Payflow: COD & Payment Methods vs Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsellfor Shopify (2026)
Payflow: COD & Payment Methods and Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell both operate within the Checkout and Cart Customization categories on Shopify, but they serve fundamentally different purposes. Payflow focuses on streamlining the payment and delivery process, specifically Cash on Delivery (COD), and offering robust control over payment method presentation. Upcart, conversely, is designed to increase Average Order Value (AOV) and reduce cart abandonment by enhancing the cart drawer experience with upsells, cross-sells, and customizable design elements. Payflow caters to merchants who need precise control over their payment options and delivery methods, particularly those heavily reliant on COD. Its strength lies in its advanced condition-based rules for hiding, renaming, and reordering payment/delivery options. Upcart, on the other hand, targets merchants looking to maximize revenue through strategic cart optimization. Its focus is on visually appealing and engaging cart drawers that encourage customers to add more items and complete their purchase. The target audience for Upcart leans towards visually-driven brands in sectors like fashion, food & beverage, and beauty, according to its description.
At a Glance
Payflow: COD & Payment Methods
110 reviews
Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell
648 reviews
Detailed Overview
Payflow: COD & Payment Methods
Integrate COD with fee. Customize Payment & Delivery methods: hide, rename, and reorder as needed
Key Features
- Streamline COD effortlessly, eliminating post-purchase edits and custom products
- Easily hide, rename, reorder payment & delivery methods based on your conditions
- Use conditions such as total price, weight, tags, products, address and more
- Advanced AND/OR condition tool enabling seamless integration of multiple rules
- Built using native Shopify functions for a faster and more integrated experience
Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell
Upcart — custom slide cart with full design control to increase AOV and reduce cart abandonment
Key Features
- Increase AOV with in-cart upsells and cross-sells for frequently bought items
- Fully customize cart design with custom templates using HTML, CSS, and JSX
- Incentivize higher spend with rewards, progress bars, and free shipping goals
- Boost conversions with in-cart discounts and free gifts
- Reduce friction with a sticky slide cart that stays visible across your store
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.8/5 | 4.7/5 |
Rating Payflow: COD & Payment Methods4.8/5 Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell4.7/5 | ||
| Reviews | 110 | 648 |
Reviews Payflow: COD & Payment Methods110 Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell648 | ||
| Core Functionality | Payment/Delivery Customization & COD Management | Cart Drawer Upselling & AOV Optimization |
Core Functionality Payflow: COD & Payment MethodsPayment/Delivery Customization & COD Management Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart UpsellCart Drawer Upselling & AOV Optimization | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Advanced AND/OR condition tool for payment methods | In-cart upsells and cross-sells |
Key Feature 1 Payflow: COD & Payment MethodsAdvanced AND/OR condition tool for payment methods Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart UpsellIn-cart upsells and cross-sells | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Streamlined COD with fee | Fully customizable cart design (HTML, CSS, JSX) |
Key Feature 2 Payflow: COD & Payment MethodsStreamlined COD with fee Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart UpsellFully customizable cart design (HTML, CSS, JSX) | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants needing granular payment/delivery control, COD focused | DTC brands (fashion, food, beauty) seeking AOV increase |
Target Merchant Payflow: COD & Payment MethodsMerchants needing granular payment/delivery control, COD focused Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart UpsellDTC brands (fashion, food, beauty) seeking AOV increase | ||
| Ease of Use Focus | Seamless integration using native Shopify functions | Customizable templates and design control |
Ease of Use Focus Payflow: COD & Payment MethodsSeamless integration using native Shopify functions Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart UpsellCustomizable templates and design control | ||
| Value Proposition | Simplified checkout & reduced fulfillment issues for COD orders | Increased AOV, reduced cart abandonment, enhanced customer experience |
Value Proposition Payflow: COD & Payment MethodsSimplified checkout & reduced fulfillment issues for COD orders Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart UpsellIncreased AOV, reduced cart abandonment, enhanced customer experience | ||
Our Verdict
The choice between Payflow and Upcart depends entirely on the merchant's primary objective. If the priority is to optimize and customize the payment and delivery process, especially COD handling, Payflow is the clear choice. Its robust conditional logic offers significant flexibility in tailoring the checkout experience.
However, if the goal is to boost revenue by enhancing the cart experience with upsells, cross-sells, and a visually appealing design, Upcart is the better option. Upcart's focus on cart optimization makes it ideal for brands seeking to increase AOV and reduce cart abandonment. For merchants needing both, integrating both apps *could* be considered, but the potential overlap and increased complexity should be carefully evaluated.
Common Questions
Which app is better for managing Cash on Delivery (COD) payments?
Payflow: COD & Payment Methods is specifically designed for managing COD payments. It offers features to streamline the COD process, add fees, and eliminate post-purchase order edits.
Which app offers more customization options for the cart's appearance?
Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell offers significantly more customization options for the cart's appearance. It allows full design control using HTML, CSS, and JSX, enabling merchants to create a unique and branded cart experience.
Which app is designed to increase the average order value (AOV)?
Upcart is designed to increase AOV through in-cart upsells, cross-sells, rewards, and free shipping goals.
Does Payflow offer any tools to increase AOV?
While Payflow focuses primarily on payment and delivery optimization, its customization features *could* indirectly influence AOV (e.g., highlighting specific payment options), but it's not its primary function.
Which app has more user reviews?
Upcart—Cart Drawer Cart Upsell has significantly more user reviews (648) compared to Payflow: COD & Payment Methods (110), suggesting a potentially wider user base and more extensive real-world experience data.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store