Pop Convert - Pop Ups, Banners and Swym Wishlist Plus both fall under the Marketing and Email Marketing categories on the Shopify app store, but they address fundamentally different marketing needs. Pop Convert focuses on immediate conversion and lead generation through pop-ups, banners, and smart bars designed to capture email addresses, announce promotions, and drive traffic within the store. Its strength lies in its visual customization, ease of use (drag-and-drop editor), and ability to deliver timely messages. It's for merchants prioritizing acquiring new customers and boosting short-term sales. Swym Wishlist Plus, on the other hand, centers on enhancing customer retention and engagement through wishlists. It focuses on building a connection with customers, allowing them to save preferred products, share wishlists, and receive notifications about price drops or restocks. Its strength lies in personalization, customer retention, and integration with various email marketing services. It also has introduced customer accounts to track wishlists, browsing activity, and offers. This makes it ideal for merchants focused on improving long-term customer relationships and reducing cart abandonment. The choice between the two depends heavily on the merchant's primary objective: acquiring new customers versus retaining existing ones. They also differ in their implementation; Pop Convert requires design and ongoing monitoring of popup performance, while Swym primarily requires setting up email integrations and customization of wishlist appearance.
8,449 reviews
1,400 reviews
Use popups and banners to collect emails and phone numbers from visitors and boost sales!
Boost sales with an easy-to-set-up Wishlist for all customer touchpoints. Top integrations included.
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Banners4.9/5 Swym Wishlist Plus4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 8449 | 1400 |
Reviews Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, Banners8449 Swym Wishlist Plus1400 | ||
| Primary Function | Lead generation and immediate sales boosts via pop-ups and banners | Customer retention and engagement through wishlists |
Primary Function Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersLead generation and immediate sales boosts via pop-ups and banners Swym Wishlist PlusCustomer retention and engagement through wishlists | ||
| Key Feature - Customization | Fully customizable styles and drag-n-drop editor | Seamless theme integration and wishlist sharing options |
Key Feature - Customization Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersFully customizable styles and drag-n-drop editor Swym Wishlist PlusSeamless theme integration and wishlist sharing options | ||
| Key Feature - Messaging | Announcements, coupons, traffic driving | Price drop, restock, and low stock email alerts |
Key Feature - Messaging Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersAnnouncements, coupons, traffic driving Swym Wishlist PlusPrice drop, restock, and low stock email alerts | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses prioritizing short-term sales and email list growth | Businesses prioritizing customer loyalty and reducing cart abandonment |
Target Merchant Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersBusinesses prioritizing short-term sales and email list growth Swym Wishlist PlusBusinesses prioritizing customer loyalty and reducing cart abandonment | ||
| Ease of Use | Drag & Drop Editor | Simple Installation (<5 Mins) |
Ease of Use Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersDrag & Drop Editor Swym Wishlist PlusSimple Installation (<5 Mins) | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase conversion rates and grow subscriber base | Reduce cart abandonment and improve customer loyalty through personalized experiences |
Value Proposition Pop Convert ‑ Pop Ups, BannersIncrease conversion rates and grow subscriber base Swym Wishlist PlusReduce cart abandonment and improve customer loyalty through personalized experiences | ||
If your main goal is to rapidly grow your email list, announce promotions effectively, and drive immediate sales through targeted messaging, Pop Convert - Pop Ups, Banners is the superior choice. Its drag-and-drop editor allows for easy creation of engaging pop-ups and banners without coding knowledge.
However, if you're more focused on cultivating customer loyalty, reducing cart abandonment, and providing a personalized shopping experience, Swym Wishlist Plus is the better investment. Its focus on wishlists, personalized customer accounts, and automated alerts makes it a powerful tool for fostering customer relationships and increasing lifetime value. Businesses with high repeat purchase rates will likely see more ROI from Swym.
According to the descriptions, Swym Wishlist Plus claims to integrate in less than 5 minutes while Pop Convert doesn't provide a setup time, focusing instead on ease of use for its editor. Swym is likely easier for initial configuration.
Pop Convert mentions webhooks, implying integration capability, while Swym Wishlist Plus explicitly mentions integration with leading email services for sending alerts. Swym likely has more comprehensive and pre-built email integrations.
Pop Convert is explicitly designed for delivering time-sensitive promotions through pop-ups and smart bars, making it more suitable for running flash sales compared to Swym Wishlist Plus, which focuses on longer-term customer engagement.
Swym Wishlist Plus includes detailed reports on shopper behavior related to wishlists. Pop Convert does not explicitly mention detailed analytics in its description; however, the ability to create specific campaign URLs suggests basic tracking is possible.
Swym Wishlist Plus specifically mentions support for anonymous wishlists, enabling users to save items without creating an account. Pop Convert focuses more on capturing user information (email/phone) to create accounts or add users to a marketing list.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store