Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 Fix vs Shogun ‑ A/B Testingfor Shopify (2026)
Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 Fix and Shogun ‑ A/B Testing are both highly rated Shopify apps (5/5), but they address completely different needs within the site optimization category. Redirect Ninja focuses on SEO and site maintenance by automating redirect management at scale, targeting merchants with large or frequently changing product catalogs. It uses AI and wildcard rules to handle 404 errors and broken links, ensuring a smooth customer experience and preserving search engine ranking. Its strengths lie in its automation, scalability, and detailed analytics for redirect activity. Shogun ‑ A/B Testing, on the other hand, aims to improve conversion rates through rigorous A/B testing of various elements within a Shopify store, including pages, themes, prices, and templates. It is designed for merchants who want to optimize their store design, product offerings, and overall customer experience to maximize profits. Its key strengths are its ability to test across different store elements, segment audiences, and track key metrics like conversion rate. The ideal merchant for Shogun is one actively focused on CRO, experimenting with different designs and marketing strategies. While both fall under "Site Optimization," they tackle fundamentally different aspects. Redirect Ninja is about technical SEO and preventing lost traffic, whereas Shogun is about conversion rate optimization and increasing sales.
At a Glance
Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 Fix
33 reviews
Shogun ‑ A/B Testing
12 reviews
Detailed Overview
Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 Fix
Safely manage redirects at scale using AI-assisted automation, wildcard rules, & detailed analytics
Key Features
- Manage 301 SEO redirects at scale using AI-assisted automation & workflow
- Redirect entire URL patterns using wildcard rules for bulk redirect management
- Redirect entire URL patterns using wildcard rules for bulk redirect management
- Monitor broken links & 404 activity with realtime detection & redirect analytics
- Review ongoing redirect activity with summaries & insights for continued control
Shogun ‑ A/B Testing
Maximize Profits with Smarter A/B Testing: Themes, Templates, Pages, Prices and More.
Key Features
- Page and Template Tests – Create variants for important pages and templates
- Theme Testing – Run storewide tests to optimize branding, UX and site flows
- Price Testing- Test different product prices to optimize your revenue and profit
- Audience Segmentation – Segment based on location, customer behavior and more
- Goals & Analytics – Set goals for key metrics like conversion rate
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 Fix5/5 Shogun ‑ A/B Testing5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 33 | 12 |
Reviews Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 Fix33 Shogun ‑ A/B Testing12 | ||
| Primary Function | Automated Redirect Management | A/B Testing & Conversion Optimization |
Primary Function Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 FixAutomated Redirect Management Shogun ‑ A/B TestingA/B Testing & Conversion Optimization | ||
| Target Merchant | Stores with Large/Changing Catalogs; SEO Focused | Merchants Focused on CRO & Experimentation |
Target Merchant Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 FixStores with Large/Changing Catalogs; SEO Focused Shogun ‑ A/B TestingMerchants Focused on CRO & Experimentation | ||
| Key Technology | AI-Assisted Automation, Wildcard Rules | Shopify's Native Editor, Audience Segmentation |
Key Technology Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 FixAI-Assisted Automation, Wildcard Rules Shogun ‑ A/B TestingShopify's Native Editor, Audience Segmentation | ||
| Main Benefit | Maintains SEO & Prevents Lost Traffic | Maximizes Profits Through Data-Driven Optimization |
Main Benefit Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 FixMaintains SEO & Prevents Lost Traffic Shogun ‑ A/B TestingMaximizes Profits Through Data-Driven Optimization | ||
| Ease of Use (Inferred) | Requires some SEO/Technical knowledge for setup | Potentially easier integration with Shopify's editor |
Ease of Use (Inferred) Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 FixRequires some SEO/Technical knowledge for setup Shogun ‑ A/B TestingPotentially easier integration with Shopify's editor | ||
| Value Proposition | Safeguards existing traffic and SEO ranking | Increases revenue and conversion rates |
Value Proposition Redirect Ninja ‑ AI 404 FixSafeguards existing traffic and SEO ranking Shogun ‑ A/B TestingIncreases revenue and conversion rates | ||
Our Verdict
The choice between Redirect Ninja and Shogun depends entirely on the merchant's priorities. If a store struggles with broken links, frequent product changes, and needs to maintain or improve its SEO ranking, Redirect Ninja is the clear choice. Its AI-assisted automation and wildcard rules make it a powerful tool for managing redirects at scale. On the other hand, if the primary goal is to increase sales and conversion rates by optimizing the store's design and user experience through experimentation, Shogun ‑ A/B Testing is the better option. Its ability to test different elements of the store and segment audiences provides valuable insights for improving performance.
In essence, Redirect Ninja is a technical SEO tool, while Shogun is a conversion rate optimization tool. For merchants with a strong existing SEO presence and stable product catalog, Shogun might be more valuable. For merchants undergoing frequent changes, migrations, or those with a large catalog and SEO issues, Redirect Ninja is critical.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Based on the descriptions, Shogun ‑ A/B Testing may be easier to set up initially, leveraging Shopify's native editor. Redirect Ninja, with its AI automation and wildcard rules, likely requires some understanding of SEO principles and URL structures to configure effectively.
Can I use both apps at the same time?
Yes, Redirect Ninja and Shogun address different needs and can be used concurrently. Redirect Ninja ensures a smooth customer experience by managing redirects, while Shogun optimizes the store for higher conversion rates. They don't directly compete with each other.
Which app is better for a new Shopify store?
For a brand-new store, Shogun ‑ A/B Testing might be more immediately beneficial. Optimizing for conversions early on can help establish a strong foundation. However, as the store grows and experiences catalog changes, Redirect Ninja becomes increasingly important for maintaining SEO and preventing lost traffic.
Does Redirect Ninja impact page load speed?
The description doesn't explicitly mention page load speed. However, poorly implemented redirects can negatively impact page load times. Redirect Ninja's "realtime link detection" suggests it may prioritize speed, but it's crucial to monitor performance after implementation.
Does Shogun offer integrations with other marketing tools?
The provided description does not mention specific integrations with other marketing tools. Further research would be required to determine Shogun's integration capabilities.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store