Review Collect by Scaly vs ReviewsYard — Product Reviewsfor Shopify (2026)
Both Review Collect by Scaly and ReviewsYard — Product Reviews are highly rated (5/5) Shopify apps designed to help merchants gather and display product reviews. ReviewsYard, with 197 reviews, has a significantly larger user base than Review Collect by Scaly (79 reviews), suggesting wider adoption and potentially a longer track record in the market. ReviewsYard positions itself as a fully automated solution, emphasizing features like automatically requesting reviews via in-email forms and scheduling review request emails. This makes it potentially more appealing to merchants seeking a hands-off approach to review collection. While Review Collect's specific feature set is unknown based on the provided data, ReviewsYard's description highlights automated email sequences, incentive programs (discounts), and import capabilities, indicating a more comprehensive feature set aimed at maximizing review volume and user-generated content (UGC).
At a Glance
Review Collect by Scaly
79 reviews
ReviewsYard — Product Reviews
197 reviews
Detailed Overview
ReviewsYard — Product Reviews
Collect products reviews from your happy customers.
Key Features
- Elegantly display your customer reviews on your store
- Automatically request reviews from your customers after purchase
- Schedule products review request emails
- Send incentives and discounts to your customers for leaving a review
- Import your existing reviews & UGC in minutes
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Review Collect by Scaly5/5 ReviewsYard — Product Reviews5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 79 | 197 |
Reviews Review Collect by Scaly79 ReviewsYard — Product Reviews197 | ||
| Automation | Unknown | Automated review request emails, scheduled sending |
Automation Review Collect by ScalyUnknown ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsAutomated review request emails, scheduled sending | ||
| Incentives | Unknown | Sends incentives (discounts) for leaving reviews |
Incentives Review Collect by ScalyUnknown ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsSends incentives (discounts) for leaving reviews | ||
| Review Display | Unknown | Elegantly displays reviews on store |
Review Display Review Collect by ScalyUnknown ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsElegantly displays reviews on store | ||
| Review Import | Unknown | Imports existing reviews and UGC |
Review Import Review Collect by ScalyUnknown ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsImports existing reviews and UGC | ||
| Target Merchant | Unknown | Merchants seeking automated, comprehensive review collection |
Target Merchant Review Collect by ScalyUnknown ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsMerchants seeking automated, comprehensive review collection | ||
| Ease of Use | Unknown | Potentially easier due to automation features |
Ease of Use Review Collect by ScalyUnknown ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsPotentially easier due to automation features | ||
| Value Proposition | Potentially strong review collection based on high rating | Comprehensive review management and automation features |
Value Proposition Review Collect by ScalyPotentially strong review collection based on high rating ReviewsYard — Product ReviewsComprehensive review management and automation features | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing a hands-off, automated approach to review collection and management, ReviewsYard — Product Reviews appears to be the stronger choice. Its features like automated email sequences, incentive programs, and review import capabilities offer a more comprehensive solution for maximizing review volume and leveraging user-generated content. However, merchants with simpler needs or those seeking a potentially more lightweight app might consider Review Collect by Scaly, though further research would be required to understand its specific feature set and capabilities. The higher review count of ReviewsYard suggests a more mature and potentially more reliable platform.
Common Questions
Which app has more users?
ReviewsYard — Product Reviews has significantly more users based on its 197 reviews compared to Review Collect by Scaly's 79 reviews.
Which app offers automated review requests?
ReviewsYard — Product Reviews specifically highlights its automated review request feature through in-email forms and scheduled emails.
Does either app offer incentives for leaving reviews?
ReviewsYard — Product Reviews explicitly states it allows sending incentives, such as discounts, to customers for leaving reviews. Review Collect by Scaly's feature set is unknown.
Can I import existing reviews with either app?
ReviewsYard — Product Reviews offers the ability to import existing reviews and user-generated content. Review Collect by Scaly's import capabilities are unknown.
Which app is easier to use?
Without using the apps, it's difficult to determine definitively. However, ReviewsYard's emphasis on automation suggests it aims to simplify the review collection process for merchants.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store