Pay What You Want and Singleton | Advanced Discounts represent fundamentally different approaches to pricing strategy on Shopify. Pay What You Want focuses on flexible pricing and customer empowerment by allowing customers to suggest prices or make donations. This strategy appeals to merchants looking to foster a sense of fairness and potentially tap into a broader customer base by catering to different willingness-to-pay levels. It highlights features like customizable 'Ask Your Price' buttons and price range limits. Singleton | Advanced Discounts, on the other hand, centers on driving sales through structured discounting mechanisms. It provides a wide range of options for creating automatic or code-based discounts tailored to specific customer segments, product quantities, or cart values. Its core value lies in motivating customers to increase their spending and improving conversion rates through clear and visible discounts displayed in the cart and checkout process. The advanced options such as B2B discounts and volume discounts position it as a powerful tool for merchants seeking a data-driven discounting strategy.
41 reviews
31 reviews
With the Pay What You Want app, Give a free hand to customers who can make an offer & donation
Create automatic or code-based discounts with advanced options. Motivate customers to buy more.
| Rating | 4.3/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Pay What You Want4.3/5 Singleton | Advanced Discounts5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 41 | 31 |
Reviews Pay What You Want41 Singleton | Advanced Discounts31 | ||
| Pricing Strategy | Customer-driven, flexible pricing | Merchant-driven, structured discounts |
Pricing Strategy Pay What You WantCustomer-driven, flexible pricing Singleton | Advanced DiscountsMerchant-driven, structured discounts | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants seeking to offer flexible pricing and accept donations, possibly mission-driven businesses | Merchants looking to boost sales through strategic discounts and targeted offers, possibly B2B or wholesale sellers |
Target Merchant Pay What You WantMerchants seeking to offer flexible pricing and accept donations, possibly mission-driven businesses Singleton | Advanced DiscountsMerchants looking to boost sales through strategic discounts and targeted offers, possibly B2B or wholesale sellers | ||
| Key Feature | Customer price suggestion & donations | Volume discounts and customer segmentation |
Key Feature Pay What You WantCustomer price suggestion & donations Singleton | Advanced DiscountsVolume discounts and customer segmentation | ||
| Ease of Use (Inferred) | Likely simpler setup due to fewer features | Potentially steeper learning curve due to complex discount rules |
Ease of Use (Inferred) Pay What You WantLikely simpler setup due to fewer features Singleton | Advanced DiscountsPotentially steeper learning curve due to complex discount rules | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase sales by offering flexible pricing, enhance customer loyalty by enabling donations. | Increase sales by motivating customers to buy more through various discounts and promotions. |
Value Proposition Pay What You WantIncrease sales by offering flexible pricing, enhance customer loyalty by enabling donations. Singleton | Advanced DiscountsIncrease sales by motivating customers to buy more through various discounts and promotions. | ||
| Discount Visibility | Ask your Price/Make an Offer button | Visible in cart drawers, cart, and checkout pages |
Discount Visibility Pay What You WantAsk your Price/Make an Offer button Singleton | Advanced DiscountsVisible in cart drawers, cart, and checkout pages | ||
Choosing between Pay What You Want and Singleton | Advanced Discounts hinges on your business goals and target audience. If you prioritize customer empowerment, accepting donations, and exploring a unique pricing model, Pay What You Want is a suitable choice. It is particularly attractive for businesses with a strong social mission or those seeking to cater to customers with varying price sensitivities.
However, if your primary objective is to strategically increase sales through discounts, targeted offers, and volume-based incentives, Singleton | Advanced Discounts is the superior option. Its robust discounting features and customer segmentation capabilities make it ideal for merchants focused on maximizing revenue and optimizing their pricing strategy based on data and customer behavior. While Pay What You Want has an interesting approach, it's more niche and potentially riskier than the revenue-driving focus of Singleton | Advanced Discounts.
Pay What You Want likely offers a simpler setup process due to its fewer features and straightforward approach. Singleton | Advanced Discounts, with its multitude of discount options and rules, may require more configuration and a steeper learning curve.
Technically, yes, but it's likely not advisable. Using both simultaneously could confuse customers and lead to unintended pricing outcomes. The strategies are mutually exclusive.
Singleton | Advanced Discounts may be more beneficial for a new store trying to attract customers and increase initial sales through promotions and discounts. Pay What You Want is better suited for established stores with loyal customers or a strong mission.
While the descriptions don't explicitly state analytics capabilities, Singleton | Advanced Discounts, given its focus on discounts and segmentation, likely offers more data-driven insights into customer behavior and discount effectiveness.
Pay What You Want emphasizes customer empowerment and goodwill by allowing customers to suggest prices and contribute through donations, potentially fostering a stronger sense of loyalty.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store