Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews vs Review Collect by Scalyfor Shopify (2026)
Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews and Review Collect by Scaly are both 5-star rated product review apps on the Shopify app store. However, Rapid Reviews seems to be positioning itself as a more comprehensive and technologically advanced solution, emphasizing speed, deep search, and modern features like AMP email integration and AI assistance. Review Collect by Scaly, based on the limited information, appears to focus primarily on review collection and may lack some of the more advanced capabilities offered by Rapid Reviews. Rapid Reviews boasts a higher number of reviews (114) compared to Review Collect by Scaly (79), potentially indicating a larger user base and broader adoption, although both show positive sentiment. Rapid Reviews' strengths lie in its feature-rich approach, including Q&A, deep search with custom attributes, extensive language support (covering many European and Asian languages), and its focus on minimizing page load times. This makes it suitable for merchants who need a robust review system that can handle complex search scenarios and a multilingual customer base. The inclusion of features like auto-verified reviews and after-review discounts suggests a strong emphasis on driving review volume and authenticity. Review Collect by Scaly, lacking detailed feature descriptions, may cater to merchants looking for a simpler, more streamlined review collection process, where advanced features are less of a priority and ease of setup and basic functionality are more important.
At a Glance
Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews
114 reviews
Review Collect by Scaly
79 reviews
Detailed Overview
Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews
Lighting-fast product reviews, Q&A, with deep search, media, and review requests.
Key Features
- High-performance product reviews, with Q&A, will not harm page speed.
- Page speed benefits and ultra-fast rendering of star ratings.
- Deep search and filtering with custom attributes.
- Customizable review requests — leave reviews directly in Gmail and Yahoo inbox.
- Photo & video reviews. Auto-verified reviews. After-review discounts.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews5/5 Review Collect by Scaly5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 114 | 79 |
Reviews Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews114 Review Collect by Scaly79 | ||
| Language Support | Extensive (14 languages) | Unknown |
Language Support Rapid Reviews: Product ReviewsExtensive (14 languages) Review Collect by ScalyUnknown | ||
| Key Features | High-performance, Q&A, Deep Search, Photo & Video Reviews, AMP Email, AI helper, After-review Discounts | Review Collection |
Key Features Rapid Reviews: Product ReviewsHigh-performance, Q&A, Deep Search, Photo & Video Reviews, AMP Email, AI helper, After-review Discounts Review Collect by ScalyReview Collection | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants with complex product catalogs, multilingual customers, and focus on page speed optimization | Merchants seeking a simple, basic review collection solution |
Target Merchant Type Rapid Reviews: Product ReviewsMerchants with complex product catalogs, multilingual customers, and focus on page speed optimization Review Collect by ScalyMerchants seeking a simple, basic review collection solution | ||
| Ease of Use | Simple setup with theme app blocks | Likely simple, but details unknown |
Ease of Use Rapid Reviews: Product ReviewsSimple setup with theme app blocks Review Collect by ScalyLikely simple, but details unknown | ||
| Value Proposition | Robust review system with advanced features to enhance customer experience and drive conversions | Streamlined review collection for basic needs |
Value Proposition Rapid Reviews: Product ReviewsRobust review system with advanced features to enhance customer experience and drive conversions Review Collect by ScalyStreamlined review collection for basic needs | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants requiring a comprehensive review system with advanced features such as deep search, Q&A, photo and video reviews, multiple language support, and a focus on page speed optimization, Rapid Reviews: Product Reviews is the clear choice. Its AMP email technology and optional AI helper further enhance its appeal for those seeking a modern and efficient solution. However, merchants looking for a simple, straightforward review collection app without the bells and whistles might find Review Collect by Scaly a suitable option, assuming it offers a user-friendly interface and reliable performance. The larger number of reviews for Rapid Reviews suggests greater adoption and potentially a more mature and actively developed platform, making it a slightly safer choice overall for merchants who prioritize feature richness and a proven track record.
Common Questions
Which app is better for SEO?
Rapid Reviews is likely better for SEO due to its focus on page speed and deep search, which can help improve product discoverability. The Q&A feature may also contribute to long-tail keyword targeting. However, a direct comparison would depend on how both apps structure their review data for search engines.
Which app is easier to set up?
Rapid Reviews claims "Simple setup with theme app blocks", suggesting ease of use. Without more info, we can only assume Review Collect by Scaly is similarly easy to set up.
Which app is more suitable for a multilingual store?
Rapid Reviews is definitively more suitable for a multilingual store, offering support for 14 languages compared to the unknown language support of Review Collect by Scaly.
Does Review Collect by Scaly offer photo and video reviews?
Based on the provided information, it is not clear whether Review Collect by Scaly offers photo and video reviews. Rapid Reviews explicitly supports them.
Which app has better support for incentivizing reviews?
Rapid Reviews explicitly states it provides Customizable review requests with discounts and After-review discounts, indicating stronger support for incentivizing reviews. Information on Review Collect by Scaly's incentivization features is not available.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store