PostCo Returns & Exchanges vs Simply Shipping Protectionfor Shopify (2026)
PostCo Returns & Exchanges and Simply Shipping Protection cater to different aspects of returns and order security on Shopify. PostCo focuses on streamlining the returns and exchanges process itself, which is not described in detail. Simply Shipping Protection, on the other hand, is about proactively managing shipping risks by allowing merchants to offer shipping protection to customers. This allows merchants to retain control of revenue and claims management, essentially providing their own insurance against lost, stolen, or damaged packages. Simply Shipping Protection empowers merchants to build their own shipping protection program, customize pricing and placement of protection offers, and manage claims directly, offering more control. It's geared toward merchants who want to retain full revenue from shipping protection and manage their own claim processes. PostCo, with a slightly higher rating but fewer reviews, seems focused primarily on facilitating returns and exchanges, suggesting a more hands-off approach for merchants. The target user of Simply Shipping Protection is a business who wants full control and ownership of their shipping protection strategy, while the user of PostCo Returns & Exchanges values a more automated and managed return experience.
At a Glance
PostCo Returns & Exchanges
79 reviews
Simply Shipping Protection
127 reviews
Detailed Overview
Simply Shipping Protection
Let customers protect their orders while you keep the full fee and manage claims your way.
Key Features
- Set fixed or percentage (%) pricing and show toggle with opt-in popup
- Customize and show widgets on cart, side cart, checkout, or post-purchase
- Let customers file claims with a widget placed on any store page
- Settle claims with refunds, reorders, or credits using built-in integrations
- Track revenue and claims in one clean dashboard
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.7/5 |
Rating PostCo Returns & Exchanges5/5 Simply Shipping Protection4.7/5 | ||
| Reviews | 79 | 127 |
Reviews PostCo Returns & Exchanges79 Simply Shipping Protection127 | ||
| Focus | Returns & Exchanges | Shipping Protection |
Focus PostCo Returns & ExchangesReturns & Exchanges Simply Shipping ProtectionShipping Protection | ||
| Pricing Control | Likely Standard Pricing | Merchant-Controlled Fixed or Percentage |
Pricing Control PostCo Returns & ExchangesLikely Standard Pricing Simply Shipping ProtectionMerchant-Controlled Fixed or Percentage | ||
| Claims Management | Likely Managed by PostCo | Merchant-Managed |
Claims Management PostCo Returns & ExchangesLikely Managed by PostCo Simply Shipping ProtectionMerchant-Managed | ||
| Integration Locations | Likely limited to returns pages | Cart, Side Cart, Checkout, Post-Purchase |
Integration Locations PostCo Returns & ExchangesLikely limited to returns pages Simply Shipping ProtectionCart, Side Cart, Checkout, Post-Purchase | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants seeking a streamlined returns process | Merchants desiring control over shipping protection revenue & claims |
Target Merchant Type PostCo Returns & ExchangesMerchants seeking a streamlined returns process Simply Shipping ProtectionMerchants desiring control over shipping protection revenue & claims | ||
| Ease of Use | Potentially simpler due to managed service | Potentially requires more setup due to customization options |
Ease of Use PostCo Returns & ExchangesPotentially simpler due to managed service Simply Shipping ProtectionPotentially requires more setup due to customization options | ||
| Value Proposition | Simplified returns and exchanges | Revenue retention and direct claims management |
Value Proposition PostCo Returns & ExchangesSimplified returns and exchanges Simply Shipping ProtectionRevenue retention and direct claims management | ||
Our Verdict
Simply Shipping Protection is ideal for merchants who want to offer shipping protection to their customers but prefer to manage the entire process, from pricing to claims, in-house. They benefit from controlling the customer experience and retaining all protection revenue. It will appeal to larger merchants or those with a specific need for brand control. PostCo Returns & Exchanges seems designed for smaller merchants or those who prefer a more hands-off approach to returns and exchanges, where an external service manages the complexities. Without detailed feature information it is harder to offer specific advice but the description suggests the focus is on reducing administrative burden. If a merchant wants to handle every step of claims themselves, Simply Shipping Protection is the stronger choice.
Common Questions
Which app lets me keep the revenue from shipping protection?
Simply Shipping Protection allows you to keep the full revenue from shipping protection fees. PostCo Returns & Exchanges does not offer this feature.
Which app is best for automating the return process?
Based on its name, PostCo Returns & Exchanges is likely more focused on automating and streamlining the returns and exchange process itself, although detailed features are not described.
Which app gives me the most control over claims management?
Simply Shipping Protection gives you complete control over claims management. You can handle claims directly from the app and settle them with refunds, reorders, or store credit.
Which app has more reviews?
Simply Shipping Protection has more reviews (127) than PostCo Returns & Exchanges (79).
Is there an app for managing shipping insurance?
Simply Shipping Protection is explicitly described as offering shipping protection, meaning the merchant is essentially self-insuring against shipping losses.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store