtectEasy to use Dashboard (assumed basic) Sam Shipping Protection UpsellCustomizable widget to match brand | ||
| Automation | Not explicitly mentioned | Auto-add to cart & auto-fulfillment |
Automation OrderProtectNot explicitly mentioned Sam Shipping Protection UpsellAuto-add to cart & auto-fulfillment | ||
| Internationalization | Not mentioned | Supports multiple languages and currencies |
Internationalization OrderProtectNot mentioned Sam Shipping Protection UpsellSupports multiple languages and currencies | ||
| Value Proposition | Additional revenue, improved customer experience | More profit, happier customers, better shopping experience |
Value Proposition OrderProtectAdditional revenue, improved customer experience Sam Shipping Protection UpsellMore profit, happier customers, better shopping experience | ||
Our Verdict
If a merchant seeks a simple, plug-and-play solution for offering basic order protection and generating additional revenue, OrderProtect might suffice. However, for merchants prioritizing a more sophisticated and customizable protection program with advanced features like flexible pricing, self-serve claims, brand matching, internationalization, and automation, Sam Shipping Protection Upsell appears to be the better choice. The higher number of reviews and features suggests that Sam Shipping Protection Upsell is a more robust and mature app.
Common Questions
Which app offers more flexibility in setting protection fees?
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell offers flexible protection plans, including fixed fees, order ranges, or percentage-based options. OrderProtect doesn't specify the fee structure but appears to offer a single option.
Which app is better suited for international stores?
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell explicitly supports multiple languages and currencies, making it the better choice for international stores. OrderProtect doesn't mention any internationalization features.
Which app provides a dedicated claims portal for customers?
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell offers an easy self-serve claims portal for customers. OrderProtect doesn't explicitly mention how customers can file claims.
Which app seems easier to integrate into my Shopify store?
Both apps claim easy integration. OrderProtect mentions a seamless integration and an easy to use dashboard. Sam Shipping Protection Upsell mentions it will fit naturally into your store. It is hard to evaluate ease of use without testing both apps.
Which app emphasizes brand alignment?
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell emphasizes brand alignment by offering a customizable widget that matches your brand style, allowing a more seamless integration with your store's design.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store